Vibe: Hard to Let it Go

[5 March 2007]

by Mark Reynolds

Vibe once nailed down the sweet spot between hip-hop swagger and Madison Avenue polish. But no longer needing to prove hip-hop’s worth to the broader audience, it morphed into a gooey valentine to hip-hop’s ghetto fabulousness.

Hip-hop is no better or worse, and no more or less important, than any other music genre. Depending on how broad your definitions are (and all musical genre definitions are in constant flux) it may be the biggest, but in terms of collective aesthetic quality and societal significance, it’s just another branch on the American entertainment tree. So to bemoan the quality of a hip-hop magazine as though it should ever have been “more” than any other music magazine, be it Maximum Rock ‘n’ Roll, Alternative Press or Metal Maniacs, is foolish and says more about the author’s personal taste than about “the state of the culture” or anything else.

Comment by pdf — March 5, 2007 @ 2:59 pm

Excellent article.  I think it’s a symptom of print music magazines that they can’t cover the whole time continuum of the past, present and future well (except maybe MOJO).

Comment by Jason Gross — March 12, 2007 @ 11:16 am

Add a comment

Please enter your name and a valid email address. Your email address will not be displayed. It is required only to prevent comment spam.

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?

Please enter the sequence of letters and numbers you see in the image above. Do not include any spaces.

Negritude 2.0
Retelling the History of Black Music: Everything You Know about the Blues Is Wrong

Retelling the History of Black Music: Everything You Know about the Blues Is Wrong

Mark Reynolds

03.Jul.08

For the most part, blacks were not involved in the heroic work of rescuing the black acoustic blues legacy from the passage of time.

Retelling the History of Black Music: Adventures in Retro-ism

Retelling the History of Black Music: Adventures in Retro-ism

Mark Reynolds

07.Mar.08

Rightly or wrongly, black audiences have always tended to chase musical innovation, not musical reverence.

Ask an African

Ask an African

Mark Reynolds

11.Jan.08

Africa will play an increasingly pivotal role in world affairs this year, and not just because a guy whose dad was Kenyan is running for President of the United States.

 
 

TODAY ON POPMATTERS
Columns | recent
Marginal Utility: Brand Evangelists
Field Studies: Vinyl: Got to Get You Into My Life
Events | recent | archive
:. Sonic Youth - River to River Festival — 4.July.08: Manhattan, NY
Books | recent | archive
:. Federico Fellini The Book of Dreams by Federico Fellini
:. When You Are Engulfed in Flames by David Sedaris
Multimedia | recent | archive
:. Wii Fit
RECENT COLUMNS
MORE COLUMNS
:. recent columns :. full archive
Marginal Utility: Brand Evangelists
By Rob Horning
[25.Jul.08]
Canon Fodder: American Film Theatre
By Michael Barrett
[18.Jul.08]
Jazz Today: Double Standards
By Will Layman
[17.Jul.08]
Pop Osmosis: Fun for the Entire Family
By Jennifer Byrne
[15.Jul.08]
Busted Headphones: Truth in Humor
By Quentin B. Huff
[11.Jul.08]
The Tackle Box: Myth-Making Dolphins
By Chris Justice
[10.Jul.08]
Moving Pixels: Just as Fun to Watch
By L.B. Jeffries
[9.Jul.08]
Pop Past: Joe Strummer: The Future Is Unwritten
By PopMatters Staff
[8.Jul.08]
From the Cheap Seats: C-O-M-P-E-T-E
By Tobias Peterson
[7.Jul.08]
Mixtape Confessions: Getting Schooled
By Ben Rubenstein
[1.Jul.08]