Three of Hearts: A Postmodern Love Story

Showing how three individuals create a family, Three of Hearts underlines how the idea and the experience change over time.

Three of Hearts: A Postmodern Love Story

Director: Susan Kaplan
Cast: Sam Cagnina, Steven Margolin, Samantha Singh
Rated: NR
Studio: ThinkFilm
Year: 2005
US date: 2011-05-10 (Stranger Than Fiction)

"Sorry we're late!" chirp Sam and Steven, coming home after a day at work. Greeted by their wife Samantha, they wonder, "Did you get the test yet?" Even before they begin explaining, you know: they mean the home pregnancy test.

The beginning of Three of Hearts: A Postmodern Love Story is at once conventional and not. On its surface, the introduction to this happy marriage of three people looks like a scene from a sitcom, the performances bright and the apartment space tight. At the same time, the 2005 film -- which screens 10 May at Stranger Than Fiction, followed by a Q&A with director Susan Kaplan -- is utterly upfront about its status as such.

In framing events and individuals in a storyline, the film makes visible their efforts to make sense, to name themselves and each other, to create a new sort of family. To this end, the documentary offers a series of episodes marked by captions ("Sam's brother") and title cards ("18 months later"). By the time you come to the film's end, and the film thanks Sam Cagnina, Steven Margolin, and Samantha Singh "for sharing the last eight years with us," you feel like part of that us. And not.

Maintaining this set of delicate tensions, Three of Hearts both respects and, to an unusual extent, reveals its subjects. While it's easy to see how they seemed remarkable and compelling subjects for a documentary, Sam, Steven, and Samantha are from the start very aware of the camera, speaking to it and performing for it. Again and again, they describe their situation and what they feel about that situation. As each recalls how they met, and how they decided to live as three, you see snapshots of their younger selves or home movie recordings with visible time-stamps.

These images convey both history and change, expectations and thought processes. "I'd been with Sam for seven years before we met Samantha," says Steven, adding that he'd been with both men and women before that. "It wasn’t a sex that I was capable of falling in love with," he says, "It was a person." For Sam, apparently, coming to a sense of his identity -- and his sexuality -- was more complicated. As he describes his childhood, the film shows a clip of Anita Bryant proclaiming that homosexuals "are not born that way, that they can be delivered through faith and trust in Jesus Christ." Sam reflects, "My mother said, 'I'd beat the shit out of you.' Oh my God," he sighs, "I could never tell anyone what was going on with me." The film cuts here, from Sam in interviewee's repose to a knife, chopping hard: it's Steven and Sam in the kitchen, preparing dinner. Sam goes on, remembering how he formulated the idea to himself: "Wouldn't it be great to have a woman in the relationship, who would fall in love with both of us?"

And so, Sam and Steven narrate, they tried more than once to "bring a woman into the relationship," not quite explaining, "It just didn't work" until they met Samantha. Following some discussion of the prospect, she says, she agreed to try it after she saw Wings of Desire. "This angel who comes down because he wants to experience love," she says, "I think in that night, I did he same thing. I went out there and tried something different."

And yet, all three suggest repeatedly that they were seeking something that was less different than the same... or rather, the same but better. Samantha remembers believing she'd met an ideal combination of men, one who was "reliable" and another who was "funny," and Sam helpfully demonstrates his role as the latter: "You can't call it monogamy, though, can you?" he asks, before conjuring a potential label: "Poly-gamy?"

As they laugh and smile and answer questions, they also have lives (including a thriving chiropractic and therapeutic massage business, set up in an office where all three have roles) as well as changing expectations. For the film's sake -- at least -- they sort through definitions, sometimes to assert their otherness but just as often to insist on their likeness to everyone else. They don't so much resist categories as they reassign them: when Samantha's sister Sabina describes her as a "tomboy" and Samantha calls herself a "princess" ("What woman wouldn’t want that, you know?"), Steven's sister Tami offers her version: "They'd buy her clothes and they'd buy her presents and they'd shop for her and, I mean, really took care of her, like you’ve never seen. And they did they treated he better than most men treat their wives."

Elucidating their choices and goals, Sam and Steven and Samantha begin to see themselves, and each other, differently. They enter into therapy, separately and together. They have a first child, Siena, and then a second, Summit. And as their "trinogomous" relationship changes, as it comes to a plainly difficult end after 13 years, they explain some more. Here the film doesn't change shape so much as it accommodates new separate self-articulations. The camera follows them through a new office (and aptly metaphorical construction problems), a new apartment, a new sense of each other. Perhaps most strikingly, they bring in a mediator to help establish "boundaries" and financial obligations. The camera follows behind as he walks from dining room to bedroom, to deliver conditions and rejections, as the three can no longer sit together in the same space. "I didn’t create this family," he tells them, "You guys did."

