High Redefinition

The 30 Best TV Shows of 2007

by PopMatters Staff

17 January 2008


cover art

Countdown with Keith Olbermann

Cast: Keith Olbermann
Regular airtime: Weeknights, 8pm

US: 31 Mar 2003


Countdown with Keith Olbermann MSNBC

Some say he’s inherited the mantle left behind by previous broadcast giants like Edward R. Murrow (whose ‘goodnight and good luck’ catchphrase he liberally borrows) and Walter Cronkite. Yet the former EPSN analyst’s shtick is far more politicized than his predecessors. Beginning with his anti-Bush posturing - he loves to point out the number of days since the President declared “Mission Accomplished” in Iraq—and ending with his famed Special Comments, Olbermann is the perfect pundit, a man unashamed of speaking his mind. That it frequently reflects the truth of a situation makes the one sided reportage all the more meaningful. Bill Gibron

cover art

Ugly Betty

Series Premiere
Cast: America Ferrera, Eric Mabius, Vanessa Williams, Alan Dale, Mark Indelicato, Ashley Jensen
Regular airtime: Thursdays, 8pm ET

US: 28 Sep 2006

Review [5.Oct.2006]


Ugly Betty ABC

Ugly Betty‘s a total soap opera. It dramatizes the struggles of children and grandchildren of Mexican immigrants. So it’s just The Devil Wears Prada reconceived as a television series, right. No: Ugly Betty‘s simply more proof that unlimited wealth can’t buy happiness, that the richest 1% of Americans have problems, too. Maybe the series does act as a loose post-mortem critique of John F. Kennedy Jr.? Question: which statement is true? Answer: all of them, which is what makes this America Ferrera-helmed vehicle one of the fiercest, funniest comedy-dramas going right now. Did I forget to mention how ceaselessly hilarious this show also is? Shame on me. Ray Cummings

cover art

The Sopranos

Cast: James Gandolfini, Edie Falco, Lorraine Bracco, Jamie-Lynn Sigler, Robert Iler, Michael Imperioli, Aida Turturro, Steven R. Schirripa
Regular airtime: Sundays, 9pm ET

US: 8 Apr 2007

Review [24.Apr.2007]
Review [16.Mar.2006]
Review [12.Apr.2004]
Review [23.Sep.2002]
Review [1.Jan.1995]


The Sopranos HBO

Cut to black. With that, The Sopranos ended and sparked a conversation about TV as art. Television is often implicated in American culture wars, but those are clashes about content. The impassioned debate about The Sopranos’ finale is about form and meaning. Is that any way to end a drama? Does the “nothingness” signify death? Or is it an elision of false resolutions? These are not questions asked of series television. Find flaws if you want with “Kevin Finnerty”, or time spent on Vito Spatafore (Joseph Gannacoli), or how abruptly Dr. Melfi (Lorraine Bracco) drops Tony (James Gandolfini), or the cut to black, The Sopranos expanded the horizons of American TV. And for that it can’t be faulted. Shaun Huston

cover art

Big Love

Cast: Bill Paxton, Jeanne Tripplehorn, Chloë Sevingy, Ginnifer Goodwin, Harry Dean Staton
Regular airtime: Sundays, 10pm


Review [2.Jul.2007]
Review [23.Mar.2006]


Big Love HBO

Season two of HBO’s polygamy drama picked up two weeks after season one, with Utah businessman Bill Henrickson in danger of being exposed as a man with three wives.  Despite a typical season’s worth of plot machinations—a video game poker enterprise, a possible fourth wife, the hardcore polygamists that make up the Henrickson’s extended family—the show sticks to what it does best, depicting a modern-day family trying, with genuine conviction and love, to make it work. The writers never condescend, and they never turn away. The acting is across-the-board excellent but Jean Tripplehorn as proud, lovelorn first wife Barbara, and Chloe Sevigny as Nicky, the wily second wife, stand out. Peter Swanson

cover art

VH1’s The White Rapper Show

Cast: MC Serch, Dasit, Jon Boy, Misfit, Sullee, Persia, John Brown, 100 Proof, $hamrock
Regular airtime: Sundays, 10:30pm

