What does it say about a pair of filmmakers when the five titles you choose to leave off a considered career overview contain at least one masterpiece (their adaptation of True Grit) and two terrific examples of their aesthetic reach (The Man Who Wasn’t There and Burn After Reading). Indeed, when discussing the Coen Brothers, only a couple of their movies warrant instant dismissal, and even then, both Intolerable Cruelty and their remake of The Ladykillers have their positives and their patrons. Of course, some may argue that any or all of these leftovers actually belong in the heralded halls of this Top 10, and that any number of the selections made herein are half-baked and ill-advised. To each his or her own.
Truth is, it’s almost impossible to fathom the track record of these remarkable filmmakers. Fifteen movies since their early ‘80s start, and very few, if any are true artistic flops. In fact, many would argue that they’ve made more masterworks than misfires, and that even their ‘failures’ are far better than anything the standard studio system creates. They aren’t just artists. They’re the very definition of an auteur. So in celebration of their catalog finally coming to Blu-ray (Blood Simple, Raising Arizona, and Miller’s Crossing are new to the format this week), we rank the brothers incredibly output. Placement be damned… when it comes to the Coens, almost everything is a classic, beginning with this unusual entry…
If Barton Fink was a meditation on writer’s block and the ditzy demands of the Hollywood studio system, then this is their take on religion, fate, faith, and belief. Tagging their own personal dogma—Judaism—and tying it to the rising counterculture of the ‘60s, the result is a warped world view that suggests that God is not only vengeful, but petty, spiteful, and imbued with a wicked sense of humor. From the adulterous wife who makes her husband feel guilty for the betrayal to the relative with a seeping pus wart on the back of his neck, the Brothers always find a way to make the ridiculous seem reverent. Here, it’s almost holy.
With a little help from pal Sam Raimi in the script department, the boys went back to the screwball roots of Tinseltown comedy to create one of the greatest epic experiments in humor ever. Everything in this film is big—the opening suicide of Warring Hudsucker, the boardroom where the corporate ruse is concocted, the basement mail machine that Norville Barnes ‘advances’ from, the canvas of a late ‘50s NYC. Everything is also very arch and reference oriented. Clearly some viewers didn’t get the joke. Of all the Coen Brothers films, this is one that remains either a clear fan favorite or a best forgotten failure.
With its combination of star power (George Clooney) and its roots revival music, this became one of Coens first commercial hits. Before, they were always considered arthouse darlings exclusively. But thanks to their lead, and the likable take on “Man of Constant Sorrow,” the mainstream sat up and took notice. Using the epic poem The Odyssey by Homer as a jumping off point, the duo delivered a kind of redneck reinvention of the road movie, a combination of the past and present with each element flawlessly intertwined into the next. That it connected beyond the critical crowd argues for the boys’ brilliance as artists.
As their second full length feature, the Coens decided to avoid another noirish murder mystery and, instead, make an all out ‘classic’ comedy. Settling on a story about a childless couple who abduct a local quintuplet, they developed a collection of insane characters and then put them through some incredibly complex situations. As a result, they expanded their motion picture playbook while utilizing the skills that had served them so well previously. With flawless performances from an amazing cast (Nicolas Cage and Holly Hunter have NEVER been better) and direction which circles the oddball action like a hungry coyote, this triumph marked the beginning of an unbelievable string of successes.
The one that started it all. The film that caught critics off guard and turn fans into fanatics. The brothers were just another novelty when they introduced this seedy, sinister thriller to unsuspecting audiences, and as they like to say, the rest is cinematic history. Aside from the magnificent script, on point performances and innovative direction, the movie managed the near impossible—it found a way to turn the tired old story of an unfaithful wife, a suspicious husband, and the dirty private dick hired to uncover the crime of passion into something Shakespearean. As a benchmark and a blueprint, it remains one of their best.
We all know how critical it is to keep independent voices alive and strong on the Internet. Please consider a donation to support our work as independent cultural critics and historians. Your donation will help PopMatters stay viable through these changing and challenging times. Thanks everyone.