Tommy Walter is at a crossroads.
As a founding member of the band eels, Walter has had his foot in the music industry door for some time. Although he was a notable contributor to Eels’ successful debut Beautiful Freak in 1996 (buoyed by the iconic alternative single “Novocaine for the Soul”), Walter soon left the group to pursue his own muse. However, after stopping and starting various projects, he finally settled on his own solo venture, which he dubbed Abandoned Pools. Their 2001 record Humanistic became a notable minor hit in the alt-rock landscape, with dark songs like “The Remedy” and “Monster” showcasing Walter’s own thoroughly considered vision, cathartic and damning in equal measures. Of course, these songs, in their own way, also proved to be red herrings: while half of Humanistic relied on minor-key dirges and pummeling guitar choruses (which the then-moody rock landscape was ready to embrace), the other half of the album showcased Walter’s intensely well-honed pop instincts, capable of crafting gigantic hooks on which he could hang his ideas about love and romance.
The album became a cult-classic in its own way, and Walter wound up endearing himself to the geek-niche contingent all the more for performing the notable theme song to the short-lived but widely-beloved animated show Clone High, which had a brief run on MTV (and helped launch the careers of several Scrubs regulars as well as creators Phil Lord and Christopher Miller, who went on to direct such notable films as Cloudy With a Chance of Meatballs and 21 Jump Street). Cartoon triumphs notwithstanding, Walter had a much harder time with his second album, 2005’s Armed to the Teeth. Now signed to Universal, Walter took his sound deeper and darker, resulting in an album that was gritty, cathartic, and much more aggressive than anything he had done before. Although he was ready to go out and tour, Universal stopped promotion at a fairly early stage in the game, which led to Walter eventually leaving the label altogether and spend his newfound free time working on side-projects like Oliver the Penguin and Glacier Hiking.
Yet all of these events remain entirely surface-level: Walter’s own life was seeing its own profound changes outside of the public eye. Following the dissolution of a close relationship, Armed to the Teeth‘s tone—questioning, angry, fiery—was understandable. The album’s various political undertones, which went from questioning faith to taking a stand against the powers that be (which, in 2005, was a common occurrence), were hailed by the people that discovered the record on their own, fitting in well with the then-polarized political climate. Yet the seven year gap between Armed to the Teeth and this year’s electronica-inspired Sublime Currency showed Walter coming to terms with where his life was meant to go: while supporting himself by working on music for films and television, he’s now married and has come to develop a healthy relationship with his Christian beliefs.
Sitting down with PopMatters, Walter was unafraid to discuss the problems he encountered with his label, what it means for his fans to discover that he is Christian, the joys to be found in his new album, and what it’s like navigating the half-truths of the L.A. social climate.
* * *
Leading up to the album’s release, how did you feel: relieved that the hard part is over with? Nervous about the reaction would be?
Mostly relieved because it’s a lot of work making a record. On this one in particular, I did 95% of it on my own; produced it and mixed it alone. It’s the first time I’ve mixed my own album. I’ve co-produced the previous two.
And mixing is where it all comes together.
Yeah, and I’m [a] somewhat experienced mixer, but I’m not some A-list guy. The thing is: you learn it as you got along and you want it to sound as good as your previous record, and you feel pretty good about it.
I’ve been following the blog posts and the various side-projects (like Oliver the Penguin) that you’ve had over the year, and in your own words, why did you want to bring back Abandoned Pools instead of staying with something like Glacier Hiking?
Well, I think it was more like [...] I always planned on bringing it back. I just kind of needed a break for a while because my experience with Armed to the Teeth with Universal was kind of disappointing, just ‘cause we made a record and they didn’t do a lot of promotion on it and I was ready to tour and get out there and do stuff and none of that came together. So I needed a little bit of a break and, like you said, I did a couple side projects and I’ve been doing some work in TV & commercials and that kind of stuff. Really, to be honest with you, what it comes down to is that you got to make a living. The music industry changed quite a bit even between now and my last album, and it became increasingly difficult to find deals and advances had really struck, so in a lot of ways I was just trying to make a living. And then once I got myself in a position where I was doing TV stuff, I was like, “Well, let’s start doing Abandoned Pools, too.” I knew I was going to bring it back—it was just a question of when. I mean, who knows what would have happened if [something] like Glacier Hiking had taken off? I’m kind of glad that they didn’t, because I do like being in this position where it’s my project and I really just have to worry about myself pretty much. So the way it panned out, I’m pretty happy.
Now one thing back to the record: I’ve listened to the album quite a bit, and while I don’t normally read press releases, there was a part of it that struck me, where it noted that your album was informed by both your recent marriage and your faith. Now the marriage part I could see come through, like all of “In Shadows”, the line “Honey I know we’ve seen bad weather / But what do you know, it’s already gone”, but hearing about your faith in all honesty, it kind of surprised me. There aren’t many allusions to it—possibly in “Marigolds”—but if you don’t mind talking about it, I was wondering if you could tell me how it informed your music and specifically this record.
