|50|| TRASHCAN SINATRAS |
A record that’s sure to crest my top 10 for the decade, Weightlifting showcases all that makes this group great, not least of which is its unconventional conventionality. The band juxtaposes the tried-and-true (melody, harmony, guitars, strings, and piano) against lyrical and musical sensibilities that are not only divorced from contemporary expectations, but are very uniquely the product of these five Scottish, bookish, and musically sophisticated men. From the lilt of the lamenting “Got Carried Away” to the hypnotic refrain of the closing title cut (“You will feel a great weight lifting”), pensiveness and delicacy are the order of the day, even in up-tempo numbers. Every note is unpretentious but careful. These guys understand music’s power to impart a state of mind and soul, a way of being. They understand the importance of atmosphere to a song’s meaning. And they have the sensitivity to appreciate extreme subtleties of mood and texture, producing a dead-perfect match between music and words.
Michael Mikesell :. original PopMatters review | buy in the PopShop
|49|| !!! |
Louden Up Now (Touch and Go)
Imagine the never-ending party in heaven. John Belushi would be parading around in his toga using an ancient Mayan pipe he stole from the dean’s office as a bong. Scantily clad women would be wrestling in children’s inflatable pools filled with KY Jelly. The crusty old dean would try to stop the fun, but would be quickly thwarted by Andrew W.K. and the cast of Jackass, who push the cantankerous dictator down a 10-mile slip’n'slide. NY octet !!!, and their own brand of carefree, danceable rock succeed where a more pretentious band would fail. With great sing-a-long refrains such as “Like I give a fuck!” and “Shit Schiesse Merde!” its near-flawless brainless disco-punk that is suited for only the craziest of parties. If you don’t find yourself swinging your hips during the epic “Me and Giuliani down by the Schoolyard”, you’re probably a nark anyway.
Erik Leijon :. original PopMatters review | buy in the PopShop
When I first heard NYC chamber-funk octet !!!‘s highly-anticipated sophomore album, I’ll admit I was puzzled. A seeming 53-minute regurgitation of the infectious quirks of their dance-floor hit “Me and Guiliani Down by the Schoolyard”, Louden Up Now initially projected a frustrating illusion of monotonous excess. But between the manic horn bursts, free-funk axe jabs, eurhythmic bass thumps, and vocalist Nic Offer’s hyper-masculine, tongue-in-cheek swagger, notions of indulgence and overstatement ultimately gave way to a single, primal urge: to shake my butt faster than you could say “cowbell”. While their peers—so confined within the single format—emulated Gang of Four, !!! crafted a cohesive album combining the white Africana of the Talking Heads with the cocksure tightness of The Fall. But wasn’t 2004 the death knoll for disco-punk? “Like I give a shit?”
Jon Fischer :. original PopMatters review | buy in the PopShop
|48|| WILLIAM SHATNER |
Has Been (Shout! Factory)
This is no joke. That’s what makes Has Been one of the biggest surprises since Haydn. Shatner’s beat poetry take on “Lucy in the Sky With Diamonds” and “Rocket Man” have become camp comedy classics, to the point that Shatner himself embraced his own legend as a caricature, turning himself into a cottage industry of self-parody. So expectations were high that his reunion with Ben Folds—following their work together on Folds’s Fear of Pop side-project—would be funny. And it is. What’s startling is how incredibly human it is as well. Shatner confronts his own image (both self-image and the image the public holds of him) in such naked honesty that Has Been feels more like a confessional to expunge years of pent up feelings than an album, much less a joke. Taken individually, “I Can’t Get Behind That” (his duet with Henry Rollins), or “You’ll Have Time”, or the Nick Hornby-penned “That’s Me Trying”, or the brilliant cover of Pulp’s “Common People” are all good songs. But when they’re wrapped up with brutally honest and personal tracks like “It Hasn’t Happened Yet” and “What Have You Done”, the sum becomes more than its parts in ways that are captivating. Shatner has indicated that he hoped Has Been would be something of a musical portrait, a way to share his feelings with those he loves or love him. He succeeds, and forces a re-evaluation of the man we think we’ve known all this time.
