Fringe: Season Two Premiere

Regular airtime: Thursdays, 9pm ET (Fox)

Cast: Anna Torv, John Noble, Joshua Jackson, Lance Reddick, Kirk Acevedo, Jasika Nicole, Blair Brown, Leonard Nimoy

US release date: 17 September 2009

By Lesley Smith

Odd-Ball

The bar was high for the second season premiere of Fringe. Not only did it have to tantalize aficionados with new angles on characters and provocative twists on long-running plot lines. It also had to tempt first-time drop-ins to enmesh themselves in the ongoing personal relationships, philosophical debates, and existential challenges. Fringe met the needs of fans and newbies alike with plotting aplomb, allied to its trademark mix of sharply directed action and self-deprecating wit.

As the premiere opened last week, the FBI’s Fringe Division, charged with investigating “a mysterious sequence of unexplained phenomena suggestive of someone or something performing experiments in the world,” was again under threat. At the same time, Olivia (Anna Torv) had just visited an alternate universe that Walter (John Noble) had long claimed existed. The episode began with familiar elements: a car accident, a missing person, a mad scientist, and an amnesiac’s warning regarding the fate of the human race. But then the missing person catapulted out of an empty car through its windscreen, and the scientist turned out to be high on hallucinogenic cocktails. Suddenly the clichés blossomed into people whose fates one might like to know.

For fans, the alchemy deepened. Instead of the ice-cold protagonist of the first series, Olivia returned traumatized from her visit to the universe where the Twin Towers still stand. Confined to a hospital bed, she was more vulnerable both to external threats and emotional intimacy, particularly with Peter (Joshua Jackson). Unlike her TV predecessors, Olivia is not moved by transcendent belief or duty. Uncertainty hurts her. In this, she and Walter are very alike, although her passion has driven her to federal investigative work and his ultimately condemned him to a mental hospital. As her backstory as a child subject of Walter’s much earlier experiments at Harvard emerged in the first series, the trust they shared seemed both more explicable and more mysterious. Unfortunately, the season premiere sidelined of this relationship, with Olivia confined to hospital and Walter immersed in his laboratory. 

On the plus side, Peter demonstrated some of the action-man skills he culled during his previous life as a dodgy dealer in the world’s trouble spots—without losing his wry humor. When a new FBI agent asked if his father was crazy, he answered, “Of course.” By the same token, as soon as he repeated out loud Walter’s latest theory (that a shape-shifting soldier who travelled from a parallel universe committed a series of murders), Peter admitted that he couldn’t believe what he just said. Serving as the slightly skeptical viewer’s surrogate, Peter’s is a voice of reason compelled by a sense of responsibility, affection, and the lack of alternatives, to protect his father and Olivia, the woman who recruited him to the Fringe Division by blackmail and has since become his friend.

When Olivia unknowingly repeated the last words Peter’s mother whispered to him every night (in Greek, naturally), it became clear that there is no limit to how weird things can get. This edge-walking has ever been both Fringe‘s delight and its potential downfall. As the latter stages of J.J. Abrams’ Lost wound itself into ever more byzantine tangles of history, conspiracy, love, sex, and the paranormal, watching an episode turned into the equivalent of banging one’s head against the wall—it felt so good when one stopped. But if Fringe‘s writers—Abrams, Roberto Orci, and Alex Kurtzman—sustain the sharp wit and swift plotting they managed in this summer’s Star Trek prequel, they might maintain the series’ high-speed, oddball unpredictability.

— 24 September 2009
 
Bookmark and Share

Tagged as: fringe | popmatters pick
Comments

Nice review of the season premiere. But as a longtime <i>Lost</i> fan, I have to take issue with your final paragraph.

First of all, it’s a fallacy (albeit a common one) to lay much of anything about <i>Lost</i> at the feet of JJ Abrams. Despite being a co-creator, he left the show at the end of the first season and has not been involved with it since. So don’t blame or laud him for anything that’s happened in the intervening five seasons.

Second of all, I feel bad for people who have become so frustrated with the twisty, weird storytelling of that show that they’ve given up on it. <i>Lost</i> has always been about getting morsels and being patient, at least for its viewers. There’s still the final season to go, and I’ve been confident all along that everything that needs to be revealed and wrapped up will happen then. Hopefully the show won’t drop the ball and will live up to its full potential as one of the best television series of all time.

Comment by Chris Conaton from Houston, TX — September 24, 2009 @ 8:02 am

I have to agree with Chris. I didn’t think the new Star Trek was that great [it was more of an action movie than sci-fi], and as far as I’m concerned, Fringe jumped the shark in the first episode and screwed to pooch every episode since. Lost rewards patience, getting piece of the puzzle and often forming your own conclusions and theories. We knew everything about Fringe’s three main characters after a couple episodes, and, of them, only Walter is even remotely interesting. The plot is a rambling bunch of recycled X-Files tacked on itself layer by until it’s disorienting enough to be confused for complex. It’s pure popcorn, and I’m amazed it got renewed.

Comment by Alan Ranta from Vancouver, BC — September 24, 2009 @ 10:44 am

Well, I will take issue with you regarding the overall quality level of Fringe. While the show did fumble its way around the first 8-9 episodes of the first season, the second half steadily improved to the point where the first season finale was very, very good.

And it turns out we didn’t know everything about the three principal characters right from the start, and some of those revelations, especially regarding Peter, were quite cool and should drive a lot of the second season. I feel like the show is settling into what it wants to be and it’s enjoyable on a week-to-week basis. Although I’m curious to find out if they’re still going to be able to balance the episodic with the overarching plot quite as much this season. It seems like the main story arc has gotten quite a bit denser.

Comment by Chris Conaton from Houston, TX — September 24, 2009 @ 11:35 am

Yeah, to be fair, I only made it four episodes in. I didn’t want to stick around to find out why Brad from Boston Legal wasn’t dead. I hate that guy, and I was glad to see him die in the first episode, but no, he just had to come back. I get enough of that sh!t in Lost.

Comment by Alan Ranta from Vancouver, BC — September 24, 2009 @ 1:48 pm

Add a comment

Please enter your name and a valid email address. Your email address will not be displayed. It is required only to prevent comment spam.

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?