The Top 10 Films That Should Have Won Best Picture

Oscar always gets it 'wrong.' Here are 10 Best Picture reasons (out of many) why.

So...the Academy got it 'wrong' again. Big deal. Ever since the movie industry closed ranks and decided to reward itself on the "greatest" achievements among their fellow filmmakers, there's been the same old debate: How could Cary Grant never win an Oscar? How could Katherine Hepburn win so many? Why was Hitchcock snubbed? Why did it take (insert years or decades here) for (insert name and or title here) to finally get recognized? Nowhere is the argument more heated, however, than in the backwards glancing give and take of Best Picture. As a proposed representation of what the artform does right every year, there are many who believe that the members of the AMPAS consistently get this highest honor wrong. In fact, if one looks over the 80 plus winners of the coveted prize (and their competition at the time), one can discover at least 30 instances when the wrong film (arguably) triumphed.

So in order to correct this cruel mistake, we've gone back through the list of Best Picture winners and come up with the 10 Films that should have won the Academy's highest accolade. Now, we have dispensed with some most glaring and obvious omissions (Raging Bull over Ordinary People, Pulp Fiction and a certain Mr. Gump, Goodfellas vs. Dancing with Wolves) while keeping a few which are so flagrant in their wrongheadedness that they require another mention. Also, we aren't going to jump beyond the actual nominated entries for any given year. Sure, we leap at any chance to mention our undying devotion to 2001: A Space Odyssey or Miller's Crossing, but since the members of the voting cabal choose not to every recognize them with a nomination, we will do the same (sadly).

Yes, there are many more examples that can be highlighted, and any discussion of slights is still a question of opinion, but sometimes, a mistake is a mistake. Of course, when Oscar makes a misstep, it resonates for a very long time - as with the first selection on our list.

1941: Citizen Kane over How Green Was My Valley
Yes, this is one of those obvious ones. We admit it. But it's almost impossible to conceive that a film as inventive, as important, and as consistently acclaimed as Kane could walk away with only one Academy Award (for screenplay). The year's winner was a nice little bit of dry, dated nostalgia, but when compared to what many believe is the best film of all time, the eventual win is laughable. Of course, there was even more politicking and cronyism back then, so the decision is understandable. Historically and aesthetically, it's indefensible, however.

1951: A Place in the Sun over An American in Paris
This is a close call. In truth, we could have picked 1948's The Red Shoes over Laurence Olivier's Hamlet, or Spellbound over The Lost Weekend, but we choose this example of misguided rewarding since it illustrates a trend that would haunt the AMPAS for decades to come. If there is a perfect example of "Oscar Bait," Paris is it. Dull, overblown, artsy, and totally locked in its time, it's a fine film, just not the year's pinnacle. Sun was superior in every way. And remember, just because it's beloved doesn't mean it's the best.

1964: Dr. Strangelove over My Fair Lady
While this may seem like another no brainer, there are those who passionately defend the Lerner and Loewe musical as a grand, great work of art. We, of course, argue that any film where the main actress can't actually sing her own role more or less defeats the point of the genre. Besides, Ms. Hepburn's box office clout was the only reason the original Eliza, Julie Andrews, was dropped from consideration. As he would throughout much of his career, Stanley Kubrick watched from the sidelines as his unquestionable brilliance was marginalized by the members of the Academy. Strangelove should have been the start of a series of wins for him.

1971: Five Easy Pieces over Patton
The counterculture is breathing down your neck. The other mediums are embracing the change within the country. The post-modern movement is threatening to wipe out the last remaining vestiges of the old Hollywood. So what do you do as the tastemakers for an entire artform? You embrace a pro-war rant about a heroic if pigheaded military man and let the conservatives in your club drop statues all over it. '71 also saw M*A*S*H* and Love Story nominated, but for our money, this Bob Rafelson gem deserved the top prize. As the perfect Patton antidote, it probably had no chance.

1976: Network or Taxi Driver over Rocky
The debate here is not really over the eventual winner (Rocky remains a rollicking, well made piece of sports pandering) but what would actually be the substitute selection. On the one side is Martin Scorsese's landmark work of urban alienation. On the other is Paddy Chayefsky's spot-on denouncement of the trending tabloid television (about 20 years before it's time). Trying to choose between the two (and for S&Gs, we could throw the equally amazing All the President's Men into the mix as well) becomes a decision of undeniable difficulty. If it were up to us, the boob tube would trump the loony lone gunman.

Next Page

The year in song reflected the state of the world around us. Here are the 70 songs that spoke to us this year.

