Call for Essays About Any Aspect of Popular Culture, Present or Past

Alone, But Not In The Dark: While Catherine Allingham's singular investigative mind makes her stand out in a world filled with superstition, she is usually able to piece together clues to solve almost any puzzle.
cover art

Mark Waid

(BOOM! Studios; US: )

One of the recurring conceits of the mystery genre is that there is always an answer to even the most daunting of puzzles and with the careful application of logic and sound reasoning the culprit—in whatever form it has taken—will be identified and that the crime—whatever it is—will be redressed. Conversely, stories involving ghosts, demons, and other supernatural entities, often rely on a rejection of the natural world with its rules and clearly defined laws, and instead reside in domains decidedly more illogical.

Consequently, when creators decide to blend these two genres together and force the logical to confront the inherently inexplicable, it often makes for interesting reading as the story attempts to challenge and frustrate the expectations of the readers. Legendary creator Mark Waid and artist Minck Oosterveer have attempted just such a synthesis in their book Unknown published by BOOM! Studios.

The story follows world-renowned detective Catherine Allingham and her assistant/bodyguard James Doyle as they attempt to solve a mystery whose subject matter is of personal significance to the veteran sleuth. Allingham, considered one of the smartest people in the world, has a terminal brain tumor and with her time is running out she has been asked to find a mysterious box that purportedly can measure the weight of the human soul. Naturally, the case intrigues as she attempts to use her considerable intellect to unravel the ultimate mystery of death. She hires Doyle, a former bouncer, to assist her in the event that her condition prevents her from knowing what’s real and what is a tumor-inspired illusion.

The main thematic punch from Unknown stems from Allingham’s confrontation with the seemingly supernatural juxtaposed with her own looming death. As a person of logic who has built her life and career on the idea that mysteries have answers, she attempts to use science and reason to answer what has long been the purview of the religious and spiritual. Ultimately, she successfully solves the mystery of the missing box, but the door between both life and death, and natural and supernatural, remains open. While she is able to find logical explanations for the various events she witnesses with a frustratingly Dana Scully-like persistence, the story reveals that not all these visions are byproducts of her mental condition and that there still some things that Allingham’s science has yet to explain. 

While the book is ultimately successful in its objectives and maintains the reader’s interest, it at times feels a little underdeveloped. There is a sense that the story is rushing towards its conclusion with a few awkward time-saving devices, like an overly talkative villain to provide necessary exposition and the quick introduction of the Doyle character, so that it feels like to reader is filling in the blanks.

Ultimately though the book’s strengths outnumber its few weaknesses. The writing and art work well together with the supernatural side of the story being stylistically reminiscent of old EC comics. Furthermore, unlike mystery stories like The Hound of the Baskervilles, Unknown doesn’t take the reader to the edge of the supernatural and then back away at the last minute with a Scooby Doo like logical explanation. Instead it jumps right into the dark abyss and doesn’t blink as the door between the explainable and the inexplicable (and their two respective genres) gets kicked right its hinges.

In the final analysis, Unknown is a thrill ride. Think Indiana Jones, when the series was good, think Hellboy. And the book delivers even more of what these stories perhaps should have been, a honest weighing-up of the rational colliding with irrational genres of fiction. Unknown therefore comes with solid praise and is rated as a book well worth buying.


Shawn O'Rourke is an Adjunct Instructor and Speech and Debate Coach at Orange Coast Community College. He has an MA in History and has presented papers at several academic conferences. He is on Facebook and can by followed on twitter (spo1981). Check out his blogs at and

Related Articles
9 Mar 2015
Princess Leia begins an important part of her journey towards becoming a true rebel.
29 Apr 2014
Before the Watcher meets his end, fans are reminded why they care about him.
14 Sep 2011
We often think of comic books as the height of escapism, but recent events point to an industry in a death spiral, due in no small part to how badly it mistreats the writers on which it depends.
21 Nov 2010
Comicbooks have one irreproachable strength over other forms of storytelling. Timelessness. The characters in comics are eternal. This is a point that is made abundantly clear with Stan Lee's latest foray into the comics medium, BOOM! Studios' The Traveler #1.
Now on PopMatters
PM Picks

© 1999-2015 All rights reserved.™ and PopMatters™ are trademarks
of PopMatters Media, Inc.

PopMatters is wholly independently owned and operated.