With Throats as Fine as Needles

With Throats as Fine as Needles

by Quentin B. Huff

10 October 2006


Who knew Mother Earth was a musician? More than that, who knew She had skills? With Throats as Fine as Needles—a band consisting of Campbell Kneale, Antony Milton, James Kirk, and Richard Francis—offers one of the coolest band names ever, as well as bringing our favorite planet into the recording session as the fifth band member, using battery-powered instruments in the outdoors to record six tracks. Actually, it takes place in a New Zealand abandoned bunker, with the quintet (the four musicians plus Mother Earth) recording sounds as they (the sounds) bounce off the walls. Described by the press kit as being like an “excavation turned exorcism”, the drone in this work struggles to stand on its own when it almost cries out for inclusion in a motion picture score, behind action sequences and dramatic dialogue. Tracks built on “massive drones” should undoubtedly be repetitive—that’s to be expected. It seems, though, that this particular experience could be enhanced by a sense of change or movement (in spite of how counterintuitive that suggestion may seem), not only to differentiate the tracks from one another, but also to develop a proactive rendering of sound images. That way, the tracks, though somewhat arbitrary in designation, would provide an environment of contrast to each other, creating a tension not unlike capturing photographs of the abandoned bunker from various angles. Track four does incorporate sounds similar to chimes that merge into a percussive discourse at about two minutes. Still, it soon reverts to the natural mass of spooky reverbs of the first three tracks. A change in tonality occurs in the sixth track, however, bordering on a heavier, more intense industrial sound and providing contrast to the collection’s initial reliance on its organ-like hum.

With Throats as Fine as Needles


We all know how critical it is to keep independent voices alive and strong on the Internet. Please consider a donation to support our work. We are a wholly independent, women-owned, small company. Your donation will help PopMatters stay viable through these changing, challenging times where costs have risen and advertising has dropped precipitously. PopMatters needs your help to keep publishing. Thank you.


//Mixed media

20 Questions: Amadou & Miriam

// Sound Affects

"For their ninth studio album, acclaimed Malian duo Amadou & Miriam integrate synths into their sound while displaying an overt love of Pink Floyd.

READ the article