Please donate to help save PopMatters. We are moving to WordPress in December out of necessity and need your help.

The Artists Pick the Best of 2012, Part 3

Six-string acoustic guitar © Zadorozhnyi Viktor. Image via

PopMatters is giving the artists a chance to play critic, asking them to let us in on the albums, songs, musical moments, and whatever else struck their fancy in 2012.

The end of the year is the one time on the music industry calendar when the critics take center stage, as best-of lists flood the Internet. While performers become either the objects of affection or the cause of disappointment each December, PopMatters is giving the artists a chance to play critic, asking them to let us in on the albums, songs, musical moments, and whatever else (President Obama's re-election, Mars Curiosity Rover, and the Oklahoma City Thunder, anyone?) that struck their fancy in 2012. What you’ll see is a broad range of favorites -- some echoing the critics, but many not -- as well as a good dose of holiday camaraderie among peers.


Amanda Palmer far as I'm concerned, 2012 was the "Year of the Great Piano-Songwriter-Weirdos putting out records like BAM BAM BAM all in a row."

Regina Spektor kicked it off in spring with What We Saw from the Cheap Seats, which ranks as my favorite Spektor outing since Soviet Kitsch. Even though she hasn't stipped down on the production totally, she stripped back, and that was enough to re-win me. I was an early Regina-Adopter -- she toured with the Dolls and all, and I fell in love with her solo piano sound. Every album after that...lost me a little more. This one manages to combine produced-Regina with old-skool batshit-Regina and get the alchemy right. SOLD! Standout track: "Oh Marcello". That opening piano riff, condensed to sound like it's coming out of a pasta-sauce-crusted 1941 kitchen-table-top radio in the kitchen of an insane Italian grandmother is just...perfection. LOOP IT! and BAM.

Then came Fiona Apple's new record. I've always been in awe of this lady. She be what she be. She also keeps winding up in my atmosphere, she got arrested for hash (wheee!) and has to cancel her Austin show the day after we played Austin; she just canceled a tour because she's going to say with her beloved, dying dog...and wrote a letter to her fans which reflected the inside of my soul, while I'm also dealing with a sick, sick friend and the collision of friendship and schedules. I found her first few albums harder to get into, but then I fell bam-flat in love with Extraordinary Machine. This new one The Idler Wheel yayayaayayayayaya might top that one -- the chick just knows how to write a song. This stripped-down format for her is just fucking perfect because the girl has WORDS and can WAIL, and as far as I'm concerned, anything that gets in the way of that can fuck right off. I wanna hear her sing her poems right in my face with a minimum of fanfare. Just a little boking on the piano serves me just fine. Standout track: "Every single night". Most Bizarre Earworm of the century. BAM.

Then Ben Folds released his epic "The Sound of the Life of the Mind". I wasn't totally nuts about Ben's last album Way to Normal, and I couldn't put my finger on why...I just wanted more Ben. I felt like he was being too silly and holding out on me. And then he sends THIS shit through the pipe. Holy fuck, the man is spilling some soul here, and it was like the antidote to everything I'd ever been missing from a Ben Folds album. I've been playing the song "Draw a Crowd" during my pre-show mix every night on tour for the crowd, and there's usually a bunch of Ben Folds devotees out there screaming along with the chorus, which has to be the most brilliant chorus EVER WRITTEN: "Ohhhh / If you're feeling small / And you can't draw a crowd / Draw dicks on a wall." How can you not just want to give Ben Folds the biggest high five ever? Other standout track: "Erase Me", in which Ben even goes a little cabaret and pounds the fuck out of his keys just like we like. BAM.

I'm also fond of the new piano-based Amanda Palmer & the Grand Theft Orchestra record Theatre Is Evil...but I'm not going to get all Fitty Cent on your ass. But still, that's four BAMS, if you trust that my album was also decent.



2013 will be the year of the lute

2012 was a big year for Amanda Palmer, making headlines for crowdsourcing over $1.2 million to help her create her latest album Theatre Is Evil. Palmer is one of PopMatters' Artists of the Year and Theatre Is Evil ranked #44 on PopMatters' list of best albums of 2012.


Peaking Lights

  • Flaming Tunes (Gareth Williams and Marie Currie) release on vinyl for the first time
  • Todd Terje, It's the Alps
  • Holger Czukay and U-She, La Premiere
  • Francis Bebey, African Electronic Music 1975-1982
  • Ariel Pink's Haunted Graffiti, Mature Themes
  • Thee Oh Sees, Putrifiers 2
  • Wet Hair, Spill into Atmosphere
  • Pharaohs, Island Time
  • Personal Space compilation on Chocolate Industries
  • Chris and Cosey live at the Villette Sonique festival in Paris
  • New Order live at Sonar fest in Barcelona

  • Peaking Lights released a new album Lucifer (Mexican Summer) in June 2012.


