Broken Social Dreams

As I channel my inner Fox Mulder, I should be clear that I don’t see any conspiracies here. However, I do read the When-Drew-Met-Canning narrative sketched by so many of us in the blogosphere, whether intentionally or not, as a controlling cover-up that restricts attention to the boundless spontaneity that is, in many ways, the most compelling feature of Broken Social Scene’s music and legacy.

Depending on which version of the story you trust—and part of Broken Social Scene’s charm is that there are so many different versions of the story—the band began as either a deliberate joint venture between Kevin Drew and Brendan Canning, or it was something that evolved (and continues to evolve) spontaneously and with little premeditation. Given that the buzz surrounding the group's two major releases since You Forgot It in People (2002) has had at least as much to do with how many new members have been pulled into the fray of the band’s activity as it has had to do with their music, it’s pretty evident that the consensus leans toward spontaneity—the idea that the group is a democratic collective, one in which new musical directions are always embraced and where the central creative force driving the band is always spreading out and enveloping each member, new or old, equally. Everything’s communal, in short.

This is an appealing narrative, no doubt. And if I’m being honest, I approach it much like the venerable Agent Fox Mulder: I want to believe. The problem is that the very same media outlets that have lent a hand in writing this narrative have simultaneously, and somewhat paradoxically, emphasized the opposite—the notion that BSS is in many ways not the sum of its assorted parts but is rather the creative vision, primarily, of its two founding members. Though this conclusion might not seem particularly profound, it is one worth examining (especially in light of the praise for the band’s latest release, Forgiveness Rock Record) because it is necessary to consider the limitations that the narratives we ascribe to the band poses for it, if not for its fans as well.

One possible way to contextualize Broken Social Scene is to see the group as part of the (slightly) larger pool of bands that gained prominence in the early part of this decade and that configured themselves as, well . . . collectives. The Arcade Fire, Godspeed You Black Emperor!, and, of course, Animal Collective immediately come to mind. Another way to frame BSS’s music is to attach it directly to the development of music blogs and online fanzines, both of which have proliferated over the course of the past decade. And, of course, there’s the argument to be made that Broken Social Scene exists entirely out of context, because they’re spontaneous. Take your pick. Each option is admittedly oversimplified, but not, I’d contend, wholly inaccurate.

Since Ryan Schreiber’s review of You Forgot It in People is often viewed as the press that broke the band, it’s hard for me not to see BSS as perpetually entangled with the World Wide Web and the various online music publications that have championed the group over the past eight years. Heck, you’re even reading about the band right now, on this very website.

And this, in my mind, is the biggest obstacle facing the band.

Since the cyclone of online reporting, sharing, blogging, tweeting, and publicizing news information of all kinds continues to increase in intensity (and of course with more fingertips being able to determine what constitutes news), it has become increasingly difficult to maintain a sense of control over the circulation of information. This much we know. On the one hand, this displacement of top-down control mechanisms stands as the fulfillment of the democratizing potential of the Internet. On the other hand, this displacement has, arguably, substituted one form of control with another—an argument that the bulk of the press coverage on Broken Social Scene bears out.

Despite the increasingly large volume of articles on BSS’s work, the image—the public face—of the group with which we are presented over and over again is that of Kevin Drew. Sure, there are plenty of pictures of the band in its various permutations out there. Yet, when it comes to disseminating official BSS updates, news, and even spinoff releases, Drew’s name, if not his face, is the prominent one, with Brendan Canning’s being a close second. Even This Book is Broken (2009), the official Broken Social Scene story compiled by Pitchfork’s own Stuart Berman, is framed—authenticated—by Drew and Canning’s foreword.

This overemphasis on Drew, Canning, and even Charles Spearin may or may not be deliberate. It might even be quite logical to direct so much media attention on these three, particularly since they have consistently been at the center of the band’s activity all along. Nevertheless, the intense focus on the creative vision of these three members renders the mythology surrounding Broken Social Scene—the idea that the band members “break all codes”, as they once scrawled on their cover art—impossible. In its place, we are left with a narrative that is fairly traditional: after starting a band, its founding members remain, from a media standpoint, the most significant ones in the lineup. Gone is the emphasis on democratic collaboration—that sense that creativity was always and forever unfolding in the spontaneous immediacy of the moment. What remains in its place, despite the endlessly swelling membership, is the image of a social scene that has been telescoped down to just a few “core” members.

As I channel my inner Mulder in this posting, I should be clear that I don’t see any conspiracies here. However, I do read the When-Drew-Met-Canning narrative sketched by so many of us in the blogosphere, whether intentionally or not, as a controlling cover-up that restricts attention to the boundless spontaneity that is, in many ways, the most compelling feature of Broken Social Scene’s music and legacy.

