Sherlock Holmes and Philosophy by Josef Steiff

It's still elementary and the game's still afoot. Sherlock Holmes and Philosophy explains why.

Sherlock Holmes and Philosophy: The Footprints of a Giant Mind

Price: $19.95
Publisher: Open Court Publishing
Length: 384 pages
Editor: Josef Steiff
Format: Paperback
Publication Date: 2011-10

“I’m in love with Sherlock Holmes.”

This is the opening line of Sherlock Holmes and Philosophy: The Footprints of a Gigantic Mind, edited by Josef Steiff and part of the Popular Culture and Philosophy series that includes such titles as Star Trek and Philosophy: The Wrath of Kant and The Red Socks and Philosophy: Green Monster Meditations.

Sherlock Holmes and Philosophy includes 33 chapters (many of which are quite short) epitomizing, mimicking, analyzing, and adoring all that is Sherlock Holmes. Take the opening line as a call to arms or a warning: these writers are serious about Sherlock Holmes.

However, most of the time the authors don’t appear to take themselves too seriously. Certainly some articles include more than a passing reference to Jacques Derrida, René Descartes, Frederick Jameson, Baruck Spinoza and the like, but with section headings such as “A Dog Reflects the Family Life” and chapter titles that include “Watson’s a Liar!” and “Why Sherlock Holmes Is My Favorite Drug Dealer” it’s easy to tell that the “game is still afoot” and that it’s time to have a little fun.

With articles that debate and analyze everything from who is a better friend (Watson or Holmes), talking detective dogs on Japanese television, why Holmes uses drugs, and Oscar Wilde’s influence on Arthur Conan Doyle, it’s definitely an eclectic mix of essays. In fact, an introduction to orientate might have been helpful.

And, of course, with so many different topics, some chapters will appeal to audiences more than others. My favs include the whimsical “The Adventure of the Candle and the Dumbbell” by Fiona Tomkinson. Primarily told as a story, it examines the question of objects versus things: “Is a thing natural and an object manufactured? Is thing a popular term and object a scientific one? Is it a question of value? Is a beryl coronet or a golden pince-nez an object, but a missing three-quarter merely a thing?”

Another top pick is “The Mystery of the Horrible Hound” by Rafe McGregor, who asks the question “How do I convince you that The Hound [of the Baskervilles] isn’t a mystery?” It is, according to McGregor, horror.

It seems fitting that a book dedicated to Sherlock Holmes should focus on questions, or perhaps a better way of looking at it: many chapters solve their own mini-mysteries.

Other chapters examine adaptations of the Sherlock Holmes’s character. “How Marriage Changes Sherlock Holmes” by Amy Kind investigates Holmes’s relationship with Mary Russell in Laurie R. King’s books and concludes: “Marriage to Mary Russell does indeed change Sherlock Holmes, but just as he does not sacrifice his identity to their pairing, neither does she sacrifice hers. And it’s for precisely this reason that their partnership, however surprising and unconventional it may be, is a successful one. It’s even—dare I say?—elementary.”

“Out of House and Holmes” by Julia Round draws comparisons between television character Dr. Gregory House and Sherlock Holmes and notes: “Both characters are eccentric and arrogant personalities, both are drug addicts… Both solve their cases through inductive reasoning and logical thought—dismissing all the incorrect solutions until only the correct one remains”.

Sherlock Holmes isn’t restricted to human form anymore, either, as Jonathan Clements’s chapter “The Curious Case of the Dog in Prime Time” indicates. He discusses the Japanese series Meitantei Holmes (in English it’s referred to as Sherlock Hound), an animated children’s series where all the characters—Holmes, Watson, Moriarty—are talking dogs.

Sherlock Holmes is, apparently, almost everywhere today, but more modern versions are not always completely successful. Tom Dowd opens his chapter “The Game Has Virtually Stumbled” with the lines “I can’t be Sherlock Holmes. And I’m somewhat annoyed by that.” This is true, Dowd notes, even in the virtual world: “I can’t ever satisfactorily play Sherlock Holmes because my brain doesn’t work like his does, and video games provide no mechanisms to assist me”.

Whether the adaptations work or not, Sherlock Holmes seems to be thriving in the 21st century, and some of the most successful chapters in Sherlock Holmes and Philosophy address why the world is still obsessed with Sherlock Holmes and why the characters of Sherlock Holmes (and even Dr. Watson) still work for today’s audiences.

Perhaps no chapter does this better than Rachel Michaels’ s “Why Sherlock Is Like a Good Hip-Hop Song”. Using the BBC television series Sherlock as her primary focus, she notes that “One hundred and twenty years after the first stories were published, we still need Holmes’s unique abilities. Though the times have changed, the essential characters of Holmes and Watson have not.” The characters stay the same—perhaps amped up a little—but now, as Michaels relates, their stories are told in comics, in televisions shows, in linear and nonlinear fashions. These characters moved from the Victorian periodical to the e-reader and video games.