    Pearl and the Beard

    Emily Hope Price

    Top Songs

  • Lucius, "Don't Just Sit There"
  • Lady Lamb the Beekeeper, “Rooftop”
  • Franz Nicolay, featuring Emilyn Brodsky, “Take No Prisoners”
  • Ugly Purple Sweater, “Blue Crab”
  • You Won't, “Three Car Garage”
  • Anna Vogelzang, “Birdfeeders”
  • Anthony da Costa, “Don't Count Me Out”

  • Jeremy Styles

    Top Albums

  • You Won't, Skeptic Goodbye
  • Twin Shadow, Confess
  • Grizzly Bear, Shields
  • Lucius, Lucius EP

  • Jocelyn Mackenzie

    Top Albums

  • David Wax Museum, Knock Get Up
  • Dan Romer & Benh Zeitlin, Beasts of the Southern Wild soundtrack
  • Kimbra, Vows
  • They Might Be Giants, Join Us
  • Bobby Womack, The Bravest Man in the Universe

  • Pearl and the Beard released its Prodigal Daughter EP (Family Records) in March 2012.


    Francois Peglau

  • Dent May, Do Things: He is a pop genius

  • Django Django, Django Django: Talking Heads meets Devo

  • Los Saicos, Wild Teen Punk from Peru: From 1965, but rediscovered this year!

  • Edward Sharpe and the Magnetic Zeroes, Man on Fire: Better than the first album

  • Grimes, Visions: Hipster electro...loving it

  • Atlas Sound, Logos: From 2009, but discovered this year

  • Leonard Cohen, Old Ideas: Classic and good

  • Beach House, Bloom: Space pop

  • Kanaku y el Tigre, Caracoles: Peruvian folk

  • Deerhoof, Breakup Song: Is there anything more poppish and weird than Deerhoof?

    Francois Peglau came out with The Imminent Failure of Francois Peglau in 2011.


    Pomegranates' Isaac Karns

    Favorite Albums Released in 2012:

  • Caleb Groh, Bottomless Coffee
  • Beachwood Sparks, The Tarnished Gold
  • Michael Andrews, Spilling a Rainbow
  • Ben Burroughs, An Idea Kind of Person EP
  • Swans, The Seer
  • The Soil and the Sun, What Wonder Is the Universe
  • Damien Jurado, Maraqopa
  • Patrick Watson, Adventures in Your Own Backyard
  • Melody's Echo Chamber, Melody's Echo Chamber

  • Favorite Albums Discovered in 2012:

  • Bee Gees, Mr. Natural/Main Course
  • Godley and Crème, Consequences
  • 10cc, How Dare You
  • Willie Nelson, Rainbow Connection
  • AA Bondy, Believers
  • Charles Bradley, No Time for Dreamin'
  • Ryan Adams, Ashes and Fire
  • Blake Mills, Break Mirrors
  • Mercury Rev, Deserter's Songs
  • Emmylou Harris, Wrecking Ball
  • Junius, The Martyrdom of a Catastrophist
  • The War on Drugs, Slave Ambient

  • Favorite Books Read in 2012:

  • John Steinbeck, East of Eden
  • J.R.R. Tolkien, Return of the King
  • Stephen King, The Dark Tower IV: Wizard and Glass

  • Favorite Desserts of 2012:

  • Pecan Pie Milkshake at CookOut
  • Coconut Creme Pie at Neighbor's Cafe, Kansas City
  • Cinnamon Rolls at Holiday Inn Express

  • Pomegranates put out Heaven on Modern Outsider Records in June 2012.


    Matt Pond

    1. Angel Olsen, Half Way Home

    2. Melody's Echo Chamber, Melody's Echo Chamber

    3. Damon Albarn, Dr. Dee

    4. Sharon Van Etten, Tramp

    5. Chromatics, Kill for Love

    6. Niki and the Dove, Instinct

    7. The Mynabirds, Generals

    8. Spiritualized, Sweet Heart, Sweet Light

    9. The xx, Coexist

    10. King Tuff, King Tuff

    Matt Pond's upcoming album The Lives Inside the Lines of Your Hand (BMG) will come out on February 5, 2013.

    Next Page

    Please Donate to Help Save PopMatters

    PopMatters have been informed by our current technology provider that we have until December to move off their service. We are moving to WordPress and a new host, but we really need your help to fund the move and further development.





    © 1999-2020 PopMatters Media, Inc. All rights reserved. PopMatters is wholly independent, women-owned and operated.

    Collapse Expand Reviews

    Collapse Expand Features

    PM Picks
    Collapse Expand Pm Picks

    © 1999-2020 All rights reserved.
    PopMatters is wholly independent, women-owned and operated.