No More Puff Daddy
by Cynthia Fuchs
I am definitely the fault of my own image.
Sean "Puffy" Combs, to Katherine E. Finkelstein, The New York Times (17 March 2001)
P-Diddy and the Fam.
Who you know do it better?
Yeah right, no matter what, we air-tight.
Puff Daddy, "Victory"
As most everyone who might care already knows, that
notorious character whom the news media have been
calling Sean "Puffy" Combs is changing his name. Or
rather, he's suggesting an alternative, so that he
can, as he told Sway Barrow, MTV's Man on the Puffy
Beat, move on. "No more Puff Daddy," Combs announced.
"I am not doing it as serious as Prince I'm not
gonna be just crazy with it... It is going to be
changed to straight P. Diddy. You could call me P., or
Diddy, or P. Diddy." Apparently, he'll answer to most
any permutation. What an amiable guy he's become.
Some of us are less surprised than others at the name
change. And some of us know a little too much about
Mr. Diddy's ongoing saga including the restaurant,
house in the Hamptons, clothing line, Jesus-complex,
and magazine editor beat-downs than we might want
to admit. That is to say, Puffy has been P. and Diddy
to many of us for a long time. In fact, he says Biggie
gave him the name back on the day, you know, when
Puffy and Big were rolling, when the sky looked like
the limit. He's used the name in producing credits in
the past, as well as using it in lyrics. On this
point, the man's not lying: the name change is no
radical, get-me-out-the-contract
Prince-to-Squiggle-like transformation. I suppose you
can read the change jokingly as a
get-me-out-the-pending-civil-lawsuits maneuver, but
really, that would be pushing it.
Instead, the name change looks to be a self-image
thing. Troubled and strange, to be sure, but a
self-image thing nonetheless. And really, it hardly
matters what the rest of us think of it as Puffy
describes it, it's a return to a man he may once have
been, a less outrageous, slightly less affluent, more
visibly sincere fellow, someone maybe a little closer
to his so-called roots and most certainly farther from
the string of tragedies that have befallen him since
(a string of so many tragedies, in fact, that the
Village Voice's Peter Noel has made a list he calls
"the Bad Boy Curse" and dubbed Puffy "Vampire Player"
[Village Voice 3 April 2001]) . And so, he foresees a
smooth transition, wherein Daddy becomes Diddy, and
Mr. "Can't nobody hold me down" becomes Mr. "My number
one priority is God."
It might happen. The name has been circulating for
some time, after all. Even aside from the various
allusions Puff Daddy's made to it in songs over the
years, it also cropped up recently, in public, during
what MTV has called his "fourteen month ordeal."
Consider, for example, the message that Combs left on
his driver Wardel Fenderson's answering machine, just
three days after the shooting at Times Square's Club
New York on 27 December 1999, the very shooting that
would lead to the Trial of the Century (and yes, we
know that the century's only three months old). The
message was so important, so image-making, that it was
transcribed in newspapers around the nation. In it,
Puffy expressed concern over what is hard to say.
Worried, perhaps, that Fenderson was upset about the
shooting Puffy called to reassure him: "Hey, yo, it's
P. I was just thinking about you, dog... I just want
to make you feel, like, comfortable, you know what I'm
saying, make your family feel comfortable."
Now, you might read this as prosecutors did as
evidence that Combs was trying to bribe his driver
regarding what happened that evening at Club New
York. But you might also read it as did defense
attorneys Johnnie Cochran and Benjamin Brafman as
an indication of Puffy's genuine concern for
Fenderson's family, no doubt mightily uncomfortable at
the time, given all the media and judicial hubbub
surrounding the crime: three people shot, cops looking
for a perpetrator, camera crews hounding everyone even
remotely involved. But what strikes me about the
message, in hindsight of course, is that it's an early
unveiling of the new moniker, at the time still
private, used between friends P.
