Blue Light City

by David Maine

25 September 2011


Not enough grit, far too much gloss

cover art


Blue Light City

(Mason Jar)
US: 19 Jul 2011
UK: Import

New York City’s Turbine are a four-piece who seem in thrall to the history of classic pop-rock. Unfortunately, this takes them down some fairly uninteresting byways. Album opener “War of 9161 (The Pledge)” could be a Genesis tribute, with its lopsided time signatures and shimmering swathes of organ. Follow-up “No Explanation” starts off a bit grittier and more convincing, but sadly the band soon leaves that vibe behind in favor of syrupy harmonized vocals and an overarching sheen of slickness. There’s far too much forgettable 1970s AOR here and not nearly enough crunch.

Even the bouncy pseudo-funk of “Members Only” can’t leave the slick behind, and the rest of the album suffers from this as well, notwithstanding the Band-esque stomper “Eddy the Sea”, probably the best song of the bunch. “Behind These Walls” and “Blue Light City” both strive for something more, as their seven-minute-plus lengths attest, but both suffer from forgettable tunes and an overabundance of gloss. (That said, “Blue Light City” is by far the better, and thrashier, song.) That’s the band in a nutshell. After repeated listens, you’ll absorb plenty of surface sheen, but you’d be hard pressed to discern an identity.

Blue Light City



We all know how critical it is to keep independent voices alive and strong on the Internet. Please consider a donation to support our work as independent cultural critics and historians. Your donation will help PopMatters stay viable through these changing and challenging times. Thanks everyone.

//Mixed media

Beyoncé and When Music Writing Becomes Activism

// Sound Affects

"The overall response to Beyoncé's "Formation" has been startlingly positive, but mostly for reasons attached to political agendas. It's time to investigate this trend.

READ the article