Patrick Schabe :. original PopMatters review | buy in the PopShop
Perhaps the most telling indicator of just how surprisingly successful Has Been has, uh, been for William Shatner: Geffen has re-released his other album, the classic debacle The Transformed Man, even after it sold a mere 8,000 copies in the 10-year period of 1991-2001. How is Has Been, where Shatner covers Pulp’s “Common People” any different from that 1968 mess where he covers The Beatles’ “Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds”? This time, he’s in on the joke. With plenty of help from the likes of Ben Folds, Joe Jackson, Aimee Mann, Brad Paisley, and, God help us, Henry Rollins, Shatner combines self-deprecating humor with some honest-to-goodness legit poetry. He manages to tread the line separating dead serious and seriously absurd with the skill and wisdom that can only come with age.
Mike Schiller :. original PopMatters review | buy in the PopShop
|47|| EINSTÜRZENDE NEUBAUTEN |
Perpetuum Mobile (Mute)
At a period when most of their peers from the first-generation of industrial music are compiling massive retrospective box-sets, Einstürzende Neubauten are producing some of the best music of their career. The initial punk energy which originally inspired them to bang on bits of scrap metal for percussive effect back in the late ‘70s has subsided into a more sophisticated appreciation for the melodic possibilities of strange percussion. Their songwriting acumen has certainly kept pace with their instrumental prowess, and their ability to conjure moods simultaneously epic and intimate while maintaining a uniquely Teutonic sense of melancholy is simply breathtaking. They are, without a doubt, the greatest German-speaking band in the world today—their only rivals for the crown being the infinitely mordant Rammstein. Suffice it to say that singer/lead songwriter Blixa Bargeld’s decision to step away from his part-time position as lead guitarist for Nick Cave’s Bad Seeds has yielded rich profits for his primary group.
Tim O’Neil :. original PopMatters review | buy in the PopShop
|46|| THE MOUNTAIN GOATS |
We Shall All Be Healed (4AD)
As enigmatic as John Darnielle’s literary folk-pop songs can be, after listening to them you often feel like you’ve been given a glimpse of the lives of real, often quite tortured people. That’s as true here as ever - The Mountain Goats’ second album for 4AD is their most sonically polished, but that sheen has somehow intensified the emotions and brought a brighter spotlight onto Darnielle’s sense for detail. We Shall All Be Healed is an indelible portrait of misfits living in a house full of rats, sharing problems, longings, addictions. It truly gets under your skin, and speaks to truths about the world through small stories and images. It’s a grand songwriting achievement, where each note and word is helping build something remarkable.
Dave Heaton :. original PopMatters review | buy in the PopShop
|45|| PJ HARVEY |
Uh Huh Her (Island)
“Uh Huh Her” isn’t as pugnacious as its cover shot of PJ Harvey seemingly pressing her de-glamorized face against the CD case and into the listener’s personal space (“You want a piece of this? Huh?!” Personally speaking, I wouldn’t bet against her); it’s more so. Allegedly conceived solely on a four-track, the record’s highs are as strong as anything Harvey’s done in her career—“Who the Fuck” alone saturates the record in more vitriol than her entire catalog combined. But what’s most pleasing about the record is the strange desert beauty about it. Lovelorn song-fragments like “The Pocket Knife” and “The Desperate Kingdom of Love” make their way effusively through the mix like fool’s gold, glittering alongside innuendo-laden rants “The Life and Death of Mr. Badmouth” and “The Letter”. Base beauty, or beauty debased: In PJ Harvey’s songs, it’s all a sweet-tasting poison, but a poison just the same.
