Quantcast
News

Year after year, the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame adds new names to its illustrious membership.


And year after year, folks who still care find a reason to complain about said new names.


Rock hall's 2009 class is pretty solid — with one glaring omission

The Class of 2009 should elicit the usual griping from pop-music fans whose favorites have yet to be honored. The 2009 inductees are Jeff Beck, Little Anthony and the Imperials, Metallica, Run-DMC and Cleveland native Bobby Womack.


Also, Wanda Jackson will be inducted as an early influence, and former Elvis Presley rhythm section drummer D.J. Fontana and bassist Bill Black and lauded songwriter/session keyboardist Spooner Oldham will be inducted as sidemen.


Artists are eligible for induction 25 years after their first released recording.


Overall, it seems a pretty solid list that should make for a pretty entertaining VH1 television show and ceremony April 4 at Public Hall in Cleveland - and don’t think that doesn’t matter to voters.


Beck has long been considered one of the most versatile guitarists in rock. From his beginnings in the British Invasion blues of the Yardbirds through his own rockin’ blues band the Jeff Beck Group fronted by Rod Stewart and his fusion-oriented solo albums of the 1970s, Beck never got as much commercial love as fellow former Yardbirds guitarists Eric Clapton and Jimmy Page, but he is certainly a member of the rock guitar pantheon. His 2009 honor adds him to the list of multiple inductees that includes three of the Beatles, Clapton and Michael Jackson.


Also, Beck, whose famous line while inducting Rod Stewart in 1994 (“Rod and I have a love/hate relationship - he loves me, and I hate him.”) is used every year in the rock hall’s time-killing montage, is almost sure to deliver an entertaining speech.


Rock hall voters’ soft spot for the doo-wop groups of the 1950s and 1960s continues with the induction of Little Anthony and the Imperials. The group, featuring Jerome Anthony Gourdine’s lovely vocals, had such hits as “Tears on My Pillow”; “Shimmy, Shimmy, Ko-Ko-Bop”; and “Goin’ Out of My Head.”


It’s hard to argue against these inclusions as a lot of the old singing groups were essentially robbed by record companies and publishers during their heyday and, even today, many are being robbed of potential income by a slew of unauthorized imitators using their names.


Expect the yearly inclusion of at least one old doo-wop group to last for a while.


The rock hall folks don’t seem to really know what to do with heavy metal (look how long it took for Black Sabbath to be included), and it’s apparent that the genre is not a favorite of many voters. But Metallica’s first-time ballot inclusion is no real surprise. The band not only helped bring thrash metal to arenas and commercial radio, but it also was a major influence and managed to cross over, selling several truckloads of records.


Also, I still think somewhere a few voters are dreading having to consider the more commercial hair metal of the ‘80s and would like to at least get the metal wing started off right before having to vote on Motley Crue (first eligible in 2006) or Poison (2008).


Run-DMC is the logical follow-up to the hall’s embracing of hip-hop with the 2007 induction of Grandmaster Flash and the Furious Five. Flash and company took hip-hop out of the party with “The Message” and then Run-DMC took the music into arenas and used its Adidas to permanently kick open the door to pop radio, mixing rap and rock in a way that is considered standard these days.


Between hits such as “King of Rock,” “My Adidas” and the 1987 cover/duet of Aerosmith’s “Walk This Way,” which helped revive Aerosmith’s commercial fortunes, Run-DMC cemented its place in pop-music history.


Bobby Womack is a half-century veteran of music and is widely respected among old soul fans and music-industry folks. His career has covered several genres, including doo-wop, R&B, gospel and rock. As a songwriter, sideman and producer, he has worked on classic albums by artists such as Aretha Franklin (“Lady Soul”), Sly & the Family Stone (“There’s a Riot Goin’ On”) and Janis Joplin (“Pearl,” which also includes “Trust Me,” co-written by Womack).


He also had some hits of his own with “That’s the Way I Feel About Cha’”; “Across 110th St.”; and “If You Think You’re Lonely Now.”


So with the 2009 inductees taken care of, how about a little love for the 2009 rejectees: Chic, War and the Stooges.


OK, it’s griping time.


As much as I enjoy the music of Chic and War, I can’t feign surprise that they didn’t make the cut. But even the most optimistic, positive-minded music fan has to be a little riled up by the continued exclusion of the Stooges. The band’s influence is undeniable as it is one of the roots of the hard rock, metal and punk trees that have sprouted since its 1969 debut album. Additionally, the rock hall had the audacity to invite the band to induct fellow Detroit native Madonna but still couldn’t collectively bring itself to induct the Stooges.


At this point, it’s pretty hard to not assume there is some kind of effort on the part of at least a few voters to deny the Stooges its rightful place in the hall.