As my A&R guy at Tooth & Nail said, “It’s not like [you’re] out there dropping J-Bombs for Jesus” or something. When people find out [that I’m Christian], I think they’re really surprised, especially compared to the last record, which was asking a lot of questions, and most people went “Yay, Tommy’s an atheist!” after hearing the second record. It’s all a part of a search, basically. When people find out [that I’m Christian], I think they get the wrong idea. Because the way a modern American Christian is perceived as is someone who’s obsessed with homosexuality and abortion, basically. So it’s not really me and what I want Christians to represent.
You do enough investigation into philosophy, and Christian theology and science, and it all just starts to become this wonderful picture to you. That, to me, is where my faith lies: that kind of awe and wonder of the world. You can find that in Christian theology—Christian theology is based on that, and people have lost that narrative and story throughout the years. And now, when people think about Christians, they think about people being judgmental and politically right-wing, and that’s not how it’s supposed to be. So that’s where I’m coming from.
So then would you say that your faith wasn’t as much a factor in Armed to the Teeth, especially with people saying “Yay, Tommy’s an atheist!” after listening to it?
Well—I think Armed to the Teeth was more [about] searching for answers but it came across like that. It was a really tough time and I was just asking a lot of really tough questions and I [was] almost being demanding in a certain way. Demanding for answers. Almost having an argument with God, in a way. I even hate putting it in those kinds of terms—putting it into words seems to make it come across kind of shallow. I think I was just having struggles over that.
I think Armed to the Teeth was just a much angrier expression of you: songs like “Renegade” were very gritty and biting, which is a sharp contrast to this record which is a lot more pop-oriented. While I think a lot of people viewed Armed to the Teeth as politically informed, I think there’s still some elements that come through on this record, but in subtle ways. Like when you mention the causalities of war not being the most obvious or apparent—there’s these slight political elements, but never as overt as on Armed to the Teeth.
I think that’s true. In some ways, Armed to the Teeth is a little bit preachy. It is, in a way, a little bit soapbox-y—but that’s where I was at the time. For this one, I’m in a bit of a better place and I can be a bit more eloquent on my views.
My favorite song on the new record is “Hype is the Enemy”, as it’s the most natural inclinations of your pop instincts. It sounds so commercial, but there’s those lyrics of “Hype is the enemy of everything that’s beautiful”—it seems very indicative of your time in dealing with Universal, so I was wondering if by chance you could expand a little bit upon those thoughts.
I’m glad you’re asking, ‘cause that’s kind of my mindset for the entire album. In this industry, in this town [L.A.], everything is so hyped up and so inflated that after awhile, nothing has any value and all the quiet, normal things have so much value because everything else is kind of a lie, you know? So that’s where I was coming from. It’s not as much specific to labels as it’s specific to certain personalities who, when if you listen to what they say—if you cut in half, that’s what the truth is. The truth gets lost when you hear people talk about themselves: “I’m doing this and doing that and blah blah blah,” and this person is kind of like, “That’s probably not true.” It terms into this arms race of who’s doing what with whom. If everyone would just stop that and just be real, there’s real value in that. There’s real beauty in the quieter, normal things, and the things that get lost in all that white noise are the things that I think have real value.
How do you feel your relationship with your fans has changed over the past seven years?
Well I’m just amazed they’re still around after that much time! What’s changed now is that because of Facebook and Twitter, there’s a much more direct connection. I don’t think I realized what kind of fanbase we had. I think after the second record I was a bit of a sad sack. I was like, “Oh, no one wants to hear my album, I’ll just go away,” but there are plenty of fans out there, and now hearing directly from them—I have a blog, a tumblr where people can ask questions—I don’t think I’d be doing it if it wasn’t for them. In that regard, the fans have been really supportive and it’s nice to see that they’re still around and they’re really anxious to hear the record, which is fantastic.
Looking back on everything you’ve done to now, what do you feel is the biggest regret in your career and, conversely, what do think has been your proudest accomplishment?
I think they are two sides of the same coin. The regret would be the fight with confidence: every time you start a new project, a new album, as even when I was starting the first record after leaving the Eels, I was all gung-ho: “Yeah, I’m gonna do this and make a record and feel good!” And then you start realizing what kind of mountain you’re going to climb, and I think you do that every time you do a new record. For me, the first regret is the confidence issue: I should have had more confidence in myself, and I feel like I’ve made good records and managed to make a living in the music industry. But at the time when you first start out doing that, you don’t know what you’re going to do, so I think that sometimes it really gets to me and my confidence will start to wane.
On the flip side, in terms of accomplishments, I’d have to say still maintaining a career after all those years even after all that adversity. Two sides of the same coin, really.
We all know how critical it is to keep independent voices alive and strong online. Please consider a donation to support our work as an independent publisher devoted to the arts and humanities. Your donation will help PopMatters stay viable through these changing and challenging times where advertising no longer covers our costs. We need your help to keep PopMatters publishing. Thank you.
// Sound Affects
"Natalie Hemby's Puxico is a standout debut from a songwriter who has been behind the scenes for over a decade.READ the article