Call for Essays About Any Aspect of Popular Culture, Present or Past

cover art


Given to the Rising

(Neurot; US: 5 Jun 2007; UK: 7 May 2007)

Arguably the most influential metal band of the last dozen years (with Eyehategod not far behind), and now in its 22nd year of existence, Oakland, California sextet Neurosis can be viewed in the same light as such fellow metal fragmenters At the Gates, Carcass, Bathory, Napalm Death, and Godflesh, in that their entirely unique sound has spawned a new metal subgenre, spawning a spate of younger bands intent on following their lead. Having such a profound influence on a generation of musicians is the highest compliment, but it comes with a price, as popularity breeds ubiquitousness, to the point where we grow weary of the trends before long. Such is the case with At the Gates’ melodic death metal sound, which had been mimicked and bastardized by dozens upon dozens of lesser talents, and this Neurosis-inspired sound, call it “post-metal”, “metalgaze”, or “NeurIsis”, has been in danger of oversaturation as of late, with more and more bands taking the slow, crushingly heavy route, punctuated with tribal drumming and anguished screams.

While certain bands have taken the torch and ran mightily with it, such as Minsk, Intronaut, Cult of Luna, and Year of No Light, like any overexposed musical trend, before long we start to think enough is enough. However, as Isis proved on last year’s majestic In the Absence of Truth, nobody does it as well as the original masters, and Neurosis in turn has one-upped their East Coast counterparts with their ninth album, an uncompromising affirmation that they are, without question, the mightiest band if its kind, and show no signs of losing their touch whatsoever.

Three years ago, some people wondered openly if Neurosis was in fact diminishing in power, as The Eye of Every Storm took a much more lucid, sober, controlled approach as opposed to such intense, primal masterpieces as Through Silver in Blood and Times of Grace. While sounding often as eerily calm as its title would indicate, it was nevertheless an exceptional offering from the veteran band, but if one thing’s certain about the new disc Given to the Rising, it’s that Storm detractors and supporters can all agree that it delivers, plain and simple, and has Neurosis sounding more ferocious, focused, and yes, even catchier than they have in a good eight years.

Continuing what has been a remarkable eight year artistic collaboration, the band has teamed up yet again with Steve Albini, whose recording style suits Neurosis perfectly, those warm analog tape tones enveloping listeners as the massive drums and roaring vocals throttle away. For Albini’s prowess, though, what hits us from the start of the new album is just how strong the actual songwriting is. In fact, Given to the Rising wastes absolutely no time in grabbing our attention; there’s no slow fade-in here, as the title track goes for the throat from bar one, launching into a Sabbatherian guitar riff and percussion groove. When it comes to epic song dynamics, this band is without peer, manipulating us endlessly with twists and turns, but while the loud-soft-loud-soft formula is expected, when the bottom drops out in a Neurosis song, only to return with even more force, the visceral thrill is undeniable, and “Given to the Rising” is a perfect example.

“Fear and Sickness” lurches along like a limping behemoth, the disturbing, sustained guitar notes by Steve Von Till and Scott Kelly underscored by otherworldly thrums and drones of noise courtesy Noah Landis, while the eight minute “At the End of the Road” is another summation of what these guys are all about, the emphasis this time on the powerful drumming of Jason Roeder, Landis’s ambient touches, and the eventual collision of massive guitars, which come crashing in nearly five minutes into the song. “Hidden Faces”, which kicks off the second half of the album, is the most immediate song, Roeder’s continual stick count-ins adding a nervousness to the otherwise stately arrangement, but it’s on two longer tracks in particular that Neurosis boldly sticks to its time-honored template and succeeds mightily, first on the efficient, comfortably familiar “Distill (Watching the Swarm)”, and to even more spectacular effect on “Origin”, which takes nine whole minutes of bleak beauty before the climactic squall of density crushes us one last time, leaving us catching our breath when the song, and the album, comes to an immediate, jarring halt.

For all of Given to the Rising‘s awe-inspiring power, though, we are reminded from time to time of the band’s growing skill at more melodic numbers, the highlight here being the shimmering “To the Wind”, which hints at first toward the Slowdive-inspired majesty of Jesu, but eventually starts into a jarringly upbeat groove. While it may be the most conventional song on the album, it never strays from that core Neurosis sound, be it Von Till’s authoritative baritone, or the towering riffs that interrupt the tender beauty near the end, offering a tantalizing glimpse at the darkness that lurks beneath. It’s one of many examples of how Neurosis returned to the form of the late 1990s, back when underground metal was turned upside down by their spacious yet pulverizing music. The adoring young bands can try to imitate these guys all they want, but as this fantastic, near-flawless album attests, nothing beats the real thing.


Adrien Begrand has been writing for PopMatters since 2002, and has been writing his monthly metal column Blood & Thunder since 2005. His writing has also appeared in Metal Edge, Sick Sounds, Metallian, graphic novelist Joel Orff's Strum and Drang: Great Moments in Rock 'n' Roll, Knoxville Voice, The Kerouac Quarterly,,, and A contributing writer for Decibel, Terrorizer, and Dominion magazines and senior writer for Hellbound, he resides, blogs, and does the Twitter thing in Saskatoon, Saskatchewan, Canada.

Tagged as: neurosis
Given to the Rising Promotional Film
Related Articles
5 Nov 2012
You're guaranteed integrity from a Neurosis release, and the band's latest and 10th studio album, Honor Found in Decay, is no different. It's been five long years since the onslaught of 2007's Given to the Rising, but fans’ patience has been amply rewarded.
By Adrien Begrand and Andrew Blackie
16 Dec 2007
This is the best year for metal music we've seen in a very long time. Like other watershed years, such as 1983, 1984, and 1991, it's partially a case of artists peaking at the same time, and 2007 was no exception, unleashing a wave of superb releases from January straight through November.
Now on PopMatters
PM Picks

© 1999-2015 All rights reserved.™ and PopMatters™ are trademarks
of PopMatters Media, Inc.

PopMatters is wholly independently owned and operated.