Adapting Michael Lewis’ Moneyball: The Art of Winning an Unfair Game for the screen has always seemed like a strange proposition. The 2003 non-fiction book takes a fairly clinical approach to the inventive statistical methods used by Billy Beane as general manager of the Oakland A’s during the 2002 season. It also presents the history of this much-different method for evaluating talent in major league baseball.
This seems like fodder for a great documentary, but awkward material for a dramatic story. How could a movie present this dense material and interest general audiences? Steven Soderbergh was originally attached to the production, but left over creative differences. Bennett Miller (Capote) ended up directing the film, and Aaron Sorkin (The Social Network) and Stephen Zallian (Schindler’s List) wrote the script. With this kind of pedigree involved, the movie version ofMoneyball has just the right creative minds needed to bypass those obstacles. Sorkin in particular has shown an ability to translate complex material into a relatable product, so his participation is crucial to its success.
Brad Pitt stars as Beane, who’s recovering from losing his top three players to the big-spending teams. Oakland has a minimal payroll and can’t compete on the free-agent market with the wealthy clubs. Looking for a new way to scout players, he recruits numbers guru Peter Brand (Jonah Hill) to devise a new evaluation system. The old-time scouts are skeptical and believe you can’t quantify baseball success, but Beane has personal reasons to think otherwise. His frustrations from decisions he made as a top baseball prospect still haunt him today.
This personal side of the story is the master stroke in Sorkin and Zallian’s screenplay, which shifts the focus to Beane. Instead of providing intricate details on Sabermetrics, they make it a redemptive personal story. Like Mark Zuckerberg, Beane is sticking his neck out and will ride out the string, regardless of the consequences. His approach is much different than the Facebook founder, but their inventive tactics are relatable. Miller’s direction makes the point about Beane’s past without overplaying the connection. Pitt also shines by making his skepticism of the scouts clear in subtle fashion. They craft a mainstream crowd pleaser without catering to the lowest common denominator.
Moneyball is a film about baseball and should please fans interested in the stats, but it never delves too far into the approach. Brand explains the system and touts a few players they should grab, and that’s enough information. Jonah Hill received a supporting actor Oscar nomination for this role as the brains behind the operation. It’s a pretty standard performance that might not deserve this much recognition, but he still does an excellent job.
Pitt and Hill work together really well and find ways to inject a lot of humor into even some mundane moments. When they pull off a complex trade with a series of phone calls, their glee is infectious because we’re on board with the actors. Pitt has rarely looked so effortless on screen and deserves all the recognition. It’s one of his best roles because he doesn’t turn Beane into a saint. He’s a neurotic, superstitious guy who refuses to watch the game and avoids interacting with players. This isn’t the type of role you’d expect Pitt to play, but it works because of his understated approach.
The story focuses on the 2002 season, which begins terribly for the A’s and raises major questions about Beane’s sanity. Manager Art Howe (Phillip Seymour Hoffman) isn’t on board with the system and places road blocks at every turn. New players like Jeremy Giambi reveal serious negatives that likely prove the scouts’ assessments about them. It takes some serious commitment for Beane to keep his faith in Sabermetrics.
Knowledgeable viewers today know the end to this story, but there’s still a good deal of tension surrounding the early failures. Hoffman doesn’t get much to do beyond antagonizing Beane, but he sells the role of the grizzled veteran manager. He senses the ship is sinking and is acting for his own personal interests. It’s pretty much a thankless performance for the veteran, but he doesn’t phone in the role. This is Pitt’s movie and Beane is driving the story, so Howe just plays a small part in the main plot. There are recognizable players like David Justice and Scott Hatteberg involved, and the actors playing them are believable. However, these guys are more representative of the types of players valued in this system, not completely original characters.
This Blu-ray release includes a decent amount of extras, though the material barely scratches the surface. Some featurettes waste a lot of time on unnecessary clips we just watched in the movie. The biggest offender is “Drafting the Team”, a 20-minute feature on the movie’s cast. There are a few interesting tidbits mixed in there, including a quick discussion with Ken Medlock, who plays the head scout. He was a major league baseball player and doesn’t like Sabermetrics, so he fit the role perfectly.
A better feature is “Billy Beane – Reinventing the Game”, which provides a quick look at the real person. Beane appears to give worthy information during this 16-minute piece, but he doesn’t talk about what he thinks of the movie. The most intriguing part involves Michael Lewis’ take on the current baseball environment, which he describes as even more uneven today. “Moneyball: Playing the Game” offers good details about shooting the baseball scenes and adjusting the set design to match the period. It runs for 19 minutes and includes minimal clips, which makes it a refreshing inclusion.
The most interesting topic is discussed in “Adapting Moneyball”, a 16-minute feature that includes conversations with the crew who crafted the picture. I would have enjoyed hearing even more from Sorkin and Zallian, but it’s still a solid extra. There are also 12 minutes of deleted scenes, including one that spotlights an interesting story line that was cut from the film. Beane had actually re-married by this point in real life, and his wife appears during a dinner conversation after the season. Her character was cut from the movie, and Brand takes over to cover the same material. Another noteworthy scene expands Beane’s consideration of the Red Sox offer, which offers more plot but isn’t really needed. Miller made the right choice in removing that slow moment.
Moneyball is top-notch commercial filmmaking that doesn’t receive enough credit because of its flawless execution. Pitt makes playing Beane look easy, and his chemistry with Hill also feels effortless. It takes some major creativity from Miller, Sorkin, and Zallian to make the story flow so well. A possibly dull subject is exciting for more than two hours, which is a major achievement.
Another smart move is focusing on Beane’s relationship with his daughter. These scenes reveal a different side of his character, and work because they’re not overly emotional. The final scene of him driving as her song plays in the background is sentimental, but in the best way possible. I was fighting back a few tears at the end. This powerful effect is a testament to my connection with the characters and the underdog story. The result is one of the bigger surprises of the past year.