Call for Music Critics and Music Bloggers

Music
cover art

Counting Crows

August and Everything After - Live at Town Hall

(Eagle Rock; US: 29 Aug 2011; UK: 29 Aug 2011)

Live shows are an integral part of the Counting Crows fan experience. Like plants in a breeze, songs bend and sway to the internal biorhythms of the band and crowd. In 2008, the band stumbled across a brilliant idea: create a soundboard recording of every show and sell it online, in essence making a live album each night. So what does this live track-by-track version of the group’s debut album add to the glut of live material? Unfortunately, not much.


Live At Town Hall finds the boys doing the same covers and alternates they’ve done for years: “Private Archipelago” during “Round Here”, “Doris Day” during “A Murder of One”, and “Thunder Road” during “Rain King”. It’s like they’re recreating a set from 1997 minus the hunger that made those early sets so powerful, adding neither to the standalone beauty of August and Everything After nor to the well-documented Counting Crow live experience.


The band does sound phenomenal. Songs like “Perfect Blue Buildings” and “Ghost Train” get the attention they rarely receive live. There’s good stage banter and a great intro to “Sullivan Street”. However, there’s nothing illuminating, there’s nothing that fans haven’t heard before. What we’re left with is a reminder of what a poetic storm cloud Adam Duritz was in the early ‘90s and why, for many years, like self-immolating traveling preachers, Counting Crows converted listeners wherever they went. Still, you could piece together a better version of Live At Town Hall from a summer’s worth of bootlegs.

Rating:

Adam Finley has two unmarketable degrees and a framed picture of Arnold Schwarzenegger in his office. He's been in the freelance game since 2007. He writes music reviews, political essays, non-award-winning short fiction, travel articles, and Limp Bizkit haiku. He once published a story about a chimpanzee. He is still shocked that people are willing to pay him money to write words. His dream is to ride a manatee.


Media
Related Articles
12 Nov 2013
Counting Crows have never played things by the book, which is why the Oscar-nominated group's third live release is filled with covers, and Duritz talks to PopMatters about his process, his regrets, and what fans can expect next ...
13 May 2012
Their live show is an occasionally uncomfortable mix of polish and genuine raggedness.
6 May 2012
Fifteen covers performed with as fine a sense of group interplay as you’ll find outside the jazz world.
26 Jan 2012
On this Counting Crows side project, personality is overshadowed by rote competence.
Comments
Now on PopMatters
PM Picks
Announcements
PopMatters' LUCY Giveaway! in PopMatters's Hangs on LockerDome

© 1999-2014 PopMatters.com. All rights reserved.
PopMatters.com™ and PopMatters™ are trademarks
of PopMatters Media, Inc.

PopMatters is wholly independently owned and operated.