On April 22, 2004, Pat Tillman was shot and killed in a mountain pass in Afghanistan. The initial reports said that Tillman — the Arizona Cardinals defensive safety who left the NFL and enlisted in the Army after the attacks of 9-11 — had died while valiantly defending his fellow Rangers when they were caught in a Taliban ambush. It was a tragic story, and a great one.
Only problem: It wasn’t true.
Five weeks later, the Army announced that Tillman had been killed by U.S. gunfire, a terrible mistake attributed to “the fog of war.” But the spokesmen stuck to their story about the ambush, and the football star’s valor in the heat of battle.
That, it turns out, wasn’t true either.
Caught in the middle of the conflations and contradictions were the surviving members of Tillman’s family: his mother, Mary “Dannie” Tillman; his two brothers, Kevin and Richard; his widow, Marie; and his father, Patrick Tillman Sr. They could easily have accepted the Army’s version of events — after all, it painted their fallen loved one as a patriot, a hero.
But, as Amir Bar-Lev’s wrenching documentary, “The Tillman Story,” reveals, the family was not ready to accept easy lies. Nor were they willing to let Pat become a symbol in a propaganda campaign. They insisted on finding out what really happened. And they defied the Pentagon, the White House and Congress in their efforts to uncover the truth.
“There’s something that we do — the media, the public — to a family in the role that the Tillmans were in that takes away their dignity,” says Bar-Lev. “They can be used as a kind of prop for the pageantry that we wanted to put on to celebrate Pat Tillman’s sacrifice. ... But the Tillmans have hung onto their dignity. That’s one of the most noble things about this family, is that they’ve resisted that. They’ve tried to seize control of their son’s story, their husband’s story, their brother’s story.”
Narrated by Josh Brolin, “The Tillman Story” offers a powerful portrait of a fiercely independent-minded clan, and an equally powerful condemnation of military and government institutions playing fast and loose with the facts. Bar-Lev’s 2007 documentary “My Kid Could Paint That” similarly explored issues of truth: Did a 4-year-old girl really paint these abstract artworks selling for five and six figures in New York galleries?
But the issue assumes far greater weight in “The Tillman Story,” and no one — not the generals, not the Bush administration, not the television and print news outlets that “reported” the story about Tillman’s heroic sacrifice in combat — comes away unsullied. In fact, though there’s plenty of culpability to go around, the news media come off as particularly complicit — and irresponsible — in their coverage of the Tillman affair.
“To me, it’s really the heart of the issue. The reason that these handful of liars in the last administration were able to deceive the American people is because their deception touched a nerve,” says Bar-Lev, who incorporates footage from the “rescue” of Jessica Lynch — the Army private in Iraq who was hailed as a hero, but subsequently accused the government of embellishing her story as part of a concerted propaganda effort — into “The Tillman Story.”
“Jessica Lynch and Pat Tillman were characters derived straight out of our movie mythology,” Bar-Lev says. “And everybody gets off, basically, when it seems as though the movies have come to life.
“And the press knows that. ... They know they can sell many, many bottles of shampoo. In other words, it’s good for their advertising, it’s good for their ratings. It’s like mice and cocaine.”
Bar-Lev wants to make it clear that “The Tillman Story” is not a political film. What happened under the Bush administration with Tillman and Lynch — the hagiography, the rewriting of history — has happened down through the ages.
Yes, lefty doc-meister Michael Moore hailed Bar-Lev’s film when it premiered at Sundance in January. “But a few hours later somebody came up to me and said, ‘Well, I’m an American exceptionalist and an ardent pro-military conservative and I thought your film was amazing,’” Bar-Lev reports.
“Obviously, there are people in some quarters who are angry about (the film), but it’s an interesting debate to have. ... The soldiers and the veterans who have seen the film have very much responded to it and have felt it to be accurate.
“I look forward to a real debate with those people who accuse the film of being anti-military. I don’t see it that way.
“To me, this is a story, really, about publicists behind the scenes. Yes, publicists. And the question for people who are antiwar or pro-war is, do you want publicists running our wars, or do you want soldiers and generals running our wars?
“This is the worst example of using soldiers, and even using generals, for political photo ops.”
// Short Ends and Leader
"This featherweight, all-star WWII fundraiser looks great in its new Blu-ray edition.READ the article