Call for Essays About Any Aspect of Popular Culture, Present or Past

Music
cover art

Adam Haworth Stephens

We Live on Cliffs

(Saddle Creek; US: 28 Sep 2010; UK: 28 Sep 2010)

I am finding it difficult to begin this review of Adam Haworth Stephen’s debut solo release We Live on Cliffs, so perhaps I should begin by saying, I’m not particularly moved by this record.  That’s not to say that it’s a bad record. On the contrary, it’s actually a very well written, adequately produced and ably performed pop/folk/rock album.  The biggest problem I’ve discovered is that from beginning to end there is little variation, and when there is, it’s almost expected, clichéd even.  As a result, it is difficult to penetrate this record.  It’s also difficult to discuss.  How do you write about a record toward which you feel indifferent?  I will try to step lightly. 


Stephens is one part of the duo Two Gallants, touring and creating music together since 2002.  We Live on Cliffs is Stephens’ first effort on his own, and the result is a good record that is simply bland.  There is nothing here that warrants more than a few listens. Simultaneously, there is nothing here to suggest you take cover.  The album is a perfectly crafted MOR record.  The assumption now becomes is MOR music inherently bad given its inability to strike an extreme (or even any) emotion in the listener, be it excitement or revilement?  The average-ness of the record is not so suffocating that you are put to sleep.  It is perfectly crafted to go unnoticed by many, but noticed just enough by those who may be listening.  It’s almost as if Stephens has succeeded in elevating the MOR genre above its standard of mediocrity.  The conundrum then becomes, if We Live on Cliffs is above the MOR standard, is it still middle of the road fare?  The short answer is yes, with a small however.  Tracks like the openers “Praises in Your Name” and “Second Mind” establish a nice folk/country/rock groove, but this soon begins to dissipate upon the realization that every other track on the album is structured in nearly the exact same way.  It’s almost as if Stephens was aware of this thematic death nail and decided to cap the album at a mere 9 songs—one of a few salivations.  The others being Stephens’ adept songwriting abilities and the somewhat intriguing strain in his voice.  We Live on Cliffs is a fine effort, but slightly more focus and drive could have given this beige record to brighter, more memorable colors.

Rating:

Enio is an MA graduate in Music Sociology who has written his thesis on the cultural regulation of Jamaican dancehall music by the Stop Murder Music campaign. He was born and raised in Toronto, Canada, and has an honours BA degree from the University of Toronto in Equity Studies and Sociology. Enio enjoys understanding the cultural implications of music and how music reinforces cultural identity.


Media
discussion by

Comments
Now on PopMatters
PM Picks
Announcements

© 1999-2014 PopMatters.com. All rights reserved.
PopMatters.com™ and PopMatters™ are trademarks
of PopMatters Media, Inc.

PopMatters is wholly independently owned and operated.