PopMatters is moving to WordPress. We will publish a few essays daily while we develop the new site. We hope the beta will be up sometime late next week.

Revisiting 'Dark Souls 2'

Erik Kersting

Is Dark Souls 2 as perfect as I once thought it was? Not quite.

Time has a way of changing one's opinions. A year and a half ago I reviewed Dark Souls 2, and I gave it a perfect 10. A few months after the review, I played through the game again, and even more recently, I started yet another run. Exploring the game's damp corridors, I couldn't help but ask myself, “Is this a perfect game?” Is it a good game? Positively. A great game? Probably. A perfect game? No.

I was undeniably hyped to play Dark Souls 2. Dark Souls is probably my favorite game, but in my excitement in playing Dark Souls 2, I too easily overlooked its flaws, which, once fully explored, reveal clearly how the lack of Hidetaka Miyazaki, director of Dark Souls and Bloodborne, lead to some small, but significant errors. These are errors that gnaw on the player and bring down the experience, especially upon replay.

Probