The Black Man
Atop a Hong Kong highrise on New Year's Eve 1999,
supersecret agent Neil Shaw (Wesley Snipes) takes his
time completing his supersecret task. He's renowned,
you soon learn, for being so supersecret that no one
knows he exists, for having no "identity." As he looks
down on the thronged streets far, far below, his team
members, monitor his activities from inside their
supersecret van, filled with all kinds of supersecret
devices. "What's he doing?" they wonder aloud. His
answer: "Experiencing the moment."
For a man who has no identity, Shaw sure has plenty of
attitude. When he completes his assignment on the
roof, he descends to the street, where he makes
trouble with a sense of style and self-congratulatory brilliance. Not only does he steal precious North
Korean computer data, he also out-martial-artses a
series of hapless Chinese bodyguard-types and sasses
clueless interrogators, to boot. When Chinese business
mucky-muck David Chan (Cary-Hiroyuki Tagawa) inquires
after Shaw's identity, he answers, "I'm Eddie Murphy."
Chan looks surprised, but thoughtful, as if he's
considering the possibility. The point seems to be
this: all black men look alike to those who are not in
the know. And in this movie, that means just about
everyone but Shaw.
Such anonymity is useful in his line of work, which,
as far as I can make out, is dirty-tricking for the
United Nations. Employed by the ruthless Head of UN
Security Eleanor Hooks (Anne Archer), he and his team
bop about the world, stealing data from and exposing
scandalous wrongdoing by various governmental
officials in order to force them to do what the UN
wants them to do. Who knew that global politics was so
insidious!? And it's not just that Shaw is some
heartless merc he's a sincere martial artist and
Buddhist with a carefully worked out ideology (which
remains mostly supersecret to the rest of us),
dedicated to keeping peace and doing the right thing.
And experiencing the moment, of course.
After completing the Hong Kong mission, Shaw heads
back to New York (actually, all the locations are
Montreal, set-designed and digitally enhanced to
resemble Hong Kong and NYC), where again, he's
apparently the only African American male anyone
notices. In order to discuss his next assignment with
Hooks, Shaw arrives at the UN dressed as some sort of
"African" diplomat. On their way out, they run into
her superior, Secretary General Thomas (Donald
Sutherland), who observes that they haven't met
before. "We still haven't," says Shaw, so very
mysteriously and self-importantly. Some time later,
when the usually oblivious Thomas finally demands that
Hooks let him in on what's going on and who's been
taking care of all their nefarious minutiae, she
declares simply, "The black man."
On the most obvious level, this answer speaks to the
film's casting and narrative organization: Shaw is
indeed the only black character. Normally, such
visual prominence might severely compromise one's
ability to go undercover, but here it only seems to
increase Shaw's inscrutability factor, not to mention
the threat he poses to all sides. (As in, "Who is that
super-smooth, super-lethal guy?") He's admired and
envied by his teammates, Bly (Michael Biehn), and
Novak (Liliana Komorowska), as well as by the FBI guy
who's tracking him, Capella (Maury Chaykin). He's also
somewhat enthralling to a UN translator, Julia Fang
(Marie Matiko), who's an accidental witness to the
assassination of the Chinese Ambassador, just at the
moment when the UN is voting on a Chinese "trade
agreement." (Details are fuzzy, but the plot more or
less revolves around this world-changing vote, which
grants China more power on the world stage than some
folks would like.)
This plot point leads to the second level where Shaw's
racial singularity is thematic and meaningful. Not
only does he stand out visually and Snipes is a
stunning presence, no doubt Shaw is also a kind of
chosen one, an "action hero" with a sense of mission
and righteousness, no matter that he happens to be
working for those who seek to maintain order by his
illegal and often violent activities. Self-assured and
serious about his philosophy and image (his wardrobe
and gadgetry are first class), Shaw is determined to
right the wrongs of the world (or, as many as he can
get his hands on). Though Shaw complains to Hooks
about the job's lack of benefits and "insurance," he's
special and knows it; he recognizes that he's the only
man equipped with the requisite physical and psychic
gifts to get all this shit done (track down the
killers, save the planet). Indeed, it appears that he
has harnessed a way to channel his memories and
spiritual powers into action. Or something like that.
He tends to roll his head back, close his eyes, and
meditate when things get wild. It could be that he's
gathering his wits. Or better, his inner strength: he
is strong. The film highlights two great-looking
set-pieces in which Shaw chases a villain through
rainy streets, over murky rooftops, into an ominous
warehouse, and by the time the second one comes along,
he's apparently seeing flashbacks to the first one,
and cinematographer Pierre Gill's mesmerizing point of
view camera blends the two scenes together, through
fast-cutting and "negative" imaging (such that the
picture resembles a photo negative). Being inside
Shaw's head like this is a little disconcerting, but
it might make you start to respect his weirdness, too.
Even if he is impressively abstruse, Shaw doesn't have
much going for him in the way of "character
development." And Snipes brings his usual action guy
stoicism and surface-intensity to the role. Wayne
(Murder at 1600) Beach and Simon Davis Barry's
script is full of explosions, stunts, and shoot-outs,
plus some basic holes (those bizarre and annoying
coincidences that make you stop watching the film and
start wondering just how some particular event has
come to pass). Shaw has lots of toys ultrafast palm
piloty thingies and gleaming, cannon-like guns but
no apartment, no friends, no life except this
high-stakes job (unless you count his White Men Can't Jump basketball scene, where he bonds with Bly on a
street-court, with a hip-hop soundtrack during a flashy
montage of sweaty body parts, so you know they're both
just regular guys, I suppose).
And Shaw's relationship with Julia is, well, tedious:
for most of the movie he's holding her in a kind of
protective custody, handcuffing her to steering
wheels, or, when they agree to work as a team, keeping
in contact with her by high-tech earpieces and
mini-mics. She's a familiar Snipes action flick
heroine (see also Irene Jacob U.S. Marshals,
Jennifer Lopez in Money Train, Yancy Butler in Drop Zone), pretty, brave, and eventually, in need of
rescue. Julia wants to be tough and rebellious, but
Shaw's got all the (script-mandated) advantages. Or
maybe not: their verbal exchanges tend toward the
cryptic, awkward, and mundane. She: "You're not used
to this are you, not having control of a situation,
being manipulated?" He: "Are you stating the obvious
for your own enjoyment or are you moonlighting as a
psychic friend?"
In fact, much of the film states and restates the
obvious: international "diplomacy" is really another
form of war, a duplicitous business where, as Hooks
observes, appearances are everything and you destroy
your enemies from within. That the enemies here are
the "Chinese" imagined by the U.S. "right wing" is
minimally topical, as it rehearses the right's fear of
Chinese influence on U.S. elections and theft of
military secrets, as well as the right's desire to
return to Cold War politics by strong-arming and
profiteering. But the movie dumps all this bad
"ideology" on one evil character, so that the basic
U.S. world-domination system looks just fine.
Though again, "looking fine" is, of course, precisely
the problem in global governing and war-making. The
film's title is lifted from Sun Tsu's famous ancient
handbook, which makes just these points: no one can be
trusted and nothing is what it seems. But while The Art of War suggests that Shaw's lack of identity is
an asset in such an environment, it's also something
of a liability, or at the least, a distraction. It
makes it hard to tell what he's experiencing moment
to moment, and that makes it hard to care much.