Being “moved” was a topic I chatted about with two women waiting in line with me to see the sub-par The Secret Life of Bees at this year’s Toronto International Film Festival. It seemed like everyone I talked to was eager to find a special film with which they could emotionally connect and actually feel something. This was a film that seemed tailor-made to realize those wishes, but it unfortunately did not deliver on the promise that was indicated by the trailers.
Let me first say that I desperately wanted to love this movie. I had been excited to see this adaptation of Sue Monk Kidd’s 2002 novel of the same name since I heard about the powerhouse casting of Queen Latifah, Sophie Okonedo and musician Alicia Keys in the key roles of the Boatwright sisters, and Oscar winner Jennifer Hudson tackling her first big dramatic part since scoring a statuette (no, Sex and the City doesn’t count). Films with predominantly African American female casts are almost anomalies, even in 2008. So the prospect of seeing so many authoritative, talented black women working together onscreen was virtually intoxicating for someone like me who lives for seeing quality roles for actresses. Add to this the fact that it was actually being made by a female director, Gina Prince-Blythewood (Love & Basketball), and it sounded like a dream come true.
With an abundance of feminine energy that centered on a uniquely successful family of all-girl entrepreneurs, educators and all-around pillars of their community in the South, this was a tale that hadn’t really been told before. With the divergent perspectives of the sisters, the Black Mary’s dominance in this Gospel as universal mothering figure, and the powerful symbolism of the queen bee, this project seemed a slam dunk. Sadly, the finished product is more of a muddled, neutered story that was stripped of its feminist overtones and watered down for mass consumption. What could have been a brave film turned out lukewarm, lost in its own self-importance, struggling to find a filmic identity.
Unfortunately, one could count on two hands the number of movies made in the last 20 years that exclusively celebrate the full experience of African American women, with predominantly black casts and fewer still actually succeed artistically (Jonathan Demme’s Beloved and Kasi Lemmons’ Eve’s Bayou are two of them, in my book); a point that was driven home by the moderator Elvis Mitchell (host of TCM’s Under the Influence) during a special press conference with the entire cast and director.
This seems to be a ticket-buying audience that is both historically underrepresented and not courted properly by Hollywood, so it makes it extremely regrettable that Bees tries so hard to be winning, but falls so flat; mainly due to overly-sentimental direction, a scattered script with maybe one too many “big” ideas, and the fact that the material revolves around four capable, intelligent black female characters going out of their way to help, nurture and love a white runaway who complicates their lives in the most dire ways. There is still a long, long way to go until our great actresses of color get the kind of quality material they deserve, and they cannot be held to blame for this utter fiasco – each woman works wonders in their own special way with what they are given, yet when all roads lead back to Dakota (Fanning, the star), there are a few problematic red flags raised that kill any substance or magic that might have existed on the page – and all those little red flags are rather distracting.
The film begins with a four-year-old Lily watching her mother getting roughed up by her rube of a father as she is furiously trying to leave. The vantage point is from the closet, where Lily is hidden. Her mother grabs a gun, which slides over to the child. She picks it up and fires, accidentally killing her mother with a single shot. In the next scene, which starts out promising enough, the wan, depressed Lily is a 14-year-old who sees swarms of imaginary bees in her room. Deluded, she likens herself to the Virgin Mary with a far away look in her eyes as an inane voice-over lets us hear her inner monologue which obsesses over, you got it, bees.
The year is 1964 and Lyndon Johnson is on the television talking about the Civil Rights Act and urging African American citizens to vote, which pleases Lily’s caretaker/maid/friend Rosaleen (Hudson, who is officially cornering the market on playing into a modern mammy stereotype after this). Lily’s nasty, greasy father T. Ray (a hammy Paul Bettany) refuses to talk about her mother at all, and gets violent when Lily asks to hear a story about her for her birthday present.
Late at night, she sneaks out to uncover a box of her mother’s belongings that she has buried in a peach orchard, so her father won’t find out, and talks to the dead woman. On this particular night, her father discovers her, and surmises that the girl has been promiscuous. As punishment, she is forced to kneel in grits on the kitchen floor and is deemed a whore.
