Call for Essays About Any Aspect of Popular Culture, Present or Past

Photo: Todd Roeth
cover art

Ha Ha Tonka

Death of a Decade

(Bloodshot; US: 5 Apr 2011; UK: 5 Apr 2011)

A few facts about Springfield, Missouri’s favorite sons Ha Ha Tonka. Despite their moniker, they’re not a goofy barroom band, though they call Bloodshot home and can bring the rock when the situation demands it. They’re really more of a singer-songwriter-y, folk-y, indie rock-with-a-mandolin band these days. Second, these guys really know how to give an album an evocative title (‘07’s Buckle in the Bible Belt, ‘09’s Nove Sounds of the Nouveau South and now Death of a Decade). Third, there’s a lot of buzz around Ha Ha Tonka, here in 2011, and deservedly so. Frontman Brian Roberts, more than ably backed by guitarist Brett Anderson, bassist Lucas Long and drummer Lennon Bone, is a rapidly maturing songwriter unafraid to examine the darker side of life, while still delivering catchy songs.

Though Death of a Decade as a title calls to mind a massive gesamtkunstwerk tackling the last 10 years, Roberts’ POV is far more personal, and feels like an inventory one makes as one nears 30. After the bait-and-switch opening rocker “Usual Suspects”, the midtempo waltz “Westward Bound” finds Roberts packing up and starting over – “Our bad times, we left them back east”—before yielding to a hopeful, wordless chorus.  Of course the dark, driving cautionary tale “Made Example Of” immediately flips the script: “If you don’t change where you’re going, you’re gonna end up right where you’re headed.” It’s equal part AA slogan and deep universal truth. Meanwhile, “Lonely Fortunes”, with its sweep of cinematic strings, acknowledges that taking a chance means risking losing everything. There are no easy answers in this life: move, stay put, change gears, self-destruct. Roberts wants to know, where did those choices take you? Did you make it through to adulthood?

Roberts continues that line of questioning and exploration on Side B, even if a definitive answer never arrives. To these ears, the soaring title track gets a little too obtuse (“I was just about to change…. You were the passenger who would not wave”), but there’s no denying his passion and frustration, both with himself and those around him. The rueful confessional “No Great Harm” finds Roberts admitting, “I only hurt the ones I loved by keeping myself separate,” and hoping for forgiveness after a dark night of the soul. Heavy stuff.

Fortunately, Ha Ha Tonka come out intact. The closing “The Humorist” veers towards an upbeat jazzy vibe, where most of the preceding tracks have a Fleet Foxes/Moondoggies/pick your Band disciple bent; a happier sense of self-awareness (“Never thought I was all that funny”); and what seems to be a key allusion to Samuel Longhorne Clemens.

Death of a Decade feels like a trilogy-ender for Ha Ha Tonka’s discography-to-date, and a triumphant one, to be sure. Where they go from here is anyone’s guess, but they are definitely not afraid to be a band you want to grow old with.


Related Articles
By Steve Leftridge, Taylor Coe, Chris Conaton, and Steve Horowitz
10 Dec 2013
Our list for 2013 is predictably diverse, ranging from progressive newgrass to tradition-minded country to old-time acoustic to California canyon rock to psych folk to singer-songwriter and all points between.
10 Oct 2013
This excellent indie quartet from Missouri broadens its sonic palette and creates its richest album yet.
By Steve Leftridge and Jeff Strowe
19 Dec 2011
If you ask a critic or music fan to define Americana, be prepared for an avalanche of diverse responses of opinion. Still, there remain some constant benchmarks, such as pedal steel, fiddle, acoustic guitars -- and good songwriting.
29 Mar 2011
In 2007, PopMatters named Ha Ha Tonka's Buckle in the Bible Belt one of our Albums of the Year. Now, prior to the release of new album Death of a Decade, the band reveal some surprising things, like that time they made hand-farts at B.B. King's club ...
Now on PopMatters
PM Picks

© 1999-2015 All rights reserved.™ and PopMatters™ are trademarks
of PopMatters Media, Inc.

PopMatters is wholly independently owned and operated.