'Identity Thief' Struggles With Its Own Identity

Despite a solid trope and a topical premise, the story and characters aren’t quite sure what, or who, they want to be.

Identity Thief

Director: Seth Gordon
Cast: Jason Batemen, Melissa McCarthy, Jon Favreau, Amanda Peet, Tip 'T.I.' Harris, Genesis Rodriguez, Morris Chestnut, John Cho, Robert Patrick, Eric Stonestreet, Jonathan Banks
Distributor: Universal
Rated: R
Release date: 2013-06-04

There’s a rich tradition of comic films where two disparate individuals are thrown together by circumstance and then outcast geographically, socially, legally — or any combination thereof. Some of these manifest themselves as road films; John Hughes’ Planes, Trains and Automobiles (1987) is an example.

The recently released on DVD Identity Thief fits this genre. The story centers on Sandy Patterson (Jason Bateman), a trustworthy businessman and dedicated family man living in Denver. Patterson’s identity is stolen via phone fraud by Diana (Mellisa McCarthy), a con artist from Florida. With official investigations stymied by the intricacies of police jurisdictions, Patterson takes matters into his own hands by going to Florida to meet Diana, bring her back to Colorado and sort out the mess.

And what a mess it is.

Rather than providing a narrative through-line, the road trip construct in Identity Thief serves only as a loose framework on which to hang the subsequent collection of jokey set pieces. And unfortunately, none of the jokes are really all that funny. External complications in the form of a ruthless bounty hunter and a pair of mafia-like vengeance-seekers are additional seasonings thrown into a stew that just isn’t going to taste good no matter what’s put in it.

The characters are as uneven as the story. Although the exposition is dedicated to establishing the unshakable trustworthiness (Sandy) or relentless mendacity (Diana) of the central characters, those motivations shift where convenient to support the gag of the moment rather than the film as a whole.

Attempts to add depth to the characters through internal conflicts — Sandy’s vulnerability enhanced by his expected baby and recent job change, Diana’s compulsive defrauding traced to a lack of attachment in childhood — fall flat. Sandy’s shifting personality is difficult to follow, and Diana’s pathological lying is laid on so thickly that even when her character is meant to be telling the truth, it’s not very clear. It’s difficult to sympathize with such muddy characters.

That stands in sharp contrast to the aforementioned Planes, Trains and Automobiles. In that film, Neal Page (Steve Martin) simply wants to get home with as little hassle as possible; Del Griffith (John Candy) just wants a friend. Neal and Del are thrown together by circumstance, and while they do change over the course of the film, what we expect from each of them remains stable. Hughes’ Planes, Trains and Automobiles is simply a better script and a better story.

As Identity Thief clatters and bangs along, so many laws — both statutory and physical — are broken that the reality that exists within the framework of the film is difficult to grasp. Suspension of disbelief is pushed beyond its limits. For example, in the first reel, someone gets hit in the face with a guitar, with no resulting damage to person or instrument. It’s a minor detail, but in the course of the film, the physical gags get bigger and more ridiculous to the point Identity Thief starts to feel like a sweary, shorthanded Three Stooges or a lurid, live-action Looney Tunes. It raises the question whether Identity Thief may have been more successful as an animated feature film intended for an adult audience, à la South Park.

There are aspects of Identity Thief that do succeed, albeit on an industrial level. Specifically, the film is a decent résumé piece for its principals: Bateman, as the straight man, registers a level of annoyance at his predicament (or perhaps at the script, ahem) that further establishes his position as a Gen X Jack Lemmon; McCarthy flaunts her chops as a physical actor who is also capable of pulling off intensely emotional scenes. Playing a minor character, Eric Stonestreet (Modern Family) makes a scene-stealing appearance as a desperately over-the-top swinger wannabe. And much of the film shows off the U.S. state of Georgia’s versatility as a filming location.

Despite any success or failure on the part of the film, the home video edition of Identity Thief comprises quite a monument to the work. It contains both a DVD and a Blu-ray disc, plus a digital download and an Ultraviolet (cloud) copy. The discs feature an (unfunny) gag reel, a making-of featurette, another featurette about the actors’ interplay, alternate takes, and an unrated version of the film as well as the theatrical release. Sometimes it seems there is an inverse relationship between the achievement of a film and the degree to which it is commemorated in its home-video edition.

It must be said that the ambition and the idea behind Identity Thief are praiseworthy; the film takes a tried-and-true trope and attempts to rewrite it in light of something topical. But sadly, the final account contains insufficient funds.






