Call for Essays About Any Aspect of Popular Culture, Present or Past


What's the Appeal of 'Dancing With the Stars'?

Bookmark and Share
Wednesday, May 25, 2011
I've tried to appreciate the courage it takes for non-dancing D-lister's to perform outside their comfort zone. Really, I have.

Dancing With the Stars

Cast: Bruno Tonioli, Carrie Ann Inaba, Len Goodman, Brooke Burke, Tom Bergeron
Regular airtime: Tuesdays, 8pm


Review [26.Mar.2007]
Review [10.Jan.2006]
Review [11.Jul.2005]

Dancing With The Stars recently reached its climactic finalé for its 12th season but I wonder, what’s the show’s appeal? Along with American Idol, Dancing With the Stars is the most popular talent competition on television. It was the top rated show for Fall 2010 and contributed to ABC’s second place finish among the networks for the same time period. It’s loved by millions. Except me.   

I’ve tried to like it. I’ve tried to get excited about watching celebrities I’ve forgotten about or don’t know, as they ballroom dance in tight, sparkly outfits. I’ve tried to love how the judges whip up their scorecards with military zeal. I’ve tried to enjoy the forced banter between the hosts. I’ve even tried to appreciate the courage it takes for non-dancing D-lister’s to perform outside their comfort zone. Really, I have.
So to better understand what I’m missing, I decided to break the show down into its two component parts: dancing and stars.

Dance is about grace, strength and skill. It can be beautiful, provocative and sometimes, amazing. From what I’ve seen of Dancing With the Stars, none of these adjectives apply to the performances. If a compliment is used, it’s mostly reserved for the celebrities who have a dance background. Maybe if the show was called Learning to Dance With the Stars, I could get on-board and possibly appreciate the behind the scenes rehearsal footage where the stars complain, cry and repeatedly tell us how tough it all is. Maybe the appeal is the struggle to master routines.

As for the stars, it could be intriguing to watch celebrities not excel at everything they do. But for this to be true we’d have to be watching actual stars. This season, the show gave us actors whose spotlights dimmed decades ago, a woman only familiar to the Disney demographic, another who is famous for being the former girlfriend of an octogenarian and an L.A. radio host who calls himself ‘Psycho Mike’ while giving out relationship advice with Dr. Drew. Here’s the thing. If large numbers of the public have to consult Wikipedia to figure out the cast, they might not qualify as actual ‘stars’.

If the show is about learning, not dancing, and features people who have name recognition not stardom, why do people watch?

Maybe it’s for the competition. Viewers love a fight, whether it’s a fight to be the best at something or an old-fashioned brawl. Audiences want to cheer for their favorite. More importantly, they want to vote for their favorite and that’s what Dancing With The Stars offers. Like American Idol, it’s about giving the audience control and power over someone’s fate. When that someone happens to be a media personality (however faded) who inspires like and dislike, it’s even more powerful.

For me, however, the most powerful thing that Dancing With the Stars offers is the opportunity to change the channel.

Tagged as: american idol
Kirstie Alley Performs in Week One of Season 12 to a PC mangled Cee-Lo Green Song
Related Articles
14 Dec 2011
It's been over 70 years since Lili Elbe underwent the first gender reassignment surgery, so isn't it time that media in so-called 'advanced' cultures began to recognize the presence of trans persons in its midst?
21 Sep 2011
Once again, Dancing With the Stars celebrates big personalities and finds drama in its contradictory politics of casting and voting, not to mention dancing.
28 Sep 2010
Which is she, empowered teen or soiled dove? What image does Bristol want to sell and why sell one at all?
21 Sep 2010
The predictability of the cast is their Achilles' heel. Ronnie and Sammi’s weekly dysfunctional hour of make-up/break-up is as expected as Snooki’s alcohol soaked antics and the Situation’s Sunday dinner of sausage and peppers.
Now on PopMatters
PM Picks

© 1999-2015 All rights reserved.™ and PopMatters™ are trademarks
of PopMatters Media, Inc.

PopMatters is wholly independently owned and operated.