Call for Music Writers... Rock, Indie, Hip-hop, R&B, Electronic, Americana, Metal, World and More

cover art

The Most Serene Republic

Fantasick Impossibliss

(Home of the Rebels/Arts & Crafts; US: 4 May 2010; UK: 4 May 2010)

What a title. Only the Most Serene Republic, the Milton, Ontario-based sextet most famous for being the Robin to Broken Social Scene’s Batman, could have dreamt up a phrase as simultaneously polarizing and fascinating. Fantasick Impossibliss the album, meanwhile, is equally polarizing and fascinating, offering up a pummeling 26 minutes of frenzied indie prog that actually earns the title.

If you’re already a fan, the description is old news. The Most Serene Republic are seasoned, with three full-lengths and one criminally overlooked EP (2006’s stellar tour-only Phages) under their belts. However, Fantasick is a jolt, even to the acquainted. Here, a raw, powerful full-band attack dominates, stepping back from the kaleidoscopic chamber pop of last year’s David Newfeld-produced ...And the Ever Expanding Universe.

That album found the band trying their hand at accessibility… well, their definition of it, at least, downplaying the layered instrumental ferocity of 2007’s layered prog behemoth Population in favor of a more laid-back feel that, for once, actually merited the Broken Social Scene comparisons. They even delivered a full-fledged, if still warped, pop song with the banjo-driven “Heavens to Purgatory”. After the release of Universe, vocalist/guitarist Emma Ditchburn left the band, and the game of musical drum chairs was abandoned with the addition of percussionist Adam Balsam.

The intensity of Fantasick could be viewed as a reaction to the quiet rumblings of Universe, an explosion of the tension built up on that album. Maybe it could be attributed to the fact that the band is made up of just dudes now. Whatever the reason, Fantasick finds the Most Serene Republic back doing what they do best: creating heady, majestic, instrumentally and emotionally complex workouts that are as muscular as they are intelligent.

With “Jelly Chamber”, the band sets a new peak, with vocalist/trombonist Adrian Jewett reaching skyward, reflecting on birth and sex (“Could it be remembered? / the time in jelly chamber / if recalled hard enough / years are spent to discover that feel!”) over a tsunami of percussion, thick bass, and strings. Not only one of the Most Serene Republic’s best tracks, it’s one of the most exciting and devastating things you’ll hear all year.

Elsewhere, the band offers a singalong satire of drunk culture (“Pink Noise”), some more spooky-great prog (“Comeuppance”, “The Ache of Goon”), and “The Church of Acorns”, which features the line, “Where are all the squirrels that die of natural causes? / do they hold service in the church of acorns?” Some will still find Jewett’s observations impenetrable. For the likeminded, it’s one-of-a-kind stuff that’ll keep you glued to the speakers, pining and analyzing the unusual details. Ditto the music.

By the time the title track ends the set with a suffocating six minutes of Radiohead-inflected space jazz (check out Jewett channeling Thom Yorke’s claustrophobia via “The National Anthem”), you’ll be too head-spun to notice that maybe it goes on a couple minutes more than it needs to. This is prog, anyway, remember? And this is only a warm-up. They’re currently working on a full-length sequel. If Fantasick Impossibliss is any indication, it’s sure to be pretty spectacular. For now, they’ll have to settle for one of the year’s best releases, regardless of length.


Ryan Reed is an Adjunct English Professor, English Department Graduate Assistant, and freelance music critic/journalist with degrees in English and Journalism. In addition to serving as an Associate Music Editor/Music Writer with PopMatters, he contributes reviews, feature stories, and other work to Billboard, Paste, American Songwriter, Boston Phoenix, Relix, Blurt, Metro Pulse, Cleveland Scene, and a handful of others. If you want to contact him for any reason, send an e-mail to rreed6128[at]

Related Articles
9 Sep 2010
Swiping movies scores from Jon Brion? Smoking up with Michael Bublé? Crafting album titles out of Lewis Carroll-inspired word games? Vocalist Adrian Jewett talks to PopMatters about his band's Juno nomination, it's never-ending stream of EPs, and finally getting a Jewish drummer.
24 Aug 2010
Most people don't know the Most Serene Republic, but even those who do may have missed this 2006 EP -- quite possibly their most coherent and spellbinding statement.
16 Jul 2009
Techno beats and female vocal choirs merge with '80s synth keyboards and pocket orchestras to create the Most Serene Republic's most sonically overstimulated, instensely replayable album of their young career.
3 Dec 2007
Ryan Lenssen nearly had his hands cut off, made his bandmates re-record the same album three times over, and says that their latest album wouldn't have been possible without the help of Ayn Rand.

discussion by
Now on PopMatters
PM Picks

© 1999-2015 All rights reserved.™ and PopMatters™ are trademarks
of PopMatters Media, Inc.

PopMatters is wholly independently owned and operated.