Some fans will probably blame the recent inclusion of hip-hop legends as artists who were given the Stooges’ spot. But with the hall expanding its scope to more resemble a “Pop Music Hall of Fame,” both Grand Master Flash and the Furious Five and Run-DMC have earned their relative spots.


But the other Motor City madmen fronted by Iggy Pop has been eligible since 1994. Back in the mid-1990s, the backlog of beloved classic rockers and legendary soul men (and Bob Marley) was still being cleared with huge names such as John Lennon (1994), Led Zeppelin (1995) and Iggy Pop buddy and Stooges fan David Bowie (1996).


But as the eligibility years have risen into the late ‘70s and early ‘80s (the current year is 1984), the rock hall’s decision making has become more questionable. Among the folks who have made it in before the Stooges are Dusty Springfield (1999), the Lovin’ Spoonful (2000), Traffic (2004) and the Stooges-influenced Sex Pistols and Blondie (2006). While those artists might all be deserving of enshrinement, the Stooges are, too.


The band might have sold only about 100 copies of its early albums during its initial run, but like the already inducted Velvet Underground (1996), the Stooges have had an enduring influence on rock music, evidenced by the number of Facebook and MySpace bands that list the band under “influences.”


Maybe next year.



Comments
Now on PopMatters
Short Ends and Leader: 10 Alternative Cinematic Valentines
Will we always love Whitney? (PopWire) [Tue, 12:35 pm]
Tough Like Glue: An Interview with V.V. Brown (Sound Affects) [Tue, 12:00 pm]
10 Alternative Cinematic Valentines (Short Ends and Leader) [Tue, 9:00 am]
  1. 'Nebraska': Bruce Springsteen's 'Heart of Darkness' (Columns)
  2. The 10 Greatest Shakespeare Film Adaptations of All Time (Short Ends and Leader)
  3. Not-So-Central Casting: Kevin Smith and the Birth of the Reality Podcast (Features)
  4. The 10 Greatest Movie Spies Ever (Short Ends and Leader)
  5. Bored This Way: The 54th Annual Grammy Awards (Features)
  6. Slipped Discs 2011 - Part 2: From the Go! Team to the Phoenix Foundation (Features)
  7. Slipped Discs 2011 - Part 3: From Real Estate to Youth Lagoon (Features)
  8. Lana Del Rey: Born to Die (Reviews)
  9. The Top 15 Madonna Singles of All Time (Sound Affects)
  10. Your Anti-Valentine's Day Playlist. (Mixed Media)
  11. Google and the Production of Curiosity (Marginal Utility)
  12. Carole E. Barrowman’s Authorial Journey to Hollow Earth (Features)
  13. Van Halen: A Different Kind of Truth (Reviews)
  14. “Don’t Let Me Fall”: Hip-Hop in the Age of Austerity (Features)
  15. Tower Songs: Townes Van Zandt (Columns)
  16. Black Bananas: Rad Times Xpress IV (Reviews)
  17. Paul McCartney: Kisses on the Bottom (Reviews)
  18. Of Montreal: Paralytic Stalks (Reviews)
  19. The Gay Ole Countryside (Columns)
  20. Rating the Performances at the 54th Annual Grammy Awards (Mixed Media)
  21. Nick Cave’s The Death of Bunny Munro: A Rock Star’s Midlife Crisis or Valid Literature? (Features)
  22. Counterbalance No. 67: John Coltrane’s 'A Love Supreme' (Sound Affects)
  23. A Look to the Past, An Insight Into the Present: The Use of Gender in 'Mad Men' (Features)
  24. The 10 Best John Coltrane Solos (Sound Affects)
  25. Mark Lanegan Band: Blues Funeral (Reviews)
  26. A Tale of How Great Journalism Became Revisionist History: Grambling State U Football (Columns)
  27. Chairlift: Something (Reviews)
  28. Mitt Romney Can Reside at Today's Proverbial 'Downton Abbey'... Newt Gingrich Cannot (Features)
  29. After Cease to Exist: The Far-from-Final Report of Throbbing Gristle (Features)
  30. Die Antwoord: Ten$ion (Reviews)
PM Picks
Music Archive
Announcements
Ratings

10 - The Best of the Best

9 - Very Nearly Perfect

8 - Excellent

7 - Damn Good

6 - Good

5 - Average

4 - Unexceptional

3 - Weak

2 - Seriously Flawed

1 - Terrible

© 1999-2012 PopMatters.com. All rights reserved.
PopMatters.com™ and PopMatters™ are trademarks
of PopMatters Media, Inc.

PopMatters is wholly independently owned and operated.
PopMatters is a member of BUZZMEDIA Music, MOG and Guardian Select.