Who knows how the next generation of Sherlockians will interact with Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson, but “One thing’s for sure, though—no matter what the era, Sherlock Holmes can solve the most improbable cases. His unerring powers of observation and deduction illustrate an apparently timeless faith in the applicability of empirical reason. And that, my dear, is elementary.”






Literary Scholar Andrew H. Miller On Solitude As a Common Bond

Andrew H. Miller's On Not Being Someone Else considers how contemplating other possibilities for one's life is a way of creating meaning in the life one leads.


Rodd Rathjen Discusses 'Buoyancy', His Film About Modern Slavery

Rodd Rathjen's directorial feature debut, Buoyancy, seeks to give a voice to the voiceless men and boys who are victims of slavery in Southeast Asia.


Hear the New, Classic Pop of the Parson Red Heads' "Turn Around" (premiere)

The Parson Red Heads' "Turn Around" is a pop tune, but pop as heard through ears more attuned to AM radio's glory days rather than streaming playlists and studio trickery.


Blitzen Trapper on the Afterlife, Schizophrenia, Civil Unrest and Our Place in the Cosmos

Influenced by the Tibetan Book of the Dead, Blitzen Trapper's new album Holy Smokes, Future Jokes plumbs the comedic horror of the human condition.

Love in the Time of Coronavirus

Fire in the Time of Coronavirus

If we venture out our front door we might inhale both a deadly virus and pinpoint flakes of ash. If we turn back in fear we may no longer have a door behind us.


Sufjan Stevens' 'The Ascension' Is Mostly Captivating

Even though Sufjan Stevens' The Ascension is sometimes too formulaic or trivial to linger, it's still a very good, enjoyable effort.

Jordan Blum

Chris Smither's "What I Do" Is an Honest Response to Old Questions (premiere + interview)

How does Chris Smither play guitar that way? What impact does New Orleans have on his music? He might not be able to answer those questions directly but he can sure write a song about it.


Sally Anne Morgan Invites Us Into a Metaphorical Safe Space on 'Thread'

With Thread, Sally Anne Morgan shows that traditional folk music is not to be smothered in revivalist praise. It's simply there as a seed with which to plant new gardens.


Godcaster Make the Psych/Funk/Hard Rock Debut of the Year

Godcaster's Long Haired Locusts is a swirling, sloppy mess of guitars, drums, flutes, synths, and apparently whatever else the band had on hand in their Philly basement. It's a highly entertaining and listenable album.


What 'O Brother, Where Art Thou?' Gets Right (and Wrong) About America

Telling the tale of the cyclops through the lens of high and low culture, in O'Brother, Where Art Thou? the Coens hammer home a fatalistic criticism about the ways that commerce, violence, and cosmetic Christianity prevail in American society .


The Dance of Male Forms in Denis' 'Beau travail'

Claire Denis' masterwork of cinematic poetry, Beau travail, is a cinematic ballet that tracks through tone and style the sublimation of violent masculine complexes into the silent convulsions of male angst.


The Cradle's 'Laughing in My Sleep' Is an Off-kilter Reflection of Musical Curiosity

The Cradle's Paco Cathcart has curated a thoughtfully multifarious album. Laughing in My Sleep is an impressive collection of 21 tracks, each unapologetic in their rejection of expectations.


Tobin Sprout Goes Americana on 'Empty Horses'

During the heyday of Guided By Voices, Tobin Sprout wasn't afraid to be absurd amongst all that fuzz. Sprout's new album, Empty Horses, is not the Tobin Sprout we know.


'All In: The Fight for Democracy' Spotlights America's Current Voting Restrictions as Jim Crow 2.0

Featuring an ebullient and combative Stacey Abrams, All In: The Fight for Democracy shows just how determined anti-democratic forces are to ensure that certain groups don't get access to the voting booth.


'Transgender Street Legend Vol. 2' Finds Left at London "At My Peak and Still Rising"

"[Pandemic lockdown] has been a detriment to many people's mental health," notes Nat Puff (aka Left at London) around her incendiary, politically-charged new album, "but goddamn it if I haven't been making some bops here and there!"


Daniel Romano's 'How Ill Thy World Is Ordered' Is His Ninth LP of 2020 and It's Glorious

No, this is isn't a typo. Daniel Romano's How Ill Thy World Is Ordered is his ninth full-length release of 2020, and it's a genre-busting thrill ride.


The Masonic Travelers Offer Stirring Rendition of "Rock My Soul" (premiere)

The Last Shall Be First: the JCR Records Story, Volume 1 captures the sacred soul of Memphis in the 1970s and features a wide range of largely forgotten artists waiting to be rediscovered. Hear the Masonic Travelers "Rock My Soul".

Collapse Expand Reviews

Collapse Expand Features

PM Picks
Collapse Expand Pm Picks

© 1999-2020 All rights reserved.
PopMatters is wholly independent, women-owned and operated.