Call for Music Writers... Rock, Indie, Hip-hop, R&B, Electronic, Americana, Metal, World and More

Photo: Tina Tyrell

St. Vincent

(22 May 2012: Bijou Theater — Knoxville, TN)

As she proved with enviable ease at Knoxville’s fabulous Bijou Theatre, Annie Clark is every indie-rock geek boy’s dream come true: a rare blend of physical beauty, mousey theater girl charm, and neck-breaking art-rock prowess that veers dizzyingly between virtuosic noise (her guitar playing) and virtuosic sweetness (her voice).

But the stage was set rather impressively by Shearwater, who bulldozed through an eclectic set way more dynamic and passionate than the well-oiled St. Vincent performance that followed. Personally, though I’d heard their name for ages (and had read rave reviews for their last album, Animal Joy), I’d never actually heard the band’s music. Along with most of the sold-out Bijou, I had my ass blown away. In a live setting, frontman Jonathan Meiburg’s voice is a thing of exquisite power, harnessing the passion of a metal singer: At his quietest, he moaned with the grace of Talk Talk’s Mark Hollis; at his throatiest, he bellowed with the intensity of Jefferson Airplane’s Grace Slick.

He offered a commanding presence as a frontman, often staring menacingly into a void in the center of the crowd—and throughout their over-too-soon opening slot, the whole quintet channeled a similar intensity, with a sound that recalled nearly every indie-rock band on the planet yet none at all. (“Spoon on Mars”, I scribbled in my notes at one point. “Blued-eyed-soul Clap Your Hands Say Yeah” the next.)

Though St. Vincent’s sprawling, Strange Mercy-heavy set lacked that same, well, “animal joy” and creative spirit, it was still a majestic wash of sound, complete with an utterly disorienting barrage of flashing lights. Clark’s ace backing band (drummer Matt Johnson, Mini-Moog-ist Toko Yasuda, keyboardist Daniel Mintseris) conjured every dry, alien rhythm and piercing frill with precision—to the point where some tracks were virtually indistinguishable from their album counterparts. Which begs the question, “Why go see a live band if it sounds absolutely identical to the album?” For most concert-goers, the answer is energy or spontaneity—but unfortunately, as talented a performer and songwriter as she is, Clark isn’t exactly a riveting performer—staggering awkwardly during her many guitar breaks like a drunk robot, killing momentum with dead-end between-song chatter. (All of the above, however, seemed to positively thrill the obnoxious hippie standing in front of me, who continuously screamed “FUCK YEAH! ROCK AND ROLL!” and swayed back and forth like a hunchbacked ape.)

But what St. Vincent may have lacked in spark, they made up for with mesmerizing musicianship. Clark, as we all know, is a flat-out phenomenal guitarist, despite her extreme over-use of effects-pedal fuzz. “Surgeon”, the Strange Mercy stand-out (and one of 2011’s finest tracks), was even nastier in person, and despite lacking the album version’s maniac synth-bass explosion, it was transfixing to follow Clark’s skinny fingers on the fretboard, wearing out that track’s incredible hammer-on riff while somehow singing simultaneously. “Cruel” was equally huge (anchored by Mintseris’ subtly intricate two-hand synth work), and their now familiar cover of The Pop Group’s “She is Beyond Good and Evil” was funky and ferocious: easily the highlight of the evening.

During said song, the aforementioned hippie appeared to be in a near-religious state of ecstasy, swaying his hairy caveman arms in the air, letting rip with another mighty “ROCK AND ROLL!”, just in case the rest of the venue hadn’t heard his prior requests. Annoying as he was, and as unintentional as his message may have been, the guy ironically had a point: A little more rock and roll vigor, a little more “FUCK YEAH” intensity couldn’t have hurt. But even though it could have been one of the coldest performances I’ve ever witnessed, it also might be the most beautiful.

Ryan Reed is an Adjunct English Professor, English Department Graduate Assistant, and freelance music critic/journalist with degrees in English and Journalism. In addition to serving as an Associate Music Editor/Music Writer with PopMatters, he contributes reviews, feature stories, and other work to Billboard, Paste, American Songwriter, Boston Phoenix, Relix, Blurt, Metro Pulse, Cleveland Scene, and a handful of others. If you want to contact him for any reason, send an e-mail to rreed6128[at]

Related Articles
29 Jan 2015
PopMatters predicts a night of newcomers, huge sweeps, and some love for two theme songs from 2013.
12 Jan 2015
The combination of the Black Keys and St. Vincent in one arena brought together two formidable and well-received guitar-driven acts for the final show of their 2014 tours.
By PopMatters Staff
22 Dec 2014
From Polish black metal to mind-blowing progressive R&B and electronic music, 2014's best albums certainly have something for everyone.
28 Feb 2014
We caught St. Vincent's sold out tour kick off show in New York City and have the photos to prove it. Check out her lengthy North American tour schedule.

Visit PopMatters's profile on Pinterest.
discussion by
Now on PopMatters
PM Picks

© 1999-2015 All rights reserved.™ and PopMatters™ are trademarks
of PopMatters Media, Inc.

PopMatters is wholly independently owned and operated.