Call for Music Writers... Rock, Indie, Hip-hop, R&B, Electronic, Americana, Metal, World and More

cover art

Umphrey's McGee

The Bottom Half

(Sci-Fidelity; US: 3 Apr 2007; UK: Unavailable)

As a jam band, Umphrey’s McGee took the largest risk of their career with their 2006 release Safety In Numbers: they released a jam band album with actual

songs (see: totally non-indulgent).  Umphrey’s is often so easy to lump into the post-Phish jam band crowd, but their fans know that the group is so much more than that.  Safety was the album that gained Umphrey’s their first major critical notices, largely because they weren’t as focused on sudden style-shifting and guitar noodling—they were writing grounded songs that were based on the recent death of one of the band’s closest friends.  They were in the midst of recording a double-disc acoustic/electric album when the tragedy happened, and they developed Safety from there.  The resulting album still managed to rock out on occasion, but it was to-the-point, somber, and—at times—even poetic.  After a handful of live and studio releases, here the band upped their game, going as far as securing Storm Thorgerson to do the cover art (the same Storm Thorgerson who did album covers for Pink Floyd and Audioslave).  Needless to say, the little jam-rockers that could had finally arrived.

Yet, what happened to all of those songs they recorded before their friend’s passing?  While many of those numbers would be played during their live shows, the studio versions (along with various other demos and alternate takes) were put together on The Bottom Half, released almost one exact year after Safety in Numbers hit shelves.  While it would be simple to dismiss The Bottom Half as a mere rarities compilation, it actually holds its ground as an album remarkably well, making it not only an essential addition to the band’s canon, but places it as an easy frontrunner for the best jam-rock album of 2007.

The first disc of The Bottom Half works so well is because it’s a unified effort: the expected themes of overcoming adversity, believing in what you know is right, etc.; it’s all there.  The difference s that, melodically, the band has never been in such tight form.  Even the ten-minute long “Division” (riding a folk-rock groove that would make Jerry Garcia proud) manages to hold together without drifting off into Infinite Guitar Solo Land.  Even when they do bring in the dread six-string meandering, it’s in short, controlled bursts (like on the excellent title track, which opens the album), where soloing isn’t as much an issue of showing off to us as it is contributing to the song’s melody.  Few jam bands these days show the amount of deliberate restraint that Umphrey’s do, and even fewer could have composed a moving acoustic ballad like “Home” (much less one that clocks in at under four minutes). 

The group adds sampling to their resumé with the electronica-turning-rock meditation “Atmosfarag” (named after percussionist Andy Farag), and goes into full-on radio pop mode with the bombastic “Bright Lights, Big City”, which is undoubtedly fun but begins to drag after only a few minutes.  “Intentions Clear”, however, remains one of their most indelible melodies to date, riding on a light, crunchy guitar riff that eventually gives way to their insanely tight horn section, creating a lazy nighttime groove.  The sheer precision of their synchronized melodies is marvelous, proving that while many still prefer the experience of Umprhey’s McGee live on stage, missing out on their studio experience is missing out on a huge part of what makes the band so unique to begin with.

The other half of The Bottom Half (see: the second disc), is interesting but not essential.  Don’t let the track listing fool you: of the 28 songs featured, five of them are just studio chatter, two of them are fascinating samples from an old vinyl by the touring troupe the Browning Family (said samples are heard on “Atmosfarag”), and the rest are demo counterparts to practically every song off of Safety in Numbers and The Bottom Half’s first disc.  Most fascinating are the multiple treatments given to the emotional centerpiece of Safety in Numbers: the harrowing tune “Words”.  Their one-minute a capella version of the chorus is a true gem, while the group also includes the intro and instrumental versions of it as well (the chorus-only version is largely studio chatter).  While most of the demos are simply interesting blueprints of the fleshed-out album versions of songs, it’s the most eclectic treatments that catch our ears.  “Red Room Disco” is just what it says it is, a disco treatment of the Southern-leaning original “Red Room”.  It starts with studio chatter, then evolves into the band completely letting loose with a pumped dance version of the same number.  It’s a brief but fun insight into their recording process.  There’s also the keyboard-only version of “Atmosfarag”, riding on a heavy trip-hop vibe.  Anyone who listens to the free podcasts that the band puts on their website knows that these genre exercises are more than just one-offs; from classical to heavy-metal, Umphreys’ McGee have few obstacles in their way when it comes to composition or improv.

At 39 tracks, The Bottom Half is an intimidating starting point for any listener new to Umphrey’s, and justifiably so.  The second disc is wild and fun, but really only for die-hard fans.  Yet it’s the stunning, powerful first disc that serves as the kind of musical statement that reshapes notions of what a stereotypical “jam band” is.  This music need not be long, drawn-out, or indulgent—a true jam band knows when to control themselves, when to have fun, and knows full-well that the those two notions need not be independent of each other.  With Safety in Numbers and The Bottom Half, the group officially enters the big leagues, but with the way they sound now, they’ve been ready for years.


Evan Sawdey started contributing to PopMatters in late 2005, and has also had his work featured in publications such as SLUG Magazine, The Metro (U.K.), Soundvenue Magazine (Denmark), the Daily Dot, and many more. Evan has been a guest on HuffPost Live, RevotTV's "Revolt Live!", and WNYC's Soundcheck (an NPR affiliate), was the Executive Producer for the Good With Words: A Tribute to Benjamin Durdle album, and wrote the liner notes for the 2011 re-release of Andre Cymone's hit 1985 album A.C. (Big Break Records), the 2012 re-release of 'Til Tuesday's 1985 debut Voices Carry (Hot Shot Records), and many others. He currently resides in Chicago, Illinois. You can follow him @SawdEye should you be so inclined.

Umphrey's McGee -- Higgins (Live)
Related Articles
27 Mar 2015
The Chicago prog jam outfit Umphrey's McGee were given 12 hours in the legendary Abbey Road studios. The funky and groovy "Bad Friday" is one of the results of that fruitful time in the studio.
4 Aug 2014
Despite its good yet forgettable songwriting, Similar Skin is still uplifting and colorful enough musically to warrant at least a few listens.
26 Mar 2014
The men of Umphrey's McGee did their best to triumph over the adverse conditions with a series of high-energy jams to get some good vibes going.
30 Jan 2014
Many fans are simply enraptured watching Redman trade licks with Cinninger and Bayliss, a dazzling showcase of 21st century music fusion.
Now on PopMatters
PM Picks

© 1999-2015 All rights reserved.™ and PopMatters™ are trademarks
of PopMatters Media, Inc.

PopMatters is wholly independently owned and operated.