Call for Book Reviewers and Bloggers

Film

A Mass of Neuroses

Bookmark and Share
Text:AAA

The marked difference in Marcotte’s approach and tone from other adaptations of “A Country Doctor” is immediately noticeable. Some of the better radio adaptations of literary works appeared on the series The Black Mass, which began in 1963 (long after radio drama was functionally “dead”), and its version of Kafka’s “A Country Doctor” was broadcast on 14 August 1964.


Part of The Black Mass’ strength in adaptation was its determined reliance on its source text: rather than aim for standard dramatisation, the shows were instead mildly-dramatised readings (a highly underappreciated artform). Such an approach may seem uncreative, but in fact places an additional (and highly desirable) emphasis on the links between interpretation and performance rather than potentially clumsy transposition to an entirely new narrative form.


As Black Mass producers John Whiting and Erik Bauersfeld agreed of their sources, “the text was sacred: no story was to be altered in plot, in substance, or in diction. We were convinced that “too close to the original” was a compliment, not a criticism” (“Black Mass”, My-KPFA). This careful adherence to the text (beyond the simple literalism that passes for “authenticity” in many popular adaptations) produced some highly effective and powerful works of radio drama, but “A Country Doctor” is one of the rare misfires.


In presenting Kafka’s world of enclosure and confinement, the Country Doctor himself emerges almost immediately as an addled, confused, and powerless man, blathering about the world around him and already trapped in its nightmares before they’ve fully emerged to the listener. The effect is by no means a failure, but it reduces the text to something of a monotonous whine rather than the troubled glimpses into a human condition struggling actively with life’s constant progression as an unyielding nightmare. As hinted at above in Welles’s complaint of character expectations, the Country Doctor is a mass of neuroses with no confounding element of authentic humanity peeking through.


The Black Mass’ “A Country Doctor” and its other excellent adaptations can be downloaded here: KPFA History.info.


A more recent adaptation was produced by the Seeing Ear Theater starring Mark Hamill as the Country Doctor. Hamill’s Doctor is nowhere near as jittery as the Doctor in The Black Mass, but seems entirely lackadaisical throughout the strange nightmare ordeal, seemingly bored rather than devoured by the nightmare world that emerges around him, almost as though the actor and producers were afraid to offer any dramatic interpretation of Kafka’s weird events.


(audio only)

The Country Doctor is perhaps slightly less feeble and and more engaged in the 2007 enjoyable (if that’s the right word) anime adaptation by Kōji Yamamura, Kafuka: Inaka Isha, with a hint of confidence and humour slipping through before he’s sucked into his atemporal nightmare. It’s another strong (faithful) adaptation, although once again its lead is marked with an internal passivity that somehow negates the enforced passivity that Kafka’s story thrusts on the Doctor from the outside. As with the two radio adaptations, the text is recreated faithfully, but almost too faithfully, stifling any real bursts of adaptive insight and instead drawing heavily on well-worn “spooky signifiers” like creepy music, sound effects and low ominous drones.




Combining Kafka and noir in The Sickroom in fact allows Marcotte to maintain the sense of powerlessness and enclosure that Kafka presents without stripping his title character of all traces of active decision. As with all the best noir heroes, just because they think they’re driving, it doesn’t mean that they’re actually in control. Another affinity with noir is the fact that the characters,  though vaguely aware of their doom, still might feel that spark to struggle against their fate, even if only briefly and without direction. Welles turning Joseph K. into something of a defiant hero at the end of The Trial may not be true to Kafka’s miserable ending, but it nevertheless taps into the potential for defiance that bubbles away beneath moments in Kafka’s scenarios.


Similarly, noir offers a world where the narrative might be able to find some kind of stable resolution, but only after the hero has been forcibly and miserably expelled from it; it’s not that there isn’t a happy ending to be found, it’s just that he/she won’t be around to see it (the end of Kafka’s The Metamorphosis, for example, or the unnerving ending of “Before the Law”).




Marcotte’s Doctor rationalises as best he can in the face of the sudden fortuitous appearance of the car offered by the leering monochrome punk, forcing his way to decision even as the turns of the story take it out of his control (his young assistant fleeing and the punk leaping out to pursue him). Where other adaptations tend to dwell on establishing Kafka’s setup with heavy emphasis on the opening text and ominous visual or aural triggers, Marcotte races through this early sequence at breakneck pace, making tangible the entrapment faced by the Doctor as he is summoned from out of nowhere to perform his task as a “Doctor”, a title that he wields as a vague storybook title like “knight” (as with the “P.I.” of noir) rather than an actual medical practitioner. Where other adaptations linger on Kafka’s establishment of the scenario, Marcotte skilfully leaves us with the same partial, half-understood glimpses that the Doctor himself experiences.


