Call for Music Writers... Rock, Indie, Urban, Electronic, Americana, Metal, World and More

Toronto International Film Festival 2011: 'Pearl Jam Twenty'

Bookmark and Share
Text:AAA
Wednesday, Sep 14, 2011
Documentaries made by non-documentarians can be exhilarating since, new to the form, the filmmakers tend to break old rules and push into interesting territory. But they can also wind up looking something like Pearl Jam Twenty.

PEARL JAM TWENTY
Director: Cameron Crowe
Cast: Jeff Ament, Stone Gossard, Mike McCready, Eddie Vedder, Matt Cameron, Chris Cornell, Kurt Cobain, Neil Young
Country: USA
 
Documentaries made by non-documentarians can be exhilarating since, new to the form, the filmmakers tend to break old rules and push into interesting territory. But they can also wind up looking something like Pearl Jam Twenty. Confusing (even to this follower of the group), scattered, and unaccountably incomplete (one longtime member of the band is never even mentioned aloud!), this one is for fans only.
  
Cameron Crowe stumbles through his documentary like an amateur, missing several clear opportunities to build narrative tension, to get his subjects to open up, or to romance the audience with the music. At one point he gets the band’s frontman Eddie Vedder to start crying while thinking back on meeting bassist Jeff Ament, and then he cuts away. Surely the next question was the important one, and the next answer was going to be powerful; but we’ve moved on. At almost two hours running time, and boasting some pretty amazing access to old home videos, one-on-one interviews, and live footage, Crowe certainly had enough time and material to do more.


But, the most egregious problem with the film is that it is quite disrespectfully lopsided. While the group’s formative years are discussed in detail, their struggles with sudden fame are explored, their battle against Ticketmaster fleshed out, and the horror of the Roskilde Festival (when several fans were crushed to death at the front of the stage) is revisited, those things all happened in the first ten years of the band’s existence. But, this is Pearl Jam Twenty.


Quite weirdly, none of their records since 2000 are mentioned other than in passing, very little post-2000 material is discussed (aside from an anti-George W. Bush number that they rarely play), and one is generally given the message that Pearl Jam’s first ten years were worthy of careful consideration while the next ten years were a time that also happened. There’s great music throughout, though, and the film winds up with an absolutely thrilling bit of editing magic over a kaleidoscopic guitar solo from Mike McCreedy on the arena powerhouse “Alive”.


 


Rating:

Related Articles
5 Jun 2014
Two decades on, Superunknown remains a landmark album and the formidable Soundgarden played the entirety of it at a club show in New York.
By Sean Issofresh
27 Nov 2013
Photographer Sean Issofresh was on hand for us at the Voodoo Music + Arts Experience in New Orleans to capture some of the fest's greatest moments.
25 Oct 2013
Twenty-three years in, Pearl Jam may no longer be grunge. They may no longer be young. But the band took the Barclays Center by storm and sold out two nights.
13 Oct 2013
Lightning Bolt is sure to rank among one of the high points of Pearl Jam’s discography, standing as an example of their ability to burrow down and hone all of their strengths to a fever pitch.
Comments
Now on PopMatters
PM Picks
Announcements

© 1999-2014 PopMatters.com. All rights reserved.
PopMatters.com™ and PopMatters™ are trademarks
of PopMatters Media, Inc.

PopMatters is wholly independently owned and operated.