Quantcast

Call for Music Critics and Music Bloggers

Music
cover art

Under the Influence of Giants

Under the Influence of Giants

(Island; US: 8 Aug 2006; UK: 17 Jul 2006)

Rarely has a band name been so unerringly accurate. If you’ve heard of Under the Influence of Giants, it’s probably because you’ve encountered their debut single, “Mama’s Room”, on rotation on MTV2 or your local AOR station. That song presents a fairly representative cross-section of the group’s sound: clipped, dancefloor-ready percussion, driving bass, sparse guitar and light-rock orchestral flourishes, leavened throughout by a gratingly familiar falsetto vocal line. I say familiar because, well, you’d be hard pressed to hear “Mama’s Room” and not immediately be reminded of the Bee-Gees. Under the influence of giants, indeed.


Perhaps it isn’t lead vocalist Aaron Bruno’s fault that he is such a dead-ringer for the brothers Gibb. It doesn’t help matters that the producers insist on swaddling the vocal lines in the kind of sticky-sweet stacked harmonies with which the Bee-Gees made their fame. It would be one thing if the band didn’t seem like they were going out of their way, on song after song, to write songs and create arrangements specifically designed to place Bruno’s voice in a startlingly retro context. It perhaps says something about the state of contemporary rock that such a retro turn doesn’t sound particularly out of place. In many ways, Under the Influence of Giants is a thoroughly contemporary group: the record has the kind of shiny exterior that listeners have come to expect from High Quality Rock Product in the year 2006. Funk basslines and disco beats have been “back” for years; there have even been sporadic appearances of horn sections. The individual ingredients may seem modern, but the overall effect is unequivocally a pastiche, a modern updating of some very old templates.


And it’s not even as if they’re the first people to do so in recent years. Rock has long since made peace with funk and dance, but not quite with the specific sound of disco: it’s OK to be down with the Gang of Four and New Order and Parliament, but not so much Donna Summer. There’s been something of a neo-disco revival in the underground these last few years, spearheaded by labels like Gomma, but the only mainstream group to embrace the sound has been the Scissor Sisters. Looking at things from the perspective of a hit-hungry record company, it’s easy to see the appeal of Under the Influence of Giants: they sound just like the Scissor Sisters, only without the queer overtones that have (arguably) kept the band from hitting the big time in the United States (even after they’ve become huge everywhere else).


Perhaps I should rephrase that: they sound just like the Scissor Sisters, only without any of the energy and charm, sort of like how the Black Crowes sound just like the early ‘70s Rolling Stones, if the early ‘70s Rolling Stones sucked. Is that harsh? Perhaps. But once you get past the generally agreeable, if relentlessly imitative “Mama’s Room”, you’re stuck with an album of incredibly boring and uninspired formulaic retro crap. You want a slower power ballad, a la “How Deep Is Your Love”, with some John Bonham drumming thrown in? “Stay Illogical” will certainly fit the bill. How about an uptempo rocker that brings to mind Pulp’s “Disco 2000” without any of the wit? “In The Clouds” is the track for you. They’ve even got a downbeat, slightly expansive closing track, incorporating extended breakbeats and synthesizer riffs, “Meaningless Love”.


It would be an exaggeration to call Under the Influence of Giants a bad band, because there’s just not enough substance here to qualify as either bad or good. Their debut is so derivative that the overall effect is little more substantial than gossamer. They have a keen grasp of their influences, but that’s about it. Like Jet, they do what they do well enough, but there’s no reason why anyone should care.

Rating:

Comments
Now on PopMatters
Mommy Fearest: 'We Need to Talk About Kevin' (Blu-ray) (Short Ends and Leader) [Wed, 12:30 pm]
2012 Nelsonville Music Festival (Notes from the Road) [Wed, 12:00 pm]
20 Questions: Hannibal Buress (Sound Affects) [Wed, 11:00 am]
Cannes 2012: 'Reality' + 'In the Fog' (Reviews) [Wed, 8:08 am]
Love, and Other Indelible Stains (Columns) [Wed, 2:00 am]
Sigur Rós: Valtari (Reviews) [Wed, 2:00 am]
Lemonade: Diver (Reviews) [Wed, 2:00 am]
Cory Branan: Mutt (Reviews) [Wed, 2:00 am]
Big Science: Difficulty (Capsule Reviews) [Wed, 2:00 am]
  1. The Top 10 Overplayed Songs You Hate by Artists You Love (Sound Affects)
  2. Tea with 'Sherlock': Investigating the Investigators (Features)
  3. Sunk? This 'Battleship' Stunk! (Short Ends and Leader)
  4. Tenacious D: Rize of the Fenix (Reviews)
  5. 10 Pieces of Cinematic Art That Require Revisiting (Short Ends and Leader)
  6. She's a Rainbow: A Tribute to Donna Summer (Features)
  7. Punk Rock's Pet Sounds: An Interview with Bomb the Music Industry! (Features)
  8. Counterbalance No. 82: U2's 'Achtung Baby' (Sound Affects)
  9. 'Albatross': A Not-So-Weighty Coming-of-Age Meets Mid-Life-Crisis Film (Reviews)
  10. The 10 Greatest Aspects of the 'Star Wars' Franchise (Short Ends and Leader)
  11. Counterbalance No. 83: The Stooges' 'Fun House' (Sound Affects)
  12. We Will Avenge Them Or… Be Avenged?: The Individual in the US Experience (Features)
  13. The Queen and Her Crayons: An Interview With Donna Summer (Features)
  14. Early Summer 2012 New Music Playlist (Mixed Media)
  15. Killer Mike: R.A.P. Music (Reviews)
  16. The Best Canadian Records of the Year? The Fun Agony of Voting for the Polaris Prize Long List (Sound Affects)
  17. Sherlock Holmes, Dirk Gently and the Case of the Eccentric Detective (Columns)
  18. Flash Points: Mommy's Breast, Marriage Equality and Why Chipotle Is King (Features)
  19. Sergio Leone: Something to Do with Death (Columns)
  20. In Support of Supports (Moving Pixels)
  21. Saint Etienne: Words and Music (Reviews)
  22. Flash Points: Chicks, Sluts and Facebook (Features)
  23. In Defense Of... Rock Radio: A Force in Popular Culture (Columns)
  24. Garbage: Not Your Kind of People (Reviews)
  25. The Cult: Choice of Weapon (Reviews)
  26. Willie Nelson: Heroes (Reviews)
  27. The Walkmen: Heaven (Reviews)
  28. 'People's Pornography': The Mundanities of Pornography and Surveillance Culture (Reviews)
  29. Feeling '80s Spirit: Post-Hardcore Punk for the Plastic Generation (Columns)
  30. Various Artists: Occupy This Album (Reviews)
PM Picks
Music Archive
Announcements
Ratings

10 - The Best of the Best

9 - Very Nearly Perfect

8 - Excellent

7 - Damn Good

6 - Good

5 - Average

4 - Unexceptional

3 - Weak

2 - Seriously Flawed

1 - Terrible

© 1999-2012 PopMatters.com. All rights reserved.
PopMatters.com™ and PopMatters™ are trademarks
of PopMatters Media, Inc.

PopMatters is wholly independently owned and operated.
PopMatters is a member of BUZZMEDIA Music, MOG and Guardian Select.