Quantcast

Call for Feature Essays About Any Aspect of Popular Culture, Present or Past

Books

“Nanny State” is the name given to government policies that treat adults like children and try to protect people from every possible harm or offense, especially from their own choices. Ultimately, it is about control, as shown in David Harsanyi’s new book, Nanny State, which compiles numerous examples of what he terms the “tyranny of the busybody.” The book’s wide range and satiric tone are indicated by its long subtitle: “How Food Fascists, Teetotaling Do-Gooders, Priggish Moralists, and Other Boneheaded Bureaucrats Are Turning America Into a Nation of Children.”


Harsanyi, a columnist for the Denver Post, breaks up his chapters into short sections with headings that mock the nannies who would use legislation or litigation to control the personal behavior of others. Chapter One, “Twinkie Fascists,” contains such headings as “Plump Fiction” and “The War on Cookies.” The text itself is written in the casual, irreverent tone of a biting newspaper column, putting the author’s incredulous outrage on display throughout.


Nanny State‘s greatest value is its detailed cataloguing of nanny proposals, the people pushing them and their tactics. After finishing this book, readers will find it difficult to dismiss as just another nutty isolated incident the report on the evening news about the latest lawsuit against fast-food companies for causing obesity and the claims by lawyers that their clients had no clue that eating Big Macs three meals a day was unhealthy. The ban on trans fats and the attack on Girl Scout cookies are only the beginning. Nannies use the “obesity epidemic” and concern for “the children” to justify all manner of meddling, always for our own good, of course. This paternalistic logic goes far beyond food.


Some nannies don’t want us drinking alcohol, either. They use the pretext of protecting others to try to control the use of alcohol by adults. This includes arresting people for driving with a blood alcohol content far below the legal limit and trying to mandate that every new car have ignition interlocks, forcing people—most of whom have no record of drunken driving—to blow into a Breathalyzer every time they start their cars. In Herndon, Va., police hassled patrons at local bars, whether they owned cars or not, subjecting them to sobriety tests. This was necessary because, as the police chief explained, you “can’t be drunk in a bar.”


Turning adults into children is achieved partly by changing the age at which they become adults. Yet, despite the raising of the drinking age to 21 in 1984 and colleges’ escalating restrictions on alcohol possession by students, a Harvard study “declared binge drinking the single most pressing drug crisis on college campuses.” In the previous sentence, Harsanyi might change “despite” to “because of.” When they treat adults like irresponsible children and make drinking an underground activity, they shouldn’t be surprised when 18-year-olds binge drink. The author argues that this is a consequence of the nannies’ preventing our culture from providing young adults with any other social context for alcohol consumption.


Harsanyi explores myriad other nanny efforts. He examines the anti-smoking movement’s strong-arm tactics as well as its use of dubious statistics about secondhand smoke. He describes a nation increasingly afraid of all risk, and reminds us not only of the war against dodgeball in gym class, but against tag in the school yard. As one school superintendent says, “The idea of loosely running around and chasing each other is not safe.”


Some nannies want to protect us from our own immorality. Hence the police raids on poker games across the nation. And the provision in one state that “made it illegal to sell or produce `any device designed or marketed as useful primarily for the stimulation of human genital organs.’ ” The latter prompts the author to ask a question that applies to nearly the whole book: If this is “within the scope of government regulation, really now, what on God’s Earth isn’t?”

Rating:

Tagged as: david harsanyi
Comments
Now on PopMatters
Short Ends and Leader: Ben Gazzara and The End Of An Aura
Ben Gazzara and The End Of An Aura (Short Ends and Leader) [Wed, 4:30 pm]
Pretty Lights - “We Must Go On” (video) (Mixed Media) [Wed, 12:00 pm]
The other Academy Awards (PopWire) [Wed, 11:35 am]
The Darkness: 1 February 2012 - Toronto (Notes from the Road) [Wed, 11:00 am]
Hot YouTube Trend: People Saying Sh*t (Mixed Media) [Wed, 10:00 am]
The Top 15 Madonna Singles of All Time (Sound Affects) [Wed, 9:00 am]
'Miners' Hymns': Labor and Poetry (Reviews) [Wed, 7:15 am]
  1. The Hidden Mythos of 'Police Academy' (Features)
  2. Batman Is Boring in ‘Arkham City’ (Columns)
  3. 10 Songs That Will Make You Love U2 (Sound Affects)
  4. Slipped Discs 2011 - Part 1: From 13Ghosts to Friendly Fires (Features)
  5. 'Nebraska': Bruce Springsteen's 'Heart of Darkness' (Columns)
  6. The Best Games of 2011 (Features)
  7. Not-So-Central Casting: Kevin Smith and the Birth of the Reality Podcast (Features)
  8. Counterbalance No. 66: Carole King’s 'Tapestry' (Sound Affects)
  9. The 10 Greatest Movie Spies Ever (Short Ends and Leader)
  10. 'Amy' Is a Horror Game That Is Broken in All the Right Ways (Moving Pixels)
  11. Make-Believe Rock Star: An Interview with Anthony Green (Features)
  12. Slipped Discs 2011 - Part 2: From the Go! Team to the Phoenix Foundation (Features)
  13. Slipped Discs 2011 - Part 3: From Real Estate to Youth Lagoon (Features)
  14. Different Flavored Skulls: An Intimate Chat with the Flaming Lips' Wayne Coyne (Features)
  15. Lamb of God: Resolution (Reviews)
  16. Lana Del Rey: Born to Die (Reviews)
  17. 'Library After Air Raid': On the Survival of Culture Amid the Barbarity of War (Columns)
  18. The Future Is a Faded Song: Douglas Rushkoff on the Groundbreaking "ADD" (Features)
  19. Get Off of My Cloud!: 'Collecting' Music in the Digital Age (Features)
  20. Alcest: Les Voyages De L'Âme (Reviews)
  21. Leonard Cohen: Old Ideas (Reviews)
  22. The 10 Greatest Shakespeare Film Adaptations of All Time (Short Ends and Leader)
  23. Google and the Production of Curiosity (Marginal Utility)
  24. Carole E. Barrowman’s Authorial Journey to Hollow Earth (Features)
  25. The Top 15 Madonna Singles of All Time (Sound Affects)
  26. Tower Songs: Townes Van Zandt (Columns)
  27. Black Bananas: Rad Times Xpress IV (Reviews)
  28. The Gay Ole Countryside (Columns)
  29. Of Montreal: Paralytic Stalks (Reviews)
  30. 'Namath': Broadway Joe Looks Back (Reviews)
PM Picks
Books Archive
Announcements
Ratings

10 - The Best of the Best

9 - Very Nearly Perfect

8 - Excellent

7 - Damn Good

6 - Good

5 - Average

4 - Unexceptional

3 - Weak

2 - Seriously Flawed

1 - Terrible

© 1999-2012 PopMatters.com. All rights reserved.
PopMatters.com™ and PopMatters™ are trademarks
of PopMatters Media, Inc.

PopMatters is wholly independently owned and operated.
PopMatters is a member of BUZZMEDIA Music, MOG and Guardian Select.