Giving a pop icon the respect she's due
Nancy Sinatra is one of the most important and influential musicians in rock history, but she has never gotten the respect she deserves.
The reasons for this are complex and reveal much about the times in which she emerged. Sinatra made her greatest impact on the charts during the late sixties. She had more than 20 charting hits between 1965 and 1972, a time when the role of women in society was going through some serious changes. Sinatra helped transform the image of women in popular song from the waif who pines for her true love to the tough gal who demands respect and attention.
Unlike Aretha Franklin, Joan Baez, and her more serious peers, Sinatra declared her independence with a smile and a hook (or maybe a whip would be more accurate). While she’s best known for her 1966 number one hit “These Boots Are Made For Walkin’,” Sinatra continued to develop her go-go boot persona on a number of other chart songs.
But Sinatra was no one-trick pony. She enjoyed other big successes and explored other types of music, from the romantic duet with her father “Somethin’ Stupid,” to the jazzy James Bond theme “You Only Live Twice,” to the sultry “Sugar Town.” Sinatra’s sound was impossible to classify. While one could label Franklin as a “soul” artist and Baez as a “folk” musician and the other leading distaff artists of the day as one kind of singer or another, Sinatra embraced the wide range of pop music genres blossoming during this period.
This is something that’s best evidenced by her new album Cherry Smiles: The Rare Singles, a collection of obscure 45 sides as a digital-only release. The wonderful 14-track anthology includes a diverse selection of material that includes everything from covers of Neil Diamond’s “Glory Road,” Bill Withers’ “Ain’t No Sunshine,” and the Charley Pride hit “Is Anybody Goin’ to San Antone,” to more outrageous titles, like the song about a prostitute (as sung by the daughter), “Annabell of Mobile,” the Faulkneresque gothic of “Dolly & Hawkeye,” and the schmaltzy “She Played Piano and He Beat the Drums,” to the more esoteric, like the obscure duet with Lee Hazelwood “Indian Summer.”
Which brings us to Sinatra’s most extraordinary music: her remarkable collaborations with Lee Hazelwood. The contrast between her throaty and ethereal vocals with his low, leathery voice made them a memorable combination. Songs like “Summer Wine,” “Jackson,” “Lady Bird,” and “Some Velvet Morning” have become the touchstone by which other male/female duets are measured to this day.
Complicating matters was Sinatra’s good looks, especially in a bikini or a mini-skirt. One reason she was not taken seriously as a musician was because she flaunted her beauty. Because she was obviously well-endowed with attractive physical attributes, many thought Sinatra couldn’t be gifted musically. This type of sexism—can you imagine the same criticism of Jim Morrison?—was prevalent during Sinatra’s heyday. Sinatra’s image was featured in fashion magazines not to mention her iconographic album covers. In addition, she frequently appeared on television and in movies, including The Wild Angels with Peter Fonda and Speedway with Elvis Presley, so everyone knew what she looked like.
Plus, she was Frank’s daughter. Detractors presumed she succeeded only because she had access to the best songwriters, side-musicians, and producers of the time. Sinatra took advantage of these perks, but listening to her records reveals the depths of her talents. She knows how to inhabit and phrase a song. She delivers her lines with panache and an understanding of the material. She’s equal to, if not better than, many of the artists with whom she worked.
Sinatra gave up her career in 1972 to have children and raise a family. She made a few stabs at a comeback, including a duet album of country standards with Mel Tillis in the eighties, a return to rock album in the nineties (One More Time), and an eponymously titled Morrissey-produced disc in 2004 that featured such fan guest stars as Bono, Jarvis Cocker, Jim O’Rourke, and Thurston Moore.
Now with the release of Cherry Smiles, Sinatra seems very much at ease with her legacy. During our interview, Sinatra touched on everything from granting Jessica Simpson permission to cover her most iconic hit to expressing her wish to work with Paul Simon to reminding us all to treasure our time with the ones we love ...
What inspired you to put out Cherry Smiles? What made you decide to re-release the material now?
The truth is, I have a lot of good stuff that people haven’t heard for a whole bunch of reasons. For this first record, I was very specific. These tracks were singles that never found their way on albums. We discovered that we have enough stuff for two more CDs from cuts that never appeared as singles or on albums. I plan on calling them From the Vaults Volume I and II if I can get a label to release them.
I thought the singles were very eclectic. I put them together with an emphasis on the quality of the individual songs themselves rather than how they fit together as they came from different times, appeared on different labels, and had different players. One thing they share is that many tell a story.
I am a perfectionist. Many of the older songs had too much echo on them, which was the style back then, but doesn’t sound right now. We had to re-engineer some of them, like “Southern Lady,” to get rid of the layers and let the vocals breathe. It took years to get some of these songs to sound right.
“Southern Lady” is now one of my favorite cuts on the record. I like “Glory Road,” too. When Neil Diamond heard it he sent me a note that said, “You topped me,” which pleased me greatly. My least favorite track is “I’m Not a Girl Anymore,” not because of the lyric, although it has dated, but because it’s out of meter. That’s the classically trained musician in me talking.
Despite all the songs you have recorded over the years that found their way on to records or are in the vaults, are there any songs you wish you would have recorded but never gotten around to?
Too many, you know I started doing this stuff back in 1901. Okay, well in any case I’ve had almost a 50 year career. There’s a lot of songs I’ve done live that I never got around to doing in the studio.
One song that comes to mind is Kasey Chambers’ “Barricades and Brickwalls.” My fans loved it when I was touring. Kasey is one of the great young musicians out there, but there are too [many] great musicians and too many songs to name.
We all know how critical it is to keep independent voices alive and strong online. Please consider a donation to support our work as an independent publisher devoted to the arts and humanities. Your donation will help PopMatters stay viable through these changing and challenging times where advertising no longer covers our costs. We need your help to keep PopMatters publishing. Thank you.
// Notes from the Road
"Drive-By Truckers gave a sold out capacity crowd a powerful two hour set filled with scuzzy guitars and deeply political rock.READ the article