'The Oath': American Intelligence Gets it Wrong

With The Oath, director Laura Poitras highlights the contradictions and failures of America's "war on terror".

The Oath

Director: Laura Poitras
Cast: Salim Hamdan, Abu Jandal
Distributor: Zeitgeist Films
Studio: ITVS/P.O.V./Praxis Films
Release Date: 2010-09

The Oath tells the story of the sharply contrasting fates of two brothers-in-law, both of whom were involved with Al Qaeda. The film also offers a critique of American choices in the so-called war on terror, in particular the processes used to gather intelligence and bring alleged terrorists to trial in the days and years following the 9/11 terrorist attacks.

As the film begins in 2007, Abu Jandal is a cab driver in Sana’a, Yemen, and the father of an adorable young son. He’s an articulate and charismatic individual who is equally comfortable chatting with customers in his taxicab, discussing Islam with groups of earnest young men who gather in his home, or being interviewed on a program for the television channel Al Arabiyah. Abu Jandal was formerly chief bodyguard to Osama Bin Laden and knew the men involved in the 9/11 attacks but says he has left that life behind and now abjures violence.

Meanwhile Salim Hamdan, father of two daughters (one of whom he has never seen), has been a prisoner for seven years at the US military prison in Guantanamo Bay, Cuba. The name may be familiar: the 2006 Hamdan v. Rumsfeld decision by the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that the military commissions set up to try detainees at Guantanamo Bay violated both the Geneva Conventions and the Uniform Code of Military Justice. That decision did not bring Hamdan freedom but it did motivate the U.S. Congress to pass the Military Commissions Act which created a new charge: providing material support for terrorism. Hamdan’s defense attorney claims this charge was invented specifically so the government could convict him of something and he may well be right: when Hamdan stood trial in 2007 it was the only charge of which he would be convicted.

Most of The Oath is involved in filling in the background of these two men, who met in Yemen in 1996, and moving forward with Hamdan’s trial. In 1996 Abu Jandal was a true believer in the goals of Al Qaeda and recruited Hamdan into the organization. Hamdan was an orphan with a fourth-grade education who later said he was glad to accept a job as driver for Osama Bin Laden simply because of the salary it paid. They became brothers-in-law after Osama Bin Laden ordered them to marry sisters.

Hamdan was never a very big player in Al Qaeda, but in 2001 he had the misfortune to be picked up by Afghan forces in Kandahar (he says they were looking for people “to sell to the Americans”), taken into American custody, and subjected to coercive interrogation before being brought to trial. Meanwhile Abu Jandal, who was much more of an Al Qaeda insider, was spared this fate due because he was imprisoned in Yemen on charges of being involved in the 2000 attack on the U.S.S. Cole. However, he was still was interrogated by the FBI for 15 days shortly after 9/11, producing so much useful information that his conventional interrogation was later cited as an example of why ordinary psychological techniques are more useful than torture in gathering intelligence.

The Oath is never less than fascinating, thanks to a strong vision by director Laura Poitras, excellent cinematography by Kirsten Johnson and Poitras (which won Best Documentary Cinematography at Sundance) and first-rate editing by Jonathan Oppenheim. However its deliberate fragmentation can be confusing as attention constantly shifts between locations and story lines and the film seems to give equal weight to mundane scenes (a family outing, father and son watching television) as to major events. Ultimately it’s a film of many individual moments which offers up a selection of contradictory and conflicting information (much of it from the lips of Abu Jandal) and requires the viewer to come up with their own version of the truth.

I’m grateful that The Oath does not over-simplify a complex situation (the mass media has that market cornered already) but despite regular title cards intended to keep the viewer on course, it’s still easy to get lost in the twists and turns and illogical turn of events. It doesn’t help that there is a major imbalance between the protagonists, with the garrulous, charming Abu Jandal dominating the film while Salim Hamdan, who declined to be interviewed, is seen only in a brief interrogation clip and heard mainly through an actor who reads his words. Cameras were not allowed in the courtroom during Hamdan’s trial and the press briefings were subject to censorship so even that potentially dramatic event loses some of its impact. The result is that although this film is the story of two men, one makes a strong impression while the other, whose story is more significant from a legal and historical point of view, inevitably seems less important.

The print and sound on the DVD of The Oath are sharp and clear. Extras include a four-page insert, trailers for this film and My Country, My Country, (which form the first two parts of Poitras’ planned trilogy about America following 9/11) and about 28-minutes of unused footage shot for the film including extended and often revealing interviews with Abu Jandal.





Paul Weller - "Earth Beat" (Singles Going Steady)

Paul Weller's singular modes as a soul man, guitar hero, and techno devotee converge into a blissful jam about hope for the earth on "Earth Beat".


