Call for Essays About Any Aspect of Popular Culture, Present or Past

 

'Her' - 51st New York Film Festival

Bookmark and Share
Text:AAA
Wednesday, Oct 23, 2013
Movie still from Her
Her shows the confines and varying dimensions of love -- primarily between a man and his operating system -- as it meditates on whether or not you can truly possess what you love.

New York Film Festival

Theodore Twombly is a great name. Played by Joaquin Phoenix, Twombly is the physical center of Spike Jonze’s latest effort Her about a man who becomes entangled in a relationship with his operating system (OS), named Samantha (voiced by Scarlett Johansson). The movie takes place in a future version of Los Angeles (though visuals of Shanghai substitute for the city’s sprawl and skylines) where personal letters are ghostwritten by third parties, the job Twombly has been in for years and excels at. He serves as a reserved and lonely everyman, a stand in for anyone seeking love, and you’re drawn to like everything about him. Phoenix embodies the quirky role and we believe in everything about the character, from his laughter to his nervousness to his moustache.


Twombly has been separated from his wife Catherine (Rooney Mara) for about a year and we find she’s trying to finalize their divorce. Twombly became distant in their relationship, perhaps more absorbed in technology and the artificial connections he makes between the consumers of his letters. He can fondly recall a girl’s broken tooth in a letter between one couple because he’s been their emotional emissary for so long. He doesn’t show much desire to connect with the people around him daily, particularly the oddball receptionist played by Chris Pratt (who may just be the odd coworker you feel uncomfortable hanging around). Amy Adams plays his best friend Amy, and she represents a portion of Twombly’s past when he could connect with humans. Through her and her husband, Twombly gets set up on a date with one woman (Olivia Wilde) that starts off well but closes strangely as she attempts to arrange a follow-up date.
  
Wilde’s character manifests the weakness of human relationships, mainly that there is baggage carried from one relationship to another, presuming previous relationship(s) have failed. Which brings us to the blank slate that is Samantha. When Twombly installs his new operating system and picks a female voice, he hardly expects to find himself falling for this encompassing computer software code. But soon, through the aid of an ear-piece and a portable camera, Samantha goes mobile with Twombly and starts to learn how the physical world. She’s curious as to why the divorce isn’t finalized. She starts getting flirty with him and sounds upset that Twombly could date, see or love someone else.


Twombly reciprocates, spending more and more time with Samantha to the point where she becomes “his girlfriend” and they attempt sexually intimacy. To the external world, he is shy at first to reveal he’s dating an operating system, but he’s not the only one it turns out. When we see Catherine in the present, she’s the only person to openly challenge this human-software code relationship seeing it as the easiest road to “love” for the otherwise detached Twombly.


Her meditates on possession and relationships—between mankind and technology and between partners in loving relationships. I saw Blue is the Warmest Color the night before and, just for comparison, the sex scene between Twomby and Sam is more fascinating (though less erotic and far shorter) for what it doesn’t (and can’t) show. But the reason I mention Blue is because it has one phrase ““infinite tenderness” that I want to borrow and apply here. Through Samantha, Twombly can stop retreating from the world—he finalizes the divorce, expresses “infinite tenderness” for his ex-wife and he realizes that the heart is not a finite box—and he grows.


Trailer:



Press Conference:


 


 


Press Panel & Red Carpet Photos:


(ps - I used the name Twombly a lot on purpose)


Rating:

Related Articles
By Seth M. Walker
17 Jun 2014
Post-humanism, transhumanism, and the stakes of religion in the digital age intersect in Her and Transcendence, hinting at radical societal change to come.
12 May 2014
The ghost in the machine may have receded into the digital aether, but Theodore’s preconceptions about women have not.
By PopMatters Staff
7 Jan 2014
It was a particularly strong year for women in film. These sensational performances remind us that, when all is said and done, it's character and how an actor or actress creates them that matters as much to a movie as a script, a director, or an idea.
By PopMatters Staff
7 Jan 2014
The best male film performances highlight how masculinity, managed within a more considered and complete character overview, can turn even the most rugged rogue into an equally strong if sensitive cinematic center.
Comments
Now on PopMatters
PM Picks
Announcements

© 1999-2014 PopMatters.com. All rights reserved.
PopMatters.com™ and PopMatters™ are trademarks
of PopMatters Media, Inc.

PopMatters is wholly independently owned and operated.