70. The Horrors - "Machine"

On their fifth album V, the Horrors expand on the bright, psychedelic territory they explored with Luminous, anchoring the ten new tracks with retro synths and guitar fuzz freakouts. "Machine" is the delicious outlier and the most vitriolic cut on the record, with Faris Badwan belting out accusations to the song's subject, who may even be us. The concept of alienation is nothing new, but here the Brits incorporate a beautiful metaphor of an insect trapped in amber as an illustration of the human caught within modernity. Whether our trappings are technological, psychological, or something else entirely makes the statement all the more chilling. - Tristan Kneschke

Keep reading... Show less

Electronic music is one of the broadest-reaching genres by design, and 2017 highlights that as well as any other year on record. These are the 20 best albums.

20. Vitalic - Voyager (Citizen)

Pascal Arbez-Nicolas (a.k.a. Vitalic) made waves in the French Touch electro-house scene with his 2005 debut, OK Cowboy, which had a hard-hitting maximalist sound, but several albums later, Voyager finds him launching into realms beyond at his own speed. The quirky, wallflower vocals and guitar snippets employed throughout Voyager drop a funk that brings to mind WhoMadeWho or Matthew Dear if they had disco-pop injected between their toes. "Levitation" is as pure a slice of dance floor motivation as theoretically possible, a sci-fi gunfight with a cracking house beat sure to please his oldest fans, yet the album-as-form is equally effective in its more contemplative moments, like when Miss Kitten's vocals bring an ethereal dispassion to "Hans Is Driving" to balance out its somber vocoder or the heartfelt cover of "Don't Leave Me Now" by Supertramp. Voyager may infect you with a futuristic form of Saturday Night Fever, but afterwards, it gives you a hearty dose of aural acetaminophen to break it. - Alan Ranta

Keep reading... Show less

Hitchcock, 'Psycho', and '78/52: Hitchcock's Shower Scene'

Alfred Hitchock and Janet Leigh on the set of Psycho (courtesy of Dogwoof)

"... [Psycho] broke every taboo you could possibly think of, it reinvented the language of film and revolutionised what you could do with a story on a very precise level. It also fundamentally and profoundly changed the ritual of movie going," says 78/52 director, Alexandre O. Philippe.

The title of Alexandre O. Philippe's 78/52: Hitchcock's Shower Scene (2017) denotes the 78 set-ups and the 52 cuts across a full week of shooting for Psycho's (1960) famous shower scene. Known for The People vs. George Lucas (2010), The Life and Times of Paul the Psychic Octopus (2012) and Doc of the Dead (2014), Philippe's exploration of a singular moment is a conversational one, featuring interviews with Walter Murch, Peter Bogdanovich, Guillermo del Toro, Jamie Lee Curtis, Osgood Perkins, Danny Elfman, Eli Roth, Elijah Wood, Bret Easton Ellis, Karyn Kusama, Neil Marshall, Richard Stanley and Marli Renfro, body double for Janet Leigh.

Keep reading... Show less

Mary Poppins, Mrs. Gamp, Egyptian deities, a Japanese umbrella spirit, and a supporting cast of hundreds of brollies fill Marion Rankine's lively history.

"What can go up a chimney down but can't go down a chimney up?" Marion Rankine begins her wide-ranging survey of the umbrella and its significance with this riddle. It nicely establishes her theme: just as umbrellas undergo, in the everyday use of them, a transformation, so too looking at this familiar, even forgettable object from multiple perspectives transforms our view of it.

Keep reading... Show less

Those who regard the reclusive Argerich as one of the world's two or three greatest living pianists—classical or otherwise—would not have left the concert hall disillusioned.

In a staid city like Washington, D.C., too many concert programs still stick to the basics. An endless litany of Rachmaninoff and Tchaikovsky concerti clog the schedules and parades of overeager virtuosi seem unwilling to vary their repertoire for blasé D.C. concertgoers. But occasionally you encounter a concert that refreshes your perspective of the familiar. The works presented at The Kennedy Center on 25 October 2017 might be stalwarts of 20th century repertoire, but guest conductor Antonio Pappano, leading the Orchestra dell'Accademia Nazionale di Santa Cecilia, reminded us how galvanizing the canonical can still be. Though grandiose executions of Respighi's The Fountains of Rome and The Pines of Rome were the main event, the sold-out crowd gathered to see Martha Argerich perform one of her showpieces, Prokofiev's Third Piano Concerto. Those who regard the reclusive Argerich as one of the world's two or three greatest living pianists—classical or otherwise—would not have left the concert hall disillusioned.

Keep reading... Show less
Pop Ten
Mixed Media
PM Picks

© 1999-2017 All rights reserved.
Popmatters is wholly independently owned and operated.