The Songs (Don't) Remain the Same
From the Land of Ice and Snow: The Songs of Led Zeppelin
US: 9 Oct 2010
Zep was the first group all of whose songs I’d heard; I was eight when its debut appeared, and I grew up with the music. When punk appeared, I drifted, but those albums never left my memory. Now, my teenage sons offer their critique: “They sound like everyone else because they ripped off everyone else.” But I recall of all people Tom Petty remarking in the unlikely space of liner notes for the Byrds box set years ago how Led Zeppelin was one of the few bands who’d contributed an original sound to rock.
Originality improves these 33 tracks on this double album, with 17 bonus digital tracks, from Jealous Butcher Records. As with many tribute projects, this is for charity, a music education-based organization First Octave. And, as with the better tributes, this gathers recognizable names with lesser-known talents from the Pacific Northwest to rethink the melodies, tweak the vocals, and play with the arrangements of some of the most familiar of classic rock staples.
Familiarity proves a challenge, for straight deliveries of “Kashmir”, “Rock and Roll”, “Whole Lotta Love”, and of course “Stairway to Heaven” would entice few to listen to this compilation. Many tribute albums fall rather than rise by including straightforward cover versions of songs that need no imitation. The work that has gone into the preparation of this project attests to the will not to repeat this trend, which on many 1990s-era compilations by indie bands redoing their influences tended to bring down the more daring interpretations with too many versions that tried to slavishly repeat the originals, to no purpose.
Luckily, Pellet Gun makes “Rock and Roll” into a Big Black-Henry Rollins barking-mad, grimly industrial, perkily martial call-to-arms. This kind of invention occurs on the best contributions. Even a song for me that is weaker in its original form such as “In the Evening” improves thanks to Chris Walla’s hooks that stretch it out into meditation.
The first disc as sequenced highlights eclecticism. Bluesy female vocals start off with “Good Times, Bad Times” by Kind of Like Spitting, followed by the Clampitt Family’s down home “Babe I’m Gonna Leave You”. Then, the Portland Cello Project takes on “Dazed and Confused”. After this diversity, the disc settles into versions that do not diverge as drastically, but which find a cozy indie-rock attitude that in its own Northwest, folksy-coffeehouse-grungy-rambling qualities fit this grandiose, epic, sprawling music comfortably.
Disc two wanders into more trip-hop, trance-friendly, club-mix territory. I found this less intriguing, if well-sequenced, but this may reflect my tastes, which tend towards the first disc’s ambiance. Such talents as M. Ward on “Bron-Yr-Aur”, Laura Veirs & Mount Analog on “The Ocean”, the Long Winters on “In the Light”, and Rebecca Gates and the Consortium on “Four Sticks” take some of Zep’s (slightly) less-played songs and open up their atmospheric possibilities.
The press release enclosed claims this effort was six years in the making. While Led Zeppelin’s fans may not easily hear of this from such a small label, compared to the corporate reissues and the books that continue to be issued along with worthy projects by the band’s surviving members, it deserves coverage. Revamping the music of a band nearly every rock fan has grown up with, and maybe not out of but into, makes for an entertaining way to return to the songs that even decades of repeat play on FM radio may not have ruined. For me, coming back to Zep’s music through these tributes reminded me of the power, range, and vistas that Bonham, Jones, Page, and Plant thundered out and tenderly tendered.
"PopMatters is looking for smart music writers. We're looking for talented writers with deep genre knowledge of music and its present and…READ the article