Call for Essays About Any Aspect of Popular Culture, Present or Past

cover art

Robert Pollard

Superman was a Rocker

(Happy Jack; US: 12 Feb 2008; UK: Available as import)

Superman was a Rocker is probably the most interesting release we’ve seen from Robert Pollard in quite sometime. It’s hard to consider it a proper, frontline solo release from him, in light of his solid, fully fleshed-out Merge albums, but it is—like many of Pollard’s releases—a distinct curiosity. The album also seems far more interesting than most of his genre-aping, watered-down side projects. Here’s Pollard digs through boxes of old tapes that span back over his entire musical career, selects thirteen of those compositions and puts new lyrics and vocal harmonies to them.

It’s the sort of nostalgic project that lo-fi GBV purists would love, at least in theory. What Superman Was a Rocker should do is remind listeners of the elements that made, say, Alien Lanes so brilliant. We should get some insight into Pollard’s haphazard process. And we should see a meshing of his present day shimmer and his old school fuzz. But none of these things happen.

Instead, the album sounds, like a lot of Bob’s “minor” work, typically self-indulgent. And, for the most part, it is hard to decide why these were the compositions he chose. When Guided by Voices were making lo-fi records, it made more sense to operate in bits and pieces. The mosaic quality of those album’s fit their sound and made them distinct. But now, having left GBV behind, the worth of this album—considering how awkwardly it is executed— is questionable.

In some cases, the mixing of old music with new vocals is uneven. “Another Man’s Blood” has new, shiny vocals put way up high in the mix, drowning out the murky music underneath. In other spots, the vocals are distorted and muddy, meshed a little closer with the track, but the production, or lack thereof, sounds more obligatory than natural. Some compositions actually sound fine on their own, until Pollard’s strange vocals come in. One track, “Back to the Farm”, is smartly kept as an instrumental. Of course, you have to sit through a senseless radio show clip to get to the solid acoustic number.

A few spots do succeed here. “Go Down First” and “More Hot Dogs Please” are the kind of quick, raucous numbers that could have been on Alien Lanes or Bee Thousand, or at least been b-sides on singles. “Love Your Spaceman” is the best meshing of today’s arena rock Pollard with yesterday’s tape-noodler Pollard, and its the closest thing to a clear-cut pop number on the record.

But the rest of the record doesn’t fall apart because it’s not catchy enough. Pollard has, on occasion, succeeded with his off-kilter sound experiments. But these songs, or clips, just don’t come together to give us something new from Pollard. It doesn’t illuminate any new elements of Guided By Voices’ old sound, and it doesn’t act as a solid juxtaposition to Pollard’s more polished tunes today. Superman was a Rocker is, in the end, more work to figure out than its worth. It was a good idea on paper, but that is hardly enough.


Matthew Fiander is a music critic for PopMatters and Prefix Magazine. He also writes fiction and his work has appeared in The Yalobusha Review. He received his M.F.A. in Creative Writing from UNC-Greensboro and currently teaches writing and literature at High Point University in High Point, NC. You can follow him on Twitter at @mattfiander.

Tagged as: robert pollard
Related Articles
By Matthew Fiander and Arnold Pan
2 Apr 2015
The latest "Listening Ahead" provides an early look at new albums from Built to Spill, Speedy Ortiz, and Waxahatchee.
1 Feb 2015
I Sell the Circus, Robert Pollard's first album with his new band, makes a convincing argument for Ricked Wicky as a powerful rock band.
8 Dec 2013
You'd think we'd run out of fresh things to find in Pollard's music by now, but Blazing Gentlemen assures us that not only is that hunt still on, but it's also still satisfying.
17 Jul 2013
As always, Pollard often accomplishes the most in the shortest periods of time, in under a minute. Given twice that amount of time, he can spin out an entire story, a deep mood, or a tune that’s half the length of most people’s hits but nonetheless feels like more of a complete statement.
Now on PopMatters
PM Picks

© 1999-2015 All rights reserved.™ and PopMatters™ are trademarks
of PopMatters Media, Inc.

PopMatters is wholly independently owned and operated.