US: 8 Jan 2007


VH1’s The (White) Rapper Show VH1

Every now and again, reality television as a genre knocks one out of the park. Witness VH1’s The (White) Rapper Show, wherein a bespeckled, grizzly MC Serch put a rag-tag group of melanin-deficient hopefuls through hip-hop boot camp. The program functioned almost as a honkie microcosm of commercial, “real-deal” rap world, with a contestant for almost every possible role: John Brown as cold, conniving gangsta, Jus Rhyme as backpacker activist, Persia as b-girl female jonesin’ for respect, $hamrock as florid Lil Wayne clone, and so on. The (White) Rapper Show began—seemingly—as a way for channel-surfers to feel superior to yet another cultural public, but concluded as an unwittingly addictive cousin to Bravo’s Project Runway: we were granted a window into the bare mechanics of an art and the ugly clashes erupting between ambitious personalities. Now: when are those debut albums gonna drop? Ray Cummings

cover art

Ninja Warrior

Cast: Ichiro Furutachi, Keisuke Hatsuta, Wataru Ogasawara
Regular airtime: Weeknight, 6 and 10pm

(G4 Television)
US: 26 Sep 1997


Ninja Warrior G4 Television

Imagine MXC without the excessive toilet humor. Actually, imagine the Spike series original production, Takashi’s Castle, with actual reverence for the source. Looking for a way to broaden their fanbase, the video game oriented G4 cable channel bought truncated versions of Sasuke (a seasonal televised athletic contest) and renamed it. Now presenting all 19 seasons, including the females only Women of Ninja Warrior, this intensely entertaining obstacle course competition features recurring participants, outrageous stunts, and more than a few spectacular failures. In fact, one of the best elements of this show is its difficulty. It truly rewards only the best and most accomplished. Bill Gibron

cover art

South Park

Cast: Trey Parker, Matt Stone, Isaac Hayes, Gracie Lazar, Mona Marshall
Regular airtime: Wednesdays, 10pm

(Comedy Central)

Review [18.Oct.2006]
Review [26.Oct.2005]


South Park Comedy Central

Rumor has it that Brad Neely, creator of such internet staples as The Professor Brothers and Baby Cakes, was a consultant for this year’s season (11, for those counting) of South Park. It’s unconfirmed, but would explain the crowning achievement of the most irreverent show (cartoon or otherwise) on television: the “Imaginationland” Trilogy. If South Park this year will be remembered for anything, it will be this epic, ridiculous, avant, cult arc that posits a terrorist attack on Imaginationland and the government’s response. Indicative of what the show has become—topical and absolutely batshit crazy simultaneously—the trilogy stands against other season staples: parodies of Hillary Clinton, U2, Guitar Hero, Michael Richards, Gay Camp, and zombies. Who knew back when flying excrement was the motif of the day that South Park would be the pop culture junkies’ best friend? Mordechai Shinefield

cover art

Human Giant

Cast: Aziz Ansari, Rob Huebel, Paul Scheer
Regular airtime: Thursdays, 10:30pm ET

US: 5 Apr 2007

Review [2.May.2007]


Human Giant MTV

It was a short series run and a good chunk of the sketches were re-plays of the Internet shorts that got them there. But the comedians who make up Human Giant—Aziz Ansari, Rob Huebel, Paul Scheer, Jason Woliner—had a promising debut on MTV this year, welding Kids in the Hall and Mr. Show with New York geek cool that was absurd, accessible, and contagiously fun. They’re equally talented played broad or straight to their inspired guests (Linda Cardellini as the head of a mother/son moving company, pint sized ham Bobb’e J. Thompson as the head of Shutterbugs). And with their 24-hour marathon they proved they’re not just funny in two-minute bursts. Michael Buening

cover art

Veronica Mars

Cast: Kristen Bell, Percy Daggs III, Enrico Colantoni, Jason Dohring
Regular airtime: Wednesdays, 9pm ET


Review [28.May.2007]
Review [28.May.2007]
Review [3.Oct.2006]
Review [28.Sep.2005]
Review [17.May.2005]
Review [4.Oct.2004]
Review [1.Jan.1995]


