PopMatters home | short takes home | archives

PopMatters Music Short Takes
our brief reviews of new releases

e-mail print comment

06 January 2004

Sylvain Chateau, Un Autre Décembre (130701/Fat Cat)
This CD consists of piano-based instrumentals by a guy who claims to know nothing about playing the piano - and, dammit, he's a man of his word! There are pretty melodies on several tracks, but they are inconsequential and go nowhere. These songs kinda poke a hole in label-mates Sigur Ros, who spend a lot of money and time just to do the same thing. On other tracks, like the five numbers under the title "Granulation," it's just ambient sound, which is always a lot more boring than it sounds, which is still pretty boring. Too long, at 24 minutes.
      — Matt Cibula

.: posted by Editor 7:45 AM