Rosaleen, for her birthday, has prepared a cake and a visit to town to buy Lily her first bra, or so she tells Lily’s father: the real reason is so she can register to vote. In one of the film’s more daring scenes, Rosaleen is harassed, beaten and eventually arrested by rednecks that provoke her by calling her “nigger”. The audacious scene is very well-played by a commanding Hudson, who summons a furious anger with ease that absolutely cements her dramatic promise. The versatile performer called her research on the period and her character “terrifying. I wanted to go as deep as I possibly could and it didn’t take that much work to find her.” She pointed out that had she been alive during this time, this would have likely been her reality.
Lily comes running to the hospital, where Rosaleen lays tied up, waiting to be taken to jail (or worse); badly injured after being savagely beaten. The two take to the road, which is where the real story begins. They wind up at the “Caribbean Pink”, stately home of August Boatwright, a sweet, generous purveyor of “Black Madonna” honey, mostly on a whim of Lily’s after she spots a jar in a store window. Her sisters, June and May (Keys and Okonedo—yes, they are all named after months) have their trepidations, but August insists on letting the ladies sleep on the property and work for their room and board.
Amidst terrible, inappropriate music by contemporary adult lite-FM singers, which is complete baloney for a film about the experiences of black women in the 60s, heavy-handed (though well-intentioned) speeches about propriety, tolerance, and love are handed out in such rapid-fire, saccharine succession that viewers might actually be in danger of their teeth rotting. That the material, on paper, is so rich and thematically complex makes the dumbing-down even worse as it could have been a magnificent film.
Predictably, Lily becomes infatuated with The Boatwright’s employee Zack (Tristan Wilds), which brings us to the first of many clichéd scenes of dripping honey – this first one sadly, disgustingly features these two characters goofing around while bottling honey, and as it drips over the rims of the jars (because they aren’t really paying attention to what they’re doing), they giggly lick it from their fingers while staring oddly at one another.
It’s a really uncomfortable, poorly edited, oddly-sexualized moment for everyone involved. And yes, there is, I’m sorry to report, more than one scene of honey being licked off of fingers. The audience I saw the film with snickered, jeered, laughed out loud and were even talking on their phones during most of this rubbish.
The single saving grace of the film comes in the form of the performances by Hudson, Keys, Latifah, and Okonedo. Each woman gives a singularly capable performance, but in no way does this excuse the actual quality of the film overall, nor does it validate the film’s seeming wish to be ultra-important and its attempts to tie itself intrinsically to the current political landscape. If anything the game performances show off the glaring flaws even more.
“What most attracted me to it was the amount of love,” said the appropriately regal Queen Latifah. Latifah is a formidable player, no matter what medium she is working in. She’s adept at comedy, she can do drama (check her out in HBO’s Life Support if you want to be blown away), and she can even act while singing (1998’s underrated Living Out Loud). “She only has to go to places of love; she doesn’t have to stretch that far. I could live inside August for a few months and feel comfortable. And these were my sisters on and off set. And I was fascinated by how bees serve the queen.”
Here, she plays the family matriarch to the best of her abilities, but is let down by the weak directorial vision and a script that doesn’t really do anything other than hint at her past of being, you guessed it, a “nanny”. There is a scene where August explains the myth of the Black Madonna to Lily and Rosaleen that had so much dramatic potential that was killed by being far too overwrought. It’s puzzling that the director would settle for such mediocrity in a scene that calls for pathos.
We all know how critical it is to keep independent voices alive and strong on the Internet. Please consider a donation to support our work as independent cultural critics and historians. Your donation will help PopMatters stay viable through these changing and challenging times where costs have risen and advertising has dropped precipitously. We need your help to keep PopMatters strong and growing. Thank you.
"PopMatters (est. 1999) is a respected source for smart long-form reading on a wide range of topics in culture. PopMatters serves as…READ the article