about contributors submissions book series advertising contests Media Center PopMatters Picks
|
|
Live Fast, Die Young, or Get Off the StageIn the Fascist Bathroom: Punk in Pop Music, 1977-1992by Greil MarcusHarvard University Press March 1999, 448 pages, $24.95 [3 April 2008] by Judy BermanWhy wouldn't they burn out instead of fade away? Berman examines the sad spectacle of punk-rock reunions and shows how they destroy the two elements that actually made punk attractive: sex appeal and impermanence.
Related articles
Review: The Shape of Things to Come by Greil MarcusErika Nanes14.Feb.08 Convinced as I was by Marcus' readings, I couldn't help noticing that the primary subjects of all four chapters were works produced by white men: Philip Roth, David Lynch, Bill Pullmanm and David Thomas. 
Review: Rip It Up and Start Again: Post-Punk 1978-1984 by Simon ReynoldsAlison Neale21.Oct.05 Focusing primarily on British and American music between 1978 and 1984, Reynolds emphasizes the idea that the glossed-over post-punk years were not marginal to the history of rock: they actually spawned a range of sounds that were more revolutionary than punk itself and that left a far more significant legacy, laying the foundations for the subsequent emergence of alternative music in all its myriad forms. 
Review: Like a Rolling Stone: Bob Dylan at the Crossroads by Greil MarcusJustin Cober-Lake20.May.05 Like a Rolling Stone is not great cultural analysis or musical study, but it's a work that's both insightful and fantastic.
|
|
What you seem to forget is that for many, if not all, of the reunited punk bands just genuinely like playing music. Perhaps the media made more of the scene and the trend in 1977 than the bands themselves would have liked. They very likely formed their bands originally because they just wanted to play music. Why shouldn’t they be able to continue doing this now and at the same time finally make a little money off the music. Sure, it’s not going to be just like it was in 1977, but aren’t you older now too and able to appreciate it as music and not just a reliving of the punk lifestyle?
Comment by ca — April 3, 2008 @ 9:47 am