Veronica Mars CW Network

This year, the CW robbed us of TV’s craftiest detective in favor of the younger, blander Gossip Girl—the kind of bonehead move Veronica herself would take down with a single acidic one-liner. Not being as verbally blessed as Ms. Mars (who is?), I’ll simply note that the final chunk of the third season—including a sex tape, a sheriff election, and Paul Rudd as a besotted rock star—kept to the show’s high standards, right up to a series finale as intriguing, thorny, and frustratingly unresolved as vintage noir. Jesse Hassenger

cover art


Cast: Hugh Laurie, Omar Epps, Robert Sean Leonard, Jesse Spencer
Regular airtime: Tuesdays, 9pm

US: 16 Nov 2004

Review [16.Sep.2008]
Review [25.Sep.2007]
Review [4.Oct.2005]
Review [22.Nov.2004]


House Fox

Last season, show creator David Shore did something incredibly ballsy. He had all of the House ducklings (Chase, Cameron and Foreman) either quit or be fired. Essentially, he wiped the show clean—something admittedly needed after the extended Tritter fiasco. Still, it could’ve been the moment that Gregory House jumped the shark. Instead, we were treated to a Survivor-style reality show in which House took a room full of potential new ducklings and whittled them down to three. As always it was sharp, indignant, and hysterical, but for the first time, every episode seemed essential. Unlike Tritter (and the first season Vogler), it was a House arc worth paying attention to. Not to mention Kal Penn. Genius. Mordechai Shinefield

Topics: adam baldwin | adewale akinnuoye-agbaje | adrian pasdar | adrianne palicki | aida turturro | aidan gillen | aimee teegarden | alan dale | alec baldwin | ali larter | america ferrera | anna friel | ashley jensen | aziz ansari | b.j. novak | bill paxton | brendon small | bret mckenzie | chi mcbride | christina hendricks | clarke peters | connie britton | dan castellaneta | daniel dae kim | david zayas | deirdre lovejoy | dominic monaghan | dominic west | donald sutherland | edie falco | edward james olmos | elisabeth moss | elizabeth mitchell | enrico colantoni | eric mabius | erik king | evangeline lilly | frankie faison | gaius charles | ginnifer goodwin | grace park | gracie lazar | hank azaria | harold perrineau | harry dean staton | harry shearer | hayden panettiere | hugh laurie | ira glass | isaac hayes | jack mcbrayer | james gandolfini | james remar | jamie bamber | jamie-lynn sigler | jane krakowski | jason dohring | jeanne tripplehorn | jemaine clement | jenna fischer | jennifer carpenter | jesse plemons | jesse spencer | jill clayburgh | john brown | john doman | john krasinski | john slattery | john stewart | jon hamm | jorge garcia | josh holloway | joshua gomez | julie benz | julie kavner | katee sackhoff | keith olbermann | kristen bell | kristin chenoweth | kyle chandler | laraine newman | lauren velez | lee pace | lorraine bracco | maggie siff | mark indelicato | mary mcdonnell | masi oka | matt stone | matthew fox | michael c. hall | michael emerson | michael imperioli | milo ventimiglia | minka kelly | mona marshall | nancy cartwright | naveen andrews | omar epps | paul scheer | percy daggs iii | persia | peter krause | rachel dratch | rainn wilson | rhys darby | rob huebel | robert iler | robert sean leonard | santiago cabrera | sarah lancaster | scott adsit | scott porter | seth gabel | stephen colbert | steve carell | steven r. schirripa | taylor kitsch | terry o'quinn | tina fey | tony bourdain | tracy morgan | trey parker | tricia helfer | vanessa williams | vincent kartheiser | wendell pierce | william baldwin | yeardley smith | yunjin kim | yvonne strahovski | zach gilford | zachary levi | zoe mclellan
We all know how critical it is to keep independent voices alive and strong on the Internet. Please consider a donation to support our work. We are a wholly independent, women-owned, small company. Your donation will help PopMatters stay viable through these changing, challenging times where costs have risen and advertising has dropped precipitously. PopMatters needs your help to keep publishing. Thank you.

//Mixed media

Authenticity Issues and the New Intimacies

// Marginal Utility

"The social-media companies have largely succeeded in persuading users of their platforms' neutrality. What we fail to see is that these new identities are no less contingent and dictated to us then the ones circumscribed by tradition; only now the constraints are imposed by for-profit companies in explicit service of gain.

READ the article