Once he reaches the “sickroom”, Marcotte also has enough confidence to allow in a moment or two of humour, with the Doctor interrupting his monologue on professional focus with a dopey “huh?” as the young boy leans in to ask for death, followed by a wry observation on avoiding legal entanglements over what “might have been said”. Most “serious” adaptations emphasise the seriousness of their source, but only the best adaptations have the understanding to find an apt joke or two that somehow heighten, rather than diminish, the tough and tense mood.


Marcotte makes some changes to some of Kafka’s key images (the wound is on the leg rather than the side, and is directly stated to be symptomatic of a inner disease) but, as with the earlier changes, this streamlines rather than distorts its source. The smattering of blood over an image of the boy’s inner leg is an effective replacement for the wound, and perhaps hints slightly at the rape of the Doctor’s young (male in this version) assistant that we’re led to believe is taking place while the Doctor is away (Kafka’s text links the two with the “rose-red” wound on the boy, and “Rose” as the name of the young female assistant).


Where the other adaptation see the Doctor as somewhat uncertain and confronted by the boy’s oscillation between wanting to die and lamenting his fate, Orlando’s Doctor lets the tough guy dialogue hint at a past wealth of experience of death and suffering in similar “sickrooms”: “You know what your mistake is, my friend? You don’t have a wide enough view of the world. I’ve been in all of the sickrooms far and wide and let me tell you, you’re very well off comparatively. Done in a tight corner with two strokes of an axe as we used to say in my day”.


When questioned, he assures his patient that it’s “really how it is”: “take the word of honour of an official doctor”. Orlando places an extra emphasis on “doc-toh”, emphasising its strange Jedi-noir status (though the character earlier decries its deification) rather than its purely practical function (such as the dull “public health official” title offered by Hamill’s Doctor in this scene).


Through it all, this Doctor maintains some vestiges of self-awareness and control. Unlike the original and other adaptations, he is not challenged by anyone other than the dying boy (the most overt nightmarish and strange elements of Kafka’s text such as the stripping and singing are left out in Marcotte’s version). Even in this troubled and troubling interaction, the Doctor pushes his way through all objections to declare the boy lucky to not have a worse death (or a longer life?) in store for him.


This “two strokes of an axe” suggestion of the benefits of a quick death seems to be often problematic in its interpretation. According to Hand P. Guth’s “Symbol and Contextual Restraint: Kafka’s “Country Doctor”“, the original German refers to the boy’s wound being “done in a wedge-shaped cut”, which is translated as the less clear “tight corner”. Without the presence of an actual wound, the “done” in The Sickroom can only really refer to dying in general rather than the wound itself, essentially leaving us with the interpretation that the boy’s overall suffering will ultimately be lessened thanks to his young and relatively swift death. (Whether this is a valid emphasis or a misinterpretation can be left to Kafka scholars.)


It’s really only after this brusque exchange that the Doctor returns to his car and we have a moment to reflect as the tension dissipates. The powerlessness that he hurled almost defiantly at the dying young boy now seems an insurmountable burden. The Doctor now finds himself trapped in a slow vehicle “barely moving”, and only then truly thinks that of the “disgusting backseat man making a victim out of my assistant”, before collapsing into the necessary atemporal defeat: “I don’t want to think about it anymore”.


It’s through this counter-intuitive frantic noirish hard-boiled defiance that the story’s real sense of enclosure emerges, the frantic energy of the protagonist only a momentary diversion from the miserable and insurmountable fate of Kafka’s confined and controlling world. It’s a bold and energetic adaptation that has a confidence in its interpretation that is rarely captured by other faithful, but overly-cautious, adaptations and portrays a thoroughly convincing synchronicity between Kafka and film noir.

Kit MacFarlane has a PhD in English Literature, Film and Popular Culture, and teaches film and media as a freelance academic. He writes cultural criticism, commentary and relentless tirades, and has published regular cultural and higher education commentary in Australian media. He writes monthly-ish column Retro Remote at PopMatters. A full list of his writing can be found on his very ugly webpage. Why not follow him on Twitter? Off-the-clock, he shouts at the TV incessantly.


Retro Remote
2 Mar 2014
Grand "explanations" are simple, it's actions and decisions that are complex. Quantum Leap treated ordinary people's problems as the real matters of cosmic importance.
17 Dec 2013
Some TV shows just aren’t willing to launch themselves into Christmas joy without also considering the validity of the Grinch's perspective.
2 Oct 2013
Unassuming high school chemistry teacher faced with insurmountable medical expenses turns to manufacturing illegal drugs to make ends meet? Sorry Bryan Cranston, Angie Dickinson and William Shatner got there first.
29 Jul 2013
Man of Steel was more concerned with surly brooding than Superman's more endearing traits. I think we (and Superman) should lighten up.
Comments
Now on PopMatters
PM Picks
Announcements
Win a 15-CD Pack of Brazilian Music CDs from Six Degrees Records! in PopMatters Contests on LockerDome

© 1999-2014 PopMatters.com. All rights reserved.
PopMatters.com™ and PopMatters™ are trademarks
of PopMatters Media, Inc.

PopMatters is wholly independently owned and operated.