Or, here's another example of the intimate
connotations of the name. A few weeks ago, Puffy's
erstwhile girlfriend, Jennifer Lopez (whom you could
call J. Lo), appeared on Letterman to promote the
near-simultaneous releases of her movie (The Wedding Planner) and album (also called J. Lo in
marketing, repetition is a good thing). Dave was
probing Jennifer on the burning question of the day,
that is, were she and Puffy breaking up or what? She
insisted that they were together and still going
strong, and as if to prove the point, she let slip a
pet name for him P. Diddy. Dave looked briefly
surprised at that little bit of too-much-information,
then recovered as he usually does, by making
wisecracks, first about Diddy, then about Jennifer's
beautiful body. And that was the end of that.
Or so it seemed. Only a few days later, Valentines'
Day to be exact, lo! it was revealed that Lopez and
Combs were indeed broken up, had been broken up
earlier, and that she already had another beau, a
pretty back-up dancer. Poor Diddy. Not only had he
been dumped by his girl and traumatized by the trial,
but at that precise moment, on V. Day no less, he was
also awaiting the result of that ordeal, the verdict
from a New York City jury that might have sent him to
prison for 15 years (on weapons possession and bribery
charges), in connection with the shooting.
As it turned out, the verdict was cool, for Combs
anyway: he and his bodyguard Anthony "Wolf" Jones were
acquitted on 16 March, of weapons possession and
bribery charges. The trial turned out less well for
Puffy's boy Jamal Barrow (who, so far as we know,
still goes by Shyne), who was convicted of assault,
reckless endangerment, and gun possession. According
to
the Village Voice, the Bad Boy rapper was
"heartbroken" by Puffy's betrayal: on the stand,
testifying in his own defense while he was still
called Puffy, Combs did not clear Shyne, but left it
hanging in the courtroom whether his one-time protege
was carrying a 9mm Ruger and fired it, into the air or
at Natania Reuben, Julius Jones, and Robert Thompson.
Shyne's sentence won't be decided until 16 April, but
he's going to do time up to 25 years an outcome
that has some folks thinking he's been turned into a
scapegoat.
Meanwhile, Mr. Diddy is on the loose, and putting his
good fortune immediately to good use. That is, he's
recuperating his image, making the rounds to show off
his new, thinner-because-beleaguered look, playing
himself as a triumphant believer in the System and the
Lord, above all, who gave him the strength to
persevere. Suddenly, he's not a "fake thug" anymore.
Suddenly, he's exonerated, a victim of circumstances,
or maybe a victim of those members of the NYPD who are
looking to bust famous black men. And in that context,
P. says he's looking to get some distance on the whole
experience. He told Sway that he's going to take a
couple of months off, "a leave of absence, just to be
Sean," to recover from all the trauma and tribulation,
"the trial and the case and the Jennifer stuff and the
stuff with my kids and the business stuff and then the
scrutiny of the media." Time to kick it with his kids,
lay off the "I'm the macaroni with the cheese"
lifestyle.
All that sounds reasonable. And truth be told, we can
all use a break from the Puffy chronicles. But so far,
he doesn't appear to be taking much of a break.
Rather, he's all over tv, soliciting and securing the
love of his fans and supporters, doing damage control.
He even has a new video rotating, "Let's Get It,"
ostensibly the first single for Bad Boy artist G-Dep
and featuring Black Rob (you may remember him as
Puffy's post-Mase, shiny-suitless rap-star wannabe),
but prominently featuring P. Diddy, who adds his own
freestyle non-rhyme: "Not guilty."
On 29 March, Combs started hitting the tele-waves with
a canniness that's striking even for him. He did MTV's
TRL and BET's 106th & Park, Viacom's sister
call-in shows where fans are encouraged to think they
have say over what videos get on the air and what
topics are broached. On TRL, no surprise, Carson
Daly admired P. Diddy's big fat fur coat,
congratulated him on his acquittal, then put him on
the phone with one of the members of dream, Combs'
adorable white-girl group: she genuflected and
congratulated her boss. P. said he was proud of their
success, namely, their own heavily rotating video for
their first single, "He Loves U Not." Girls in the
studio audience squealed, Britney and BSB videos were
counted down: in other words, on TRL, life most
definitely goes on.
Two days later, P. Diddy appeared on 106th & Park,
the "urban" incarnation of TRL, where the audience
members are slightly older and quite a bit blacker.
Terminally cheerful hosts AJ and Free opened the day's
Puffy segment with what they called "The Puffy
Package," a two-or-so-minute set of video clips
showing the mogul at his moguliest, in Biggie videos,
in Tupac videos, in Lil Kim videos, counting the
benjamins. AJ and Free gushed at his Diddiness when he
made his way to the couch, where he extolled again his
faith in God, his love for his fans (eliciting
applause from the studio audience), and his new
sobriety, to be marked by the name change, which, he's
said more than once, will come about during a ceremony
of some kind, once all the excitement dies down, and
he's had sufficient time to recuperate, you know,
spend time with his two kids or maybe even his several
exes, one of whom is currently suing for child
support.
Of course, the change is all about performing
sincerity whether or not the change is actually
sincere, or what that might even mean. So
domesticated, so gentle, so Diddy is he, that now,
he's proffering wisdom and complexity. P. told Sway,
"No matter what in life, there has to be balance. So I
got to be responsible for my own image and making sure
that it has balance and that you see the many sides of
P. Diddy." Not that he hasn't been responsible for his
own image in the past, mind you. It's just that now,
he acknowledges that he's being held responsible for
it, not only by consumers but also by more serious
folks, like District Attorneys. Responsibility entails
owning past errors. It's time to fess up znd be
accountable: P. told Sway he's turning away from the
"bling bling" effect in hiphop imagery that he's
sometimes credited with starting, or at least helping
along with enthusiasm
("Mo Money, Mo Problems," "It's All About the
Benjamins," etc.). In P.D.'s words, "We used to talk
about wanting to get some money, but that's when
hiphop was based on your dreams and your fantasy. The
whole thing now is the dreams and fantasies were
achieved, and you don't want to make it the focal
point. You can't keep beating that dead horse." Better
to find another horse.
And, I suppose, better late than never. For some, the
hypester-hustler-supreme version of Combs long ago
overstayed his welcome. Months before his arrest and
trial, he was deep in the throes of what Vibe
magazine called "the Puffy backlash" his 1999 album
Forever barely moved a million units, quite the
downturn from No Way Out, released just after
Biggie's still-unsolved murder, which sold over 7
million copies. Aaron McGruder's Boondocks may be
the best current gauge of where the "blacklash" stands
poor Huey Freeman locked himself in his room for
days following the "crushing news of Puffy's
acquittal," so mad was he at the man for "ruin[ing]
hiphop with his shiny suits." Only days ago, little
Huey pulled himself together and went back to work on
the "Free Huey World report," writing up "news"stories
on the collabo between Diddy and his new partner in
survival against all odds, Bill "Uptown Clint" Clinton
(also known as Chubby C).
But even if we can see that hiphop has survived even
Puff Daddy, an obvious, if not exactly pressing,
question remains: how did he ever sell so many
records? His mic skills are limited at best, his
production skills are a function of his ear for '80s
rock samples, and his dancing, well... suffice to
recall the 1997 MTV Music Video Awards performance of
"Missing You" Puffy stepping all over that stage,
his white suit almost glowing while Faith, Sting, and
a choir did their best to hold down the vocals against
such bizarre, self-inflating spectacle.
Indeed, at this point it's difficult to explain (or
remember) Puffy's appeal, now that he's fallen into
such disregard as an artist and showman. It's like
trying to explain how Hammer had a big-pantsed heyday.
We might attribute it to Puffy and company's smart
marketing: there's not a trick they haven't used at
some time, including masterful overkill. But taking a
less cynical (or is it more cynical?) view, we might
attribute the appeal to P.'s incredible affiliation
with Christopher Wallace, and their shared desire to
take hiphop to the mainstream with a vengeance, to
popularize Biggie's sad, insightful, educational
street stories. Before the shiny suits, P. and B.
acted on what might be termed a hopeful purpose, to
"humanize" so-called gangstas, dealers, hustlers, and
players, to break down their reality so others looking
for a thrill might slow down and appreciate the
hardships. That Puffy lost sight of that goal is
hardly news. Maybe he knows it too. Maybe the name
change is an effort to return to a pre-lapserian
moment, to reinvent himself as a non-punk,
non-gangsta, non-overreaching producer boy. His
current contrition suggests as much. But the very
public and carefully staged declarations of it
simultaneously suggest otherwise, that he's still deep
into the game, whether fame or name.