Still, Drew and Canning, the band, the Collective--whoever is in studio at the time have an undeniable knack for writing, to recall Schreiber, endlessly explosive pop songs. Therefore, even if dreams of democratic collectivity are imperfect, potentially unattainable in their execution, we can forgive Broken Social Scene for that.





Numün's 'voyage au soleil' Is a Trippy, Ambient Ride and Ambitious Debut

Eclectic instrumental trio numün combine a wealth of influences to create a vibe that's both spacey and earthy on voyage au soleil.


L7's 'Smell the Magic' Is 30 and Packs a Feminist Punch

Abortion is under threat again, and there's a sex offender in the Oval Office. A fitting time, in short, to crank up the righteously angry vocals of feminist hard rock heavy hitters like L7.


Can Queer Studies Rescue American Universities?

Matt Brim's Poor Queer Studies underscores the impact of poorer disciplines and institutions, which often do more to translate and apply transformative intellectual ideas in the world than do their ivory-tower counterparts.


Jim White Offers a "Smart Ass Reply" (premiere)

Jesus and Alice Cooper are tighter than you think, but a young Jim White was taught to treat them as polar opposites. Then an eight-track saved his soul and maybe his life.


Ed Harcourt Paints From 'Monochrome to Colour'

British musician Ed Harcourt's instrumental music is full of turbulent swells and swirls that somehow maintain a dignified beauty on Monochrome to Colour.


West London's WheelUP Merges Broken Beat and Hip-Hop on "Stay For Long" (premiere)

West London producer WheelUP reached across the pond to Brint Story to bring some rapid-fire American hip-hop to his broken beat revival on "Stay For Long".


PM Picks Playlist 4: Stellie, The Brooks, Maude La​tour

Today's playlist features the premiere of Stellie's "Colours", some top-class funk from the Brooks, Berne's eco-conscious electropop, clever indie-pop from Maude Latour, Jaguar Jonze rocking the mic, and Meresha's "alien pop".


Plattetopia: The Prefabrication of Utopia in East Berlin

With the fall of the Berlin Wall came the licence to take a wrecking ball to its nightmare of repression. But there began the unwritten violence of Die Wende, the peaceful revolution that hides the Oedipal violence of one order killing another.


Electrosoul's Flõstate Find "Home Ground" on Stunning Song (premiere)

Flõstate are an electrosoul duo comprised of producer MKSTN and singer-songwriter Avery Florence that create a mesmerizing downtempo number with "Home Ground".


Orchestra Baobab Celebrate 50 Years with Vinyl of '​Specialist in All Styles'

As Orchestra Baobab turn 50, their comeback album Specialist in All Styles gets a vinyl reissue.


What 'O Brother, Where Art Thou?' Gets Right (and Wrong) About America

Telling the tale of the cyclops through the lens of high and low culture, in O'Brother, Where Art Thou? the Coens hammer home a fatalistic criticism about the ways that commerce, violence, and cosmetic Christianity prevail in American society .


Hot Chip Stay Up for 'Late Night Tales'

Hot Chip's contribution to the perennial compilation project Late Night Tales is a mixed bag, but its high points are consistent with the band's excellence.


The Budos Band Call for Action on "The Wrangler" (premiere)

The Budos Band call on their fans for action with the powerful new track "The Wrangler" that falls somewhere between '60s spy thriller soundtrack and '70s Ethiojazz.


Creature Comfort's "Woke Up Drunk" Ruminates on Our Second-Guesses (premiere)

A deep reflection on breaking up, Nashville indie rock/Americana outfit Creature Comfort's "Woke Up Drunk" is the most personal track from their new album, Home Team.


For Don DeLillo, 'The Silence' Is Deafening

In Don DeLillo's latest novel, The Silence, it is much like our post-pandemic life -- everything changed but nothing happened. Are we listening?


Brett Newski Plays Slacker Prankster on "What Are You Smoking?" (premiere)

Is social distancing something we've been doing, unwittingly, all along? Brett Newski pulls some pranks, raises some questions in "What Are You Smoking?".


Becky Warren Shares "Good Luck" and Discusses Music and Depression

Becky Warren finds slivers of humor while addressing depression for the third time in as many solo concept albums, but now the daring artist is turning the focus on herself in a fight against a frightful foe.


Fleet Foxes Take a Trip to the 'Shore'

On Shore, Fleet Foxes consist mostly of founding member Robin Pecknold. Recording with a band in the age of COVID-19 can be difficult. It was just time to make this record this way.

Collapse Expand Reviews

Collapse Expand Features

PM Picks
Collapse Expand Pm Picks

© 1999-2020 All rights reserved.
PopMatters is wholly independent, women-owned and operated.