On Point and Click Adventure Games with Creator Joel Staaf Hästö

Point and click adventure games, says Kathy Rain and Whispers of a Machine creator Joel Staaf Hästö, hit a "sweet spot" between puzzles that exercise logical thinking and stories that stimulate emotions.


The 50 Best Post-Punk Albums Ever: Part 1, Gang of Four to the Birthday Party

If we must #quarantine, at least give us some post-punk. This week we are revisiting the best post-punk albums of all-time and we kick things off with Gang of Four, Public Image Ltd., Throbbing Gristle, and more.


Alison Chesley Toils in Human and Musical Connectivity on Helen Money's 'Atomic'

Chicago-based cellist, Alison Chesley (a.k.a. Helen Money) creates an utterly riveting listen from beginning to end on Atomic.


That Kid's 'Crush' Is a Glittering Crossroads for E-Boy Music

That Kid's Crush stands out for its immediacy as a collection of light-hearted party music, but the project struggles with facelessness.


Percival Everett's ​​​'Telephone​​​' Offers a Timely Lesson

Telephone provides a case study of a family dynamic shaken by illness, what can be controlled, and what must be accepted.


Dream Pop's Ellis Wants to be 'Born Again'

Ellis' unhappiness serves as armor to protect her from despair on Born Again. It's better to be dejected than psychotic.


Counterbalance No. 10: 'Never Mind the Bollocks, Here's the Sex Pistols'

The Spirit of ’77 abounds as Sex Pistols round out the Top Ten on the Big List. Counterbalance take a cheap holiday in other people’s misery. Right. Now.


'Thor: Ragnorak' Destroys and Discards the Thor Mythos

Taika Waititi's Thor: Ragnarok takes a refreshingly iconoclastic approach to Thor, throwing out the old, bringing in the new, and packaging the story in a colourful, gorgeously trashy aesthetic that perfectly captures the spirit of the comics.


Alps 2 and Harry No Release Eclectic Single "Madness at Toni's Chip Shop in Wishaw" (premiere)

Alps 2 and Harry NoSong's "Madness at Toni's Chip Shop in Wishaw" is a dizzying mix of mangled 2-step rhythms and woozy tranquil electronics.


Kathleen Grace and Larry Goldings Team for Wonderfully Sparse "Where Or When" (premiere)

Kathleen Grace and Larry Goldings' "Where Or When" is a wonderfully understated performance that walks the line between pop and jazz.


Run the Jewels - "Ooh LA LA" (Singles Going Steady)

Run the Jewels' "Ooh LA LA" may hit with old-school hip-hop swagger, but it also frustratingly affirms misogynistic bro-culture.


New Translation of Balzac's 'Lost Illusions' Captivates

More than just a tale of one man's fall, Balzac's Lost Illusions charts how literature becomes another commodity in a system that demands backroom deals, moral compromise, and connections.


Protomartyr - "Processed by the Boys" (Singles Going Steady)

Protomartyr's "Processed By the Boys" is a gripping spin on reality as we know it, and here, the revolution is being televised.


Go-Go's Bassist Kathy Valentine Is on the "Write" Track After a Rock-Hard Life

The '80s were a wild and crazy time also filled with troubles, heartbreak and disappointment for Go-Go's bass player-guitarist Kathy Valentine, who covers many of those moments in her intriguing dual project that she discusses in this freewheeling interview.


New Brain Trajectory: An Interview With Lee Ranaldo and Raül Refree

Two guitarists, Lee Ranaldo and Raül Refree make an album largely absent of guitar playing and enter into a bold new phase of their careers. "We want to take this wherever we can and be free of genre restraints," says Lee Ranaldo.


'Trans Power' Is a Celebration of Radical Power and Beauty

Juno Roche's Trans Power discusses trans identity not as a passageway between one of two linear destinations, but as a destination of its own.


Yves Tumor Soars With 'Heaven to a Tortured Mind'

On Heaven to a Tortured Mind, Yves Tumor relishes his shift to microphone caressing rock star. Here he steps out of his sonic chrysalis, dons some shiny black wings and soars.


Mike Patton and Anthony Pateras' tētēma Don't Hit the Mark on 'Necroscape'

tētēma's Necroscape has some highlights and some interesting ambiance, but ultimately it's a catalog of misses for Mike Patton and Anthony Pateras.


M. Ward Offers Comforting Escapism on 'Migration Stories'

Although M. Ward didn't plan the songs on Migration Stories for this pandemic, they're still capable of acting as a balm in these dark hours.

Collapse Expand Reviews
Collapse Expand Features
PM Picks
Collapse Expand Pm Picks

© 1999-2020 All rights reserved.
PopMatters is wholly independent, women-owned and operated.