Robert Jay Lifton: Nazi Doctors

In Robert Jay Lifton: Nazi Doctors, the content is difficult. The narrative form, absent of the usual visual cues, complements, even enhances, that difficulty.

Robert Jay Lifton: Nazi Doctors

Director: Hannes Karnick, Wolfgang Richter
Cast: Robert Jay Lifton
Rated: NR
Studio: National Center for Jewish Film
Year: 2009
US date: 2010-10-05 (Limited release)
Traumatic events are written and rewritten until they become codified and narrative form gradually replaces content as the focus of attention.

-- Kali Tal

"We doctors are descendants of the shaman, of the pre-modern world," says Robert Jay Lifton. Seated at his desk in Cape Cod, the sea lapping at the shore just outside his window, this doctor looks serene. Much as shamans claimed to comprehend the border between life and death, he goes on, "Doctors can see themselves as mystical healers who have some moral prerogative that is of more than natural origin, to preside over life and death." Because of their "special role in societies," doctors can be tempted to see themselves both as special and as representative, to be "enlisted for killing or for controlling reality in some way."

Lifton comes to this grim and sinuous pronouncement -- a pronouncement that includes him in his "we"-- via his many hours of interviews with Nazi doctors, which he described and analyzed in his 1986 book, The Nazi Doctors: Medical Killing and the Psychology of Genocide. He condenses his conclusions for Hannes Karnick and Wolfgang Richter's film, Robert Jay Lifton: Nazi Doctors, screening at New York's Film Forum through 12 October. But even this short version is chilling, as Lifton's primary point of excavation is how ordinary people become "socialized to killing." Doctors are a specific case, even in their generalness and their sometimes "mythic" status, because they typically take the Hippocratic Oath. The Nazi doctors, he says, were sometimes fervent ideologues, but more often they learned to participate in the killing and to see what they were doing at Auschwitz as medical activity. They came to believe that killing could be a means of healing, if considered in relation to populations rather than individuals.

The film calls Lifton an "early proponent of the techniques of psychohistory," by which he sorts through not just events and politics but also through possible emotional and intellectual frameworks. He makes his case about the doctors -- individuals, he notes but all participants -- repeatedly and quietly. Sometimes he's responding to questions asked from offscreen, as the film articulates its own storytelling process. The first of these sets up a central problem for the documentary -- and really, any film about the Holocaust -- how will they make a film about "things that are nearly impossible to show"? Lifton has a ready answer, based on his own efforts to represent these "things" through his research and books and lectures, that "one has to fail to comprehend the entire event. It's elusive, but one can capture or illuminate some portion of it." That part is here indicated in Lifton's own figure as he speaks, his gestures, his surroundings (shots of trees and the seashore, with piano or somber strings), and a small metal-scraps sculpture of a man he keeps in his window, shown in close-up more than once.

These images don't show much, at least not in the usual manner of Holocaust documentaries. Robert Jay Lifton: Nazi Doctors keeps focused on its subject, rather than archival shots of emaciated bodies or smokestacks or riding-booted SS officers. In fact, the rather conventional opening credits sequence (blurry frames of collected suitcases, shoes, and broken dolls) looks inadequate and a little obvious once Lifton begins talking. Recalling his research for his book -- interviews with individuals and his own thoughts about the process of such interviewing -- Lifton draws attention to what Kali Tal calls the "narrative form" of trauma stories, and in so doing, raises the possibility of attending to the content as well.

Here the form is cut back to its barest bones, with some measure of complication. As Lifton is and also plays the storyteller, he points out how he viewed his own subjects (he was struck by "A lot of comfort that people had who were part of that evil structure and didn’t deserve that comfort"), how he formulated questions ("Mostly the interview built gradually... It wasn’t my goal to ask a shocking question to start with, 'How many people did you kill?' or something like that"), and how doctors came to accept the "medicalization of killing," that is, to see it as of a piece with their Hippocratic Oath rather than opposed.

The content is difficult, to hear, to tell, to comprehend. The narrative form, absent of the usual visual cues, complements, even enhances, that difficulty. As Lifton discusses process, the film shows process, just a little. Near the end, a scene suggests the unnerving un-representability even of conversation about the topic, as the frame shows his interviewers' backs, a camera visible on the desk between them and Lifton, who faces them as he has throughout the filming. The music soundtrack comes up at this moment, to the point that their conversation is hard to hear. At first look, this seems odd, even inept filmmaking, the seeming gist of the scene pulling away as you watch and expect that point to be delivered. But then, you see, this is a point, their conversation and your comprehension receding.

This moment, so awkward and allusive, speaks to the experience the film more broadly, the sheer horror of "medicalized killing" (which Lifton calls "the purest reversal of healing and killing"), the inversion of moral and social codes, the answers that lead to more questions. Lifton includes himself in this process, revisiting his own reactions as these shape stories of Nazi doctors. In his own writing, he says, "I am struck by the extent to which Auschwitz could be seen as an evil, mythic hospital center, on a vast scale." What might "evil" be, in a place so awful and so banal? How is evil a means to define good, to maintain a sense of "normal," that is not "deviant"? The Nazi doctors found (and conjured) a logic for their work, so they could do it. "There is the theory," Lifton says, "of the absolute need for maintaining the health of the ‘Volk’, of the people, of the Nazi-centered community, which is the only healthy community and one must get rid of all disease and disease threats to that healthy community."

