The Beatles - “I Saw Her Standing There”
After recently hearing for the first time the manic Beatles song “It Won’t Be Long”, I realized that I needed to absorb their entire catalogue and write about it. So this is my attempt at it, beginning with the start of Please Please Me and ending at the conclusion of Let It Be. Wish me luck.
+ + +
It’s only appropriate that the opening song of the Beatles’ debut album Please Please Me starts with an iconic moment. Paul McCartney’s lively count-in (“one, two, three, fahhh”) puts “I Saw Her Standing There” energetically into motion, and what follows are two-plus minutes of joyous pop electricity. Several of the touchstones of early-period Beatles are at work: jaunty riffs, unison vocals, high-pitched “woohs”, and, most delightfully, hand claps (all of which reappear with frenzied effect on the album closer, the untouchable “Twist and Shout”).
The songcraft is economized and straightforward, if not a bit underdeveloped. Paul’s bass line (which evidently came from a Chuck Berry song) tugs and struts along, and blends with John’s rhythm guitar rather seamlessly. Ringo offers a simple-sounding percussive shuffle while George’s guitar work, especially his erratic solo, reveals a burgeoning talent that still isn’t sure how to creatively occupy all its designated space. Combined, it’s the sound of a spirited young band that wants to tweak and refine the templates of rock ‘n’ roll into something distinctly its own.
Lyrically, Paul projects an innocence that isn’t surprising of early ‘60s pop. This was a period when, in song anyway, a mere exchange of glances could spawn love. As Paul sings, “Well she looked at me/ And I, I could see/ That before too long/ I’d fall in love with her”. How carefree and seemingly puritan. He even vows that this squeeze will be his one and only. Yet examine those lines once more. If you’re swooning over someone after only looking at him or her, the draw is purely physical. And I must confess that my instinctive response to the song’s introductory lines “Well she was just 17 / You know what I mean” is “No, Paul, I’m not quite sure what you mean”. It’s uncertain how cryptic and suggestive he’s aiming to be. So perhaps Paul was smuggling touches of sexuality into what seems like a sweet, if hasty, courtship. It’s also possible that the lines simply work as efficient pop couplets and are not intentionally fraught with matters between-the-sheets.
So the subtle intrigue of the lyric is amusing. But the rousing rock ‘n’ roll sounds are clearly the magnetic attraction of “I Saw Her Standing There”.
Comments
I believe the lyrics “Well she was just 17/You know what I mean” were originally “Well she was just 17/The homecoming queen”. And it was thought that line was pretty cheesy, even for then. And the line that replaced it, “You know what I mean” was definitely meant to invoke something suggestive without actually saying it (which you couldn’t then anyway). I don’t remember where I read that. It was in some Beatle book or McCartney book. Somebody else may have an exact citation. But I believe it was an intentionally suggestive lyric.
Comment by Pat — September 9, 2008 @ 4:06 pm
Steve Turner’s “A Hard Day’s Write” is probably the source of the explanation for the implied double meaning of ‘you know what I mean.’ It’s a great book for the accepted stories behind all of their self-composed songs.
Comment by Mike — September 9, 2008 @ 5:30 pm
Who Care ?? Its still a great song written by a teenage genius . and one of the best opening songs in rock and roll..
Comment by henry from usa — September 9, 2008 @ 9:49 pm
Lennon offered the “You know what I mean” substitution for McCartney’s original lyric - I think it was “she’d never been a beauty queen,” actually - because he found it not up to the standard they held their material to. McCartney agreed and history was made.
That was the great synergy of Lennon and McCartney; chemistry can’t be manufactured by “American Idol” or a management company.
Comment by Joe from USA — September 9, 2008 @ 10:40 pm
There ARE no “unison vocals” in this tune. Unison means singing the same part at the same time. In this song, Paul sings the “A” section, and John sings the lower harmony on the “B” section.
Comment by Jan from NJ from NJ — September 10, 2008 @ 12:24 pm
Welcome to Beatlemania!
Richard Thompson has recorded “It Won’t Be Long” in his 1000-year history of popular music, calling it an ultimate pop song.
The craft of Lennon and McCartney’s songwriting certainly did evolve over time. Krikey! Imagine where they went in only five years, breaking new ground, and leaving memorable music for us all to enjoy forever!
Roll over, Beethoven! .... and tell Tchaikovsky the news!
Comment by Ken from San Francisco from CALIFORNIA — September 10, 2008 @ 1:58 pm
Beatles are on of the best bands of all time!
Comment by stock trading from MA — November 5, 2008 @ 10:28 am
I am pretty young and I adore the Beatles! They rock! They have and always will be awesome! {:-)
Comment by double meaning sms from India — December 16, 2008 @ 12:10 pm