Eric Seguy :. original PopMatters review | buy in the PopShop
PJ Harvey’s latest masterpiece sums up her career in tow, gathering familiar sounds and themes together like lost children and shaping them into an incredibly engaging new record. Early, raw guitar albums like Dry and Rid of Me are represented in the sexual snarl and venom of tracks like “Who the Fuck” and “Cat on a Wall” while “Shame” echoes the clean pop-oriented sound that was prevalent on her last record, Stories From the City, Stories From the Sea. Other tracks like “The Slow Drug” and “Life and Death of Mr. Badmouth” recall the slow-burning intensity Harvey experimented with during her Is This Desire period, and “Pocket Knife”, with it’s thinly-disguised, menacing overtones, sounds as if it was ripped directly off To Bring You My Love. PJ can do no wrong in my opinion, and Uh Huh Her may be her most satisfying record to date—she remains one of music’s brightest and most vital artists.
Andrew Watson :. original PopMatters review | buy in the PopShop
|44|| LIARS |
They Were Wrong, So We Drowned (Mute)
If punk is the music where the artists’ ambitions often eclipse their capabilities, Liars have become the most punk of all with their second album, a stunning display of expectation defiance with simply no acknowledgment of self- or industry-imposed constraints on their part whatsoever. Most punk bands also know to play within certain accepted stylistic limits, especially to maintain some sort of scene status, but Liars—who once rode the crest of the Gang of Four-influenced “dance-punk” revolution that never happened—have moved onto something far more unpredictable and risky with They Were Wrong, So We Drowned, a doom-laden ode to witchcraft that plays like an honest PBS documentary rather than a pretentious gothic horrorshow. Without losing their core essence (a mix of guitars and rudimentary keyboards that often falls into cacophonic repetitive patterns), and by doing exactly what they wanted and what no one remotely expected, Liars have matured from fifteen-minute faddish heroes into a band with an undoubtedly fascinating future.
Richard T. Williams :. original PopMatters review | buy in the PopShop
Its been quite some time since an album so fiercely divided fans and critics as the Liars’ sophomore effort They Were Wrong, So We Drowned. Armed with a new rhythm section, Angus Andrew as his cohorts dumped the white-belted disco punk of their debut for something starker, darker, weirder and truly original. A concept album based around German witch trails, They Were Wrong, So We Drowned is a 10-track odyssey into fear, paranoia and mysticism. Longtime fans felt betrayed by this abrupt change in direction and critics were baffled. By no means is the album an easy listen, however it is an undeniably fascinating and immensely rewarding one. The melodies here are shrouded in primitive percussion, tribal chants, guitar noise and sometimes abandoned completely for something far more inexplicable and ultimately more intriguing. No other album this year was as provocative, mesmerizing or confrontational as They Were Wrong, So We Drowned. An absolute stunner, Liars have succeeded in creating one of the most interesting and intelligent art-rock albums to be released in the new millennium, and the best one of 2004.
Kevin Jagernauth :. original PopMatters review | buy in the PopShop
|43|| ROYCE DA 5’9” |
Death is Certain (Koch)
The stories here are as funky, personal, and creative as any you’ll hear in a hip-hop album. On his sophomore album, Royce Da 5’9” comes with somber, textured production by DJ Premier, Ty Fyffe, and Carlos Broady, asking questions of the industry that so dogs him (“It’s hard to believe, that Columbia couldn’t market me / To do numbers like D-12 at least,” on “Regardless”) and boasting adeptly of his deep knowledge (“And my kitchen is huge, we do dishes wit dudes / Coldest flow of the summer, I see ‘em come and they go,” on “Throwback”). His rhymes are less clever than thoughtful, more cunning than evident: “Hip Hop” is an extended riff on “rap basketball”, all long-limbed metaphors and verbal athleticism. Honest about his worries (his wife prefers Joe Budden, because his images are too “dark”), Royce is at once appealing and strange, walking the ideal edge.
