Created by Anthony Zuiker, the CSI series was first aired in the fall of 2000. Its continual appeal lies in its voyeuristic quality whereby we viewers, guided by scientific sleuths, enter a world that is normally closed off to us: the inside of the human body. The CSI team takes us on a “Fantastic Voyage” of sorts into the recesses of the body. Confronted with both the fragility and resilience of our human body, we watch, mesmerized. The trip into the internal world of a stranger is a valid ersatz truth that allows us to unveil the mysteries of our own bodies. This, coupled with a close look at the taboo of death, is simply irresistible.
Through the CSI scientists’ tools and eyes, we are able to watch from the comfort of our own home just how, why, and when people die. We have VIP passes to the behind-the-scenes world of forensic medicine and to the private lives—internal lives even—of people we will never have to face. This leaves us free to witness their private tragedies shamelessly and without fear of confrontation, because these people are not only dead, but also fictitious.
This legal voyeurism is not new of course. As Marshall McLuhan, the television studies pioneer has written in Understanding Media, ever since the advent of television, we have been given electronic eyes as extensions of our world and our reality. CSI takes this voyeurism one step further, however, as now we are not just watching people’s lives through a television show. Rather, we are part of a double voyeurism: we, the television viewers, get to watch a group of people, the CSI team, observe how other people live and die. Perhaps more importantly, for the duration of the show, we feel in control of that which frightens us most: death.
In CSI: Las Vegas, we see forensic experts as the ultimate voyeurs: the omniscient oracles, who, through their art, are able to dis-cover truth. These scientists hold in their hands the secret, not of life, but of death. They transcend the taboo of death and gain access to the deepest recesses of the human body and mind through their scientific tools. Forensic science has superhuman eyes that can penetrate all textures, all alibis with its technological gaze: the cold, metallic gaze of machines that can photograph, record, reconstruct, and dissect every moment, every action, every bodily function of and around the corpse it uses as its point of departure; its probing and digging into the flesh, as deep as the DNA, allows it to peek into the world behind the façade.
This is no small feat in Las Vegas. In a world where all is glitter and illusion, where bright lights blind us from everyday life and harsh reality, the CSI lab is our beacon of truth. We are brought down to earth, to the cold slab of metal which will hold the “body of evidence” reeking with decomposition, bleeding, broken, and exposed: an obscene pin-up for the graphic world of reality-based television. We are shown the body from all possible angles: allowed to peep at the insides and the reality of gore and guts, the animal humanity that we all try to ignore. Here voyeurism masquerades as truth.
That these scientists can find the truth in the city of artifice is a testimony to the power of science. In a world of desire and dreams, only cold, pragmatic science is capable to un-cover the truth. Under our hungry eyes, the CSI experts wrestle truth and reality from the artifice and dissembling of murder. They give us close ups of their thinking processes: frowning under the weight of their superhuman knowledge, they sometimes deign to show to us a glimpse into the working of their brains. Most often however, they deliver their truth, much like priests or magicians would, as a revelation.
Science As Religion
There are no limits to this voyeurism because it is sanctioned by modern society, which worships at the altar of science and technology. From the comfort of our living-rooms, we are allowed to transcend the taboo of death as we follow our guides inside the flesh and bones of our human condition. Nothing is sacred because, in this case, the god of science supersedes all else. The all-knowing, all-seeing forensic experts are the high priests of this technological religion. Through their scientific eyes, the television viewer is doubly a voyeur because the CSI team extends the viewer’s technological gaze from the contents of the television box to the insides of the body dissected within that box. We thus have the viewer’s voyeurism mediated by that of the priests of science who initiate us to the mysteries of the human body and give us access to the most private and personal parts of the victim’s body and life. We watch in awe as the team performs for us the reenactment of the crime.
This performance is a celebration of the power of omniscient science. The use of unusual camera angles, editing techniques, high-tech gadgets, graphic portrayals of bullet trajectories, blood spatter, and organ damage pulls us in. All this suffused in compelling music that makes the most tedious laboratory test fascinating. Much like performing an esoteric religious ritual, the CSI scientists command awe and reverence as they lead us through their methods of evidence recovery. At times, the scientists even use their tests as technological equivalents of a clairvoyant’s crystal ball in order to give us a glimpse into the minds of the victims and their murderers.
The autopsy table is the holy altar whence the oracles speak. On this altar of death, the CSI experts, by lifting the mortuary sheet, dis-cover not only the corpse in front of them but its whole history. No secret is safe with them: from the contents of your pockets to those of your stomach, there are no limits to the power of these scientists. They can raffle through your house, tear down your walls, peel back your skin and look inside your brain. They have free access to the most intimate parts of your body. They collect and analyze everything: including body fluids such as semen, blood, and vomit. They use technology to un-cover the deepest secrets not only of the victims but also of their killers. The dis-covering of the body is thus the dis-covering of evidence, which leads to the dis-covery of truth. To the average viewer, the powers of the CSI scientists seem to be not only superhuman, but at times almost magical.
We all know how critical it is to keep independent voices alive and strong online. Please consider a donation to support our work as an independent publisher devoted to the arts and humanities. Your donation will help PopMatters stay viable through these changing and challenging times where advertising no longer covers our costs. We need your help to keep PopMatters publishing. Thank you.