So too, the logic of evil and good, the opposition, grants a structure for perceiving and protecting community elsewhere. Lifton describes the traumatic experiences he's studied -- the Vietnam war, the Holocaust, Hiroshima, and now, terrorism -- as "extreme situations." As these are shaped by advancing technologies, they are also, apparently, ever escalating (Lifton is a founding member of the International Physicians for the Prevention of Nuclear War). But such situations are not only different, other, and unfathomable, as they are typically described. They are also familiar and comprehensible. "There's no absolute barrier between good and evil," Lifton observes. The goal is to recognize how that barrier might be represented and also, not.






Alright Alright's "Don't Worry" Is an Ode for Unity in Troubling Times (premiere)

Alright Alright's "Don't Worry" is a gentle, prayerful tune that depicts the heart of their upcoming album, Crucible.


Tim Bowness of No-Man Discusses Thematic Ambition Amongst Social Division

With the release of his seventh solo album, Late Night Laments, Tim Bowness explores global tensions and considers how musicians can best foster mutual understanding in times of social unrest.


Angel Olsen Creates a 'Whole New Mess'

No one would call Angel Olsen's Whole New Mess a pretty album. It's much too stark. But there's something riveting about the way Olsen coos to herself that's soft and comforting.


Masma Dream World Go Global and Trippy on "Sundown Forest" (premiere)

Dancer, healer, musician Devi Mambouka shares the trippy "Sundown Forest", which takes listeners deep into the subconscious and onto a healing path.


'What a Fantastic Death Abyss': David Bowie's 'Outside' at 25

David Bowie's Outside signaled the end of him as a slick pop star and his reintroduction as a ragged-edged arty agitator.


Dream Folk's Wolf & Moon Awaken the Senses with "Eyes Closed" (premiere)

Berlin's Wolf & Moon are an indie folk duo with a dream pop streak. "Eyes Closed" highlights this aspect as the act create a deep sense of atmosphere and mood with the most minimal of tools.


Ranking the Seasons of 'The Wire'

Years after its conclusion, The Wire continues to top best-of-TV lists. With each season's unique story arc, each viewer is likely to have favorites.


Paul Reni's Silent Film 'The Man Who Laughs' Is Serious Cinema

There's so much tragedy present, so many skullduggeries afoot, and so many cruel and vindictive characters in attendance that a sad and heartbreaking ending seems to be an obvious given in Paul Reni's silent film, The Man Who Laughs.


The Grahams Tell Their Daughter "Don't Give Your Heart Away" (premiere)

The Grahams' sweet-sounding "Don't Give Your Heart Away" is rooted in struggle, inspired by the couples' complicated journey leading up to their daughter's birth.


Gloom Balloon Deliver an Uplifting Video for "All My Feelings For You" (premiere)

Gloom Balloon's Patrick Tape Fleming considers what making a music video during a pandemic might involve because, well, he made one. Could Fellini come up with this plot twist?


What 'O Brother, Where Art Thou?' Gets Right (and Wrong) About America

Telling the tale of the cyclops through the lens of high and low culture, in O'Brother, Where Art Thou? the Coens hammer home a fatalistic criticism about the ways that commerce, violence, and cosmetic Christianity prevail in American society .


Brian Cullman Gets Bluesy with "Someday Miss You" (premiere)

Brian Cullman's "Someday Miss You" taps into American roots music, carries it across the Atlantic and back for a sound that is both of the past and present.


IDLES Have Some Words for Fans and Critics on 'Ultra Mono'

On their new album, Ultra Mono, IDLES tackle both the troubling world around them and the dissenters that want to bring them down.


Napalm Death Return With Their Most Vital Album in Decades

Grindcore institution Napalm Death finally reconcile their experimental side with their ultra-harsh roots on Throes of Joy in the Jaws of Defeatism.


NYFF: 'Notturno' Looks Passively at the Chaos in the Middle East

Gianfranco Rosi's expansive documentary, Notturno, is far too remote for its burningly immediate subject matter.


The Avett Brothers Go Back-to-Basics with 'The Third Gleam'

For their latest EP, The Third Gleam, the Avett Brothers leave everything behind but their songs and a couple of acoustic guitars, a bass, and a banjo.


PM Picks Playlist 1: Rett Madison, Folk Devils + More

The first PopMatters Picks Playlist column features searing Americana from Rett Madison, synthpop from Everything and Everybody, the stunning electropop of Jodie Nicholson, the return of post-punk's Folk Devils, and the glammy pop of Baby FuzZ.


David Lazar's 'Celeste Holm  Syndrome' Appreciates Hollywood's Unsung Character Actors

David Lazar's Celeste Holm Syndrome documents how character actor work is about scene-defining, not scene-stealing.

Collapse Expand Reviews

Collapse Expand Features

PM Picks
Collapse Expand Pm Picks

© 1999-2020 All rights reserved.
PopMatters is wholly independent, women-owned and operated.