As much as any title, Call of Duty signals the ascent of the video game in economic terms. Gamers who have seen their hobby win new converts in recent years often still draw a distinction between the “casual” gamer and the hardcore, between the Wii-equipped grandma and the smartass teenager with fighter pilot reflexes. But Call of Duty’s dominance suggests that gaming’s transition into the mainstream is less about making video games safe for grandma and more about increasing the size of video gaming’s biggest tent—the one where you go to shoot bad guys in the face.
Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 sold 4.7 million copies in the first 24 hours after release, making it the most successful entertainment launch of all time. The next game in the series, Call of Duty: Black Ops, did even better, moving 5.6 million copies in the first day. By the end of 2010, sales of Black Ops had passed the billion dollar mark, and in 2011, it became the all-time best-selling video game in the United States. According to an article on gaming website IGN, there is now a copy of Black Ops in 1 out of every 8 American homes (“Call of Duty: Black Ops in 1 of 8 U.S. Households”, IGN, 14 March 2011).
As games take their place in more and more households, another debate has emerged around the question of whether or not games should be considered art. Gamers point to titles like Shadow of the Colossus and Heavy Rain as evidence that games deserve serious aesthetic consideration and as proof that the medium is evolving beyond its staple fare of killing things. But if we are to think of games like films or novels, then shouldn’t we also extend this appraisal to games that aren’t telegraphing how serious they are—especially when they’re as popular as Call of Duty? What are games like Call of Duty saying to us? What are they saying about us?
Some reticence here is understandable: gamers have spent years battling claims that video games brainwash innocent children into becoming sociopaths. It’s reasonable to think that games have no more special power here than films or television shows, but if old media forms can’t turn us into killing machines, they can still transform the way that we see the world. It’s almost impossible to think about organized crime, homicide investigation, or the Vietnam War without recalling the mass media that shaped our view of these subjects.
Call of Duty, especially in its latter-day Modern Warfare incarnations, offers an immersive moral theater that combines the right-wing symbolic register of the 1980s action movie with a post-9/11 paranoid style worthy of Alex Jones. Call of Duty presents a shadowy, bullet-riddled virtual reality where policy mistakes can be reversed with superior firepower, where the player can speak truth to power with bullets, and where the messy process of liberal democracy can be transcended by one well-placed commando willing to do whatever it takes to save the world. It is armed-forces-chic meets conspiracy backlash in an attractive, 60fps package. In Call of Duty, the WMDs are real, the villains may be the ones giving orders, and the clock is always ticking.
Call of Duty flourishes by restricting your options. The limited number of choices that you have in each in-game situation—e.g. shoot the terrorist in the face, or shoot him in the groin—underscores the broader goal of decisive action and forward momentum. Call of Duty is not about fussy negotiations, the sharing of feelings, or the deliberate weighing of multiple points of view. It’s about cutting through red tape, completing the mission, and taking care of business; clearing buildings, killing enemy combatants, and seizing objectives. Call of Duty is not UN negotiators patiently trying to neutralize Iran’s nuclear weapons program, it’s the Navy SEALS killing Osama bin Laden. It’s not Woodrow Wilson; it’s George W. Bush.
But Call of Duty is also a cautionary tale. It continually reminds us that, despite our eternal vigilance and unsurpassed military might (represented by the game’s satisfying snap-aim, where a group of enemies can be neutralized in a cycle of rapid shots simulating the effect of countless hours of elite combat training), terror still lies in wait ever ready to strike. No sooner have you saved the downed helicopter pilot in Call of Duty 4 (exorcising the ghosts of Mogadishu), then a nuclear weapon is detonated, nullifying your heroic efforts in a mushroom cloud. Your character lives just long enough to crawl through a windswept wasteland straight out of Terminator 2. Call of Duty thus fulfills the grim prophecy spelled out by Dick Cheney and undercut by the failure to find WMDs in Iraq: the smoking gun as mushroom cloud.
Modern Warfare 2 does one better by giving the player a front-row seat to a nightmarish terrorist attack on a Russian airport terminal, seemingly inspired by the 1972 attack on Lod Airport by members of the Japanese Red Army. As you walk with an eerily deliberate pace through the terminal, you confront a tableau of dying victims and carry-on luggage disintegrating under machine gun fire. The devil’s in the details: the sight of all of the flights on the arrivals/departures board switching over to “DELAYED” in a clattering red wave provides more chills than an entire library of survival horror games.
Attempting to untangle the labyrinthine plot of Modern Warfare 2 may be a fool’s errand, but there’s something provocative about the game’s heady stew of geopolitical ADD. The rough outline reads like the fever dream of a committee of 9/11 truthers: a vicious terrorist attack is blamed on an American undercover agent, precipitating World War 3—until a team of off-the-reservation commandos discover that the real villain is the high ranking American general who secretly engineered the incident and ensuing conflict in order to drum up hawkish patriotism and blind allegiance. The next game in the series, Call of Duty: Black Ops, takes these cloak-and-dagger themes even further, offering a postmodern pastiche of LBJ-era paranoia so deadpan that it’s almost kitschy, while also reminding you that there’s sometimes a thin line between the rogue agent and the lone nut.
The story of General Shepherd’s treachery in Modern Warfare 2 plays almost like a sop to the Oath Keepers, the right-wing group based on refusing to follow orders issued by the Obama administration that would terrorize American citizens or confiscate their firearms. At the same time, the game brings familiar survivalist fantasies to vivid life. We see America invaded by vengeful foreigners with the Cold War resumed as an army of faceless Russians lays siege to our strip malls and monuments. The player represents a one man army of liberation, saving America from the marauding invaders one headshot at a time.
Call of Duty thus fits neatly into a schema described by David Sirota in his recent book Back To Our Future. Taking our de rigeur ‘80s nostalgia as a starting point, Sirota argues that Pentagon-approved artifacts like Top Gun and Red Dawn taught us a very clear series of ideological lessons, which continue to dominate our public discourse to this day (Back to Our Future: How the 1980s Explain the World We Live in Now—Our Culture, Our Politics, Our Everything, Ballantine Books, 2011, p. 139-170). One of the most dominant themes in these parables is our fondness for system-bucking rogues, those rugged individualists who play by their own rules and transcend the gray and mundane reality of a world ruled by timid bureaucrats. Sirota’s rogueography reveals how pervasive the idea is in our culture; from Michael Jordan to Sarah Palin to Christopher Nolan’s Batman, the rogue archetype cuts deep. (Much like The Dark Knight, Modern Warfare 2 ultimately resolves into a triangular battle of rogue against rogue against rogue with Captain Price, General Shepherd, and Makarov standing in for Bats, Two-Face, and the Joker.)
We all know how critical it is to keep independent voices alive and strong on the Internet. Please consider a donation to support our work as independent cultural critics and historians. Your donation will help PopMatters stay viable through these changing and challenging times. Thanks everyone.