Cynthia Fuchs | buy in the PopShop
|42|| STEVE EARLE |
The Revolution Starts… Now (Artemis/E-Squared)
Complete with an Air America advertising campaign, The Revolution Starts… Now was Steve Earle’s attempt to sway the election away from Bush. Though W. won another term, Revolution is no less moving. If anything, the album’s characters—caught in dire, absurd circumstances at the hands of the administration—gain dignity in the face of four more years of reckless “leadership”. In “Home to Houston”, for instance, a blue-collar truck driver risks his life by taking work in Iraq to support his family back home. Likewise, in “Rich Man’s War”, Earle details the plight of desperate American kids who join the military to escape poverty, only to find themselves in a foreign land for no clear reason. Protest albums always risk sounding like extremist propaganda, but Earle’s songs avoid polemical tirades by capturing genuine feeling. If nothing else, buy this album for “Condi, Condi”. After all, it’s not every day you hear a reggae song about the next Secretary of State, and darn if it doesn’t sound… sexy. Yuck.
Michael Franco :. original PopMatters review | buy in the PopShop
The Revolution Starts… Now kicks off with a driving guitar and lyrically thumbs its nose at the American power structure. It is Steve Earle’s definition of patriotism writ large across 11 songs, moving from simple statement to the stories of the people who are paying the price for official mendacity in George W. Bush’s America. There is the trucker facing a difficult road back from a mission in Iraq (“Home to Houston”) and the poor around the globe (“Rich Man’s War”) and the spiritual hymn to his own eternal optimism (“The Seeker”). By turns angry and hopeful—the title song combines both—the disc is a simple statement of purpose, a political statement, a reminder that change is within our grasp, that we are the ones who must make it happen.
Hank Kalet :. original PopMatters review | buy in the PopShop
|41|| GHOSTFACE |
The Pretty Toney Album (Def Jam)
Ghostface is rap’s voice of desperation. Born Dennis Coles, he was raised like a rumble fish on the streets of Staten Island, where an alias like Ghostface Killah isn’t just for the stage, it’s protection from the law, the gangsters, and Mom. It’s a name that withdraws young Dennis Coles from the emotional chaos of growing up poor. You can hear that poverty scarred him, but he’s a stronger man for it. He spits lyrics that sound desperate. He might be wailing, but he regrets the fact that he’s going to have to kill you with the punch-line of his rhyme. He’s not afraid to be seen crying at your funeral either. It’s not personal. It’s just the hot soul samples and hard beats and the fact that whatever you’ve seen in your life, Ghost has seen it twice. He’s a ghost, he’ll be here when you’re dust. His collaborations with Raekwon, and the dozens of Wu-Tang Clan gems aside, Ghostface made classic solo albums in an industry that turns its back on anyone who boasts more than two albums before they’re shot dead. In 2004, Ghostface Killah is older and better, and after (count ‘em) three previous solo records, his fourth record is a masterpiece in a unfailing discography. For the first time in rap history, the skits are actually good (some critics have said that Ghost’s skits are better than most rappers songs—I tend to agree), and they help transition the album between songs as varied as the hardcore “Metal Lungies”, and “Biscuits” to the quintessential Ghostface soul tracks “Save Me Dear”, and “Be This Way”. His new softness on the concrete, the former Iron Man has taken off the mask. Pretty Toney is here, a truly mature artist in the rap game, with words for the wise. Put your nostalgia in a drawer and pretend you didn’t have sex while listening to “Cherchez la Ghost” from Supreme Clientele. Turn on the sex with “Tooken Back”, blow your MC-face off with the graffiti-soul of “Holla”, or the insane classic RZA-produced “Run”, and see if you can argue that The Pretty Toney Album is not only the the strongest album in Ghost career, it competes for best rap album of the year.
Lee Henderson | buy in the PopShop
// Notes from the Road
"Marina's star shines bright and her iridescent pop shines brighter. Froot is her most solid album yet. Her tour continues into the new year throughout Europe.READ the article