Padma Lakshmi's 'Taste the Nation' Questions What, Exactly, Is American Food

Can food alone undo centuries of anti-immigrant policies that are ingrained in the fabric of the American nation? Padma Lakshmi's Taste the Nation certainly tries.


Performing Race in James Whale's 'Show Boat'

There's a song performed in James Whale's musical, Show Boat, wherein race is revealed as a set of variegated and contradictory performances, signals to others, a manner of being seen and a manner of remaining hidden, and it isn't "Old Man River".


The Greyboy Allstars Rise Up to Help America Come Together with 'Como De Allstars'

If America could come together as one nation under a groove, Karl Denson & the Greyboy Allstars would be leading candidates of musical unity with their funky new album, Como De Allstars.


The Beatles' 'Help!' Redefined How Personal Popular Music Could Be 55 Years Ago

Help! is the record on which the Beatles really started to investigate just how much they could get away with. The album was released 55 years ago this week, and it's the kick-off to our new "All Things Reconsidered" series.


Porridge Radio's Mercury Prize-Nominated 'Every Bad' Is a Wonderful Epistemological Nightmare

With Every Bad, Porridge Radio seduce us with the vulnerability and existential confusion of Dana Margolin's deathly beautiful lyricism interweaved with alluring pop melodies.


​​Beyoncé's 'Black Is King' Builds Identity From Afrofuturism

Beyoncé's Black Is King's reliance on Afrofuturism recuperates the film from Disney's clutches while reclaiming Black excellence.

Reading Pandemics

Colonial Pandemics and Indigenous Futurism in Louise Erdrich and Gerald Vizenor

From a non-Native perspective, COVID-19 may be experienced as an unexpected and unprecedented catastrophe. Yet from a Native perspective, this current catastrophe links to a longer history that is synonymous with European colonization.


John Fullbright Salutes Leon Russell with "If the Shoe Fits" (premiere + interview)

John Fullbright and other Tulsa musicians decamped to Leon Russell's defunct studio for a four-day session that's a tribute to Dwight Twilley, Hoyt Axton, the Gap Band and more. Hear Fullbright's take on Russell's "If The Shoe Fits".


Roots Rocker Webb Wilder Shares a "Night Without Love" (premiere + interview)

Veteran roots rocker Webb Wilder turns back the hands of time on an old favorite of his with "Night Without Love".


The 10 Best Films of Sir Alan Parker

Here are 10 reasons to mourn the passing of one of England's most interesting directors, Sir Alan Parker.


July Talk Transform on 'Pray for It'

On Pray for It, Canadian alt-poppers July Talk show they understand the complex dualities that make up our lives.


With 'Articulation' Rival Consoles Goes Back to the Drawing Board

London producer Rival Consoles uses unorthodox approaches on his latest record, Articulation, resulting in a stunning, beautiful collection.


Paranoia Goes Viral in 'She Dies Tomorrow'

Amy Seimetz's thriller, She Dies Tomorrow, is visually dazzling and pulsating with menace -- until the color fades.


MetalMatters: July 2020 - Back on Track

In a busy and exciting month for metal, Boris arrive in rejuvenated fashion, Imperial Triumphant continue to impress with their forward-thinking black metal, and death metal masters Defeated Sanity and Lantern return with a vengeance.


Isabel Wilkerson's 'Caste' Reveals the Other Kind of American Exceptionalism

By comparing the American race-based class system to that of India and Nazi Germany, Isabel Wilkerson makes us see a familiar evil in a different light with her latest work, Caste.


Anna Kerrigan Prioritizes Substance Over Style in 'Cowboys'

Anna Kerrigan talks with PopMatters about her latest film, Cowboys, which deviates from the common "issues style" approach to LGBTQ characters.


John Fusco and the X-Road Riders Get Funky with "It Takes a Man" (premiere + interview)

Screenwriter and musician John Fusco pens a soulful anti-street fighting man song, "It Takes a Man". "As a trained fighter, one of the greatest lessons I have ever learned is to walk away from a fight without letting ego get the best of you."


'Run-Out Groove' Shows the Dark Side of Capitol Records

Music promoter Dave Morrell's memoir, Run Out Groove, recalls the underbelly of the mainstream music industry.

Collapse Expand Reviews

Collapse Expand Features
PM Picks
Collapse Expand Pm Picks

© 1999-2020 All rights reserved.
PopMatters is wholly independent, women-owned and operated.