As it begins and ends on this note -- creating a family -- Three of Hearts underlines how the idea and the experience change over time. Strikingly, such changes have as much to do with trying to be "like everyone else" as with trying to be "different." Samantha reveals that she at first didn't say anything about the breakup she felt was coming because "I didn’t want to rock the happy boat." And Sam says, "I was trying to be as normal as I could be in the craziness of my life. Was Samantha a way of fitting in? I think there's some truth to that." Some truth, but not all of it. For all the revealing and performing and articulating in Three of Hearts, what seems clearest by its end is that truth is always shifting.





'Everything's Gonna Be Okay' Is  Better Than Okay

The first season of Freeform's Everything's Gonna Be Okay is a funny, big-hearted love letter to family.


Jordan Rakei Breathes New Life Into Soul Music

Jordan Rakei is a restless artistic spirit who brings R&B, jazz, hip-hop, and pop craft into his sumptuous, warm music. Rakei discusses his latest album and new music he's working on that will sound completely different from everything he's done so far.


Country Music's John Anderson Counts the 'Years'

John Anderson, who continues to possess one of country music's all-time great voices, contemplates life, love, mortality, and resilience on Years.


Rory Block's 'Prove It on Me' Pays Tribute to Women's Blues

The songs on Rory Block's Prove It on Me express the strength of female artists despite their circumstances as second class citizens in both the musical world and larger American society.


The 50 Best Post-Punk Albums Ever: Part 3, Echo & the Bunnymen to Lizzy Mercier Descloux

This week we are celebrating the best post-punk albums of all-time and today we have part three with Echo & the Bunnymen, Cabaret Voltaire, Pere Ubu and more.


Wendy Carlos: Musical Pioneer, Reluctant Icon

Amanda Sewell's vastly informative new biography on musical trailblazer Wendy Carlos is both reverent and honest.


British Folk Duo Orpine Share Blissful New Song "Two Rivers" (premiere)

Orpine's "Two Rivers" is a gently undulating, understated folk song that provides a welcome reminder of the enduring majesty of nature.


Blesson Roy Gets "In Tune With the Moon" (premiere)

Terry Borden was a member of slowcore pioneers Idaho and a member of Pete Yorn's band. Now he readies the debut of Blesson Roy and shares "In Tune With the Moon".


In 'Wandering Dixie', Discovering the Jewish South Is Part of Discovering Self

Sue Eisenfeld's Wandering Dixie is not only a collection of dispatches from the lost Jewish South but also a journey of self-discovery.


Bill Withers and the Curse of the Black Genius

"Lean on Me" singer-songwriter Bill Withers was the voice of morality in an industry without honor. It's amazing he lasted this long.


Jeff Baena Explores the Intensity of Mental Illness in His Mystery, 'Horse Girl'

Co-writer and star Alison Brie's unreliable narrator in Jeff Baena's Horse Girl makes for a compelling story about spiraling into mental illness.


Pokey LaFarge Hits 'Rock Bottom' on His Way Up

Americana's Pokey LaFarge performs music in front of an audience as a way of conquering his personal demons on Rock Bottom.


Joni Mitchell's 'Shine' Is More Timely and Apt Than Ever

Joni Mitchell's 2007 eco-nightmare opus, Shine is more timely and apt than ever, and it's out on vinyl for the first time.


'Live at Carnegie Hall' Captures Bill Withers at His Grittiest and Most Introspective

Bill Withers' Live at Carnegie Hall manages to feel both exceptionally funky and like a new level of grown-up pop music for its time.


Dual Identities and the Iranian Diaspora: Sepehr Debuts 'Shaytoon'

Electronic producer Sepehr discusses his debut album releasing Friday, sparing no detail on life in the Iranian diaspora, the experiences of being raised by ABBA-loving Persian rug traders, and the illegal music stores that still litter modern Iran.


From the Enterprise to the Discovery: The Decline and Fall of Utopian Technology and the Liberal Dream

The technology and liberalism of recent series such as Star Trek: Discovery, Star Trek: Picard, and the latest Doctor Who series have more in common with Harry Potter's childish wand-waving than Gene Roddenberry's original techno-utopian dream.


The 50 Best Post-Punk Albums Ever: Part 2, The B-52's to Magazine

This week we are celebrating the best post-punk albums of all-time and today we have part two with the Cure, Mission of Burma, the B-52's and more.


Emily Keener's "Boats" Examines Our Most Treasured Relationships (premiere)

Folk artist Emily Keener's "Boats" offers a warm look back on the road traveled so far—a heartening reflection for our troubled times.


Paul Weller - "Earth Beat" (Singles Going Steady)

Paul Weller's singular modes as a soul man, guitar hero, and techno devotee converge into a blissful jam about hope for the earth on "Earth Beat".


On Point and Click Adventure Games with Creator Joel Staaf Hästö

Point and click adventure games, says Kathy Rain and Whispers of a Machine creator Joel Staaf Hästö, hit a "sweet spot" between puzzles that exercise logical thinking and stories that stimulate emotions.

Collapse Expand Reviews
Collapse Expand Features
PM Picks
Collapse Expand Pm Picks

© 1999-2020 All rights reserved.
PopMatters is wholly independent, women-owned and operated.