Back in the mid-1990s, when Pavement were the darling buds on the thriving
indie rock azalea bush, one name that was tossed out as a reference for this
strangely-fresh yet weirdly-familiar sounding band was Swell Maps. And
indeed, hearing the two bands together, you realize that Pavement's
self-consciously uncomfortable arrangements, shambling verses and
grad-student lyrics were dandy upgrades of what Swell Maps had been doing in
the 1970s.
Nikki Sudden, along with his brother Epic Soundtracks, guided the Maps
through some remarkable singles ("Let's Build a Car") and two full-lengths
(notably Jane from Occupied Europe), all filled with damaged pop,
bluesy rave-ups, and weird noises (kazoos? toy pianos? balloon solos?).
Sounding like illegitimate offspring of the Stooges and Stockhausen, Swell
Maps arguably cast the mold in post-punk England, only to demolish it at the
same time.
All this, of course, was before a Swell Maps song featured loudly in a 2001
Honda commercial. Although the squalling punk of "Blam!!!" nicely
complemented the images of squealing tires in the desert dust, it was a
shock to realize that, in less than a decade, Sudden and Soundtracks had
made a strange move in the collective cultural consciousness. Indeed, this
was a bizarre backslide, to go from curious obscurities to venerated elder
musical statesmen to shills for lifestyle capitalism.
At the same time that this commercial blazed across our television screens
(and at the same time that Sudden was touring across the country), Indiana's
Secretly Canadian Records was in the middle of their own project of
rereleasing all of Nikki Sudden's 1980s and 1990s recorded output: his solo
albums, a collaboration with Rowland S. Howard (from The Birthday Party),
his incredible albums as the Jacobites (with Dave Kusworth). One can only
imagine how Pavement would have been received had these releases were widely
available then. This is obviously a moot point, because critics would
definitely have made the Swell Maps connection; I'm just wondering if they
would have been as willing to gaze back at Sudden's 1970s oeuvre with
rose-tinted pens, because this Secretly Canadian series is truly amazing in
the way that it aesthetically redefines Sudden.
The Ragged School, originally released by Twin/Tone Records in 1986,
was a collection of songs intended to introduce Jacobites (on this release
it's Sudden on guitars, organ, and synthesizer; Kusworth on guitar, bass,
and vocals; Soundtracks beating drums and percussion; and Mark Lemon playing
bass, guitars, and drum) to American audiences. And, as a rerelease, it's a
stunning introduction to those unfamiliar with Sudden's work after the
demise of Swell Maps. This album features the remastered release in its
entirety (and what a remastering it is, as Sudden and Kusworth have shined
the muddiness of the original release so that it's ringing as clear as a
broken bell), plus 11 rarities and a sharp-looking booklet, complete with
track notes (gotta love those reminiscences, in which you'll find a Hanoi
Rocks name-drop!) and photos from the Jacobites' German tour of 1985.
Just as Pavement in the 1990s was looking back to various 1970s jangly
post-punkers for artistic inspiration, Sudden with his various collaborators
in the 1980s was looking back to the 1960s electric rock-folk of the Rolling
Stones, Neil Young, and Bob Dylan, and the 1970s glittery proto-punk of Marc
Bolan and Johnny Thunders. Indeed, these songs have the vigor and
melancholy of the best of those artists; the lyrics cover similar areas:
we're in a fog-choked world of busted relationships, nostalgia, and
unreciprocated obsession. If you're not careful when listening to them, the
title of "It'll All End Up in Tears" may very well prove prophetic about
describing your listening experience.
This is best realized on "Heart of Hearts" and "Son of a French Nobleman",
which employ the same stylistic effect of starting slow and gentle -- the
former with ringing acoustic guitar, the latter with a warm organ -- before
building slowly, with percussive accents, to a triumphant ending. The
effect is like running up a hill in a light drizzle, away from your lover.
What really gets under the skin (in the unforgettable sense, not the
irritating one) here are the vocals: they're somewhere between the nasal
twang of Rob(yn) Hitchcock and the strained bleat of Rob(ert) Zimmerman.
And in the cracks and slightly off-kilter harmonies, you'll find ecstatic
misery made aural.
The songs on this rerelease range from quiet ballads such as these, to
driving tambourine-shakers like "Pin Your Heart to Me", hauntingly acoustic
ballads ("Tell Me"), boombastic rockers like "Bethlehem Castle" and "Big
Store (Orig.)", and strange noisescapes ("The Old Church Steps", which
sounds suspiciously like the end of the Beatles' "Good Morning, Good
Morning" mixed with some good old-fashion backward tape loops). Oddly,
these last two genres -- the rockers and the oddball experimental ones --
come closest to resembling the Sudden and Soundtracks of old, if not in
sound, then in execution.
There's no doubt, though, that The Ragged School is the document of a
group of troubadour punks, gutter poets, and flophouse balladeers with (as
one of the spookier stripped-down songs has it) "Tattered Scarves". Yes,
it's heartbreaking. But in a way that makes you want to return to it, not
because you want to want to dwell in your (and the Jacobites') oceans of
sadness, but because you want to find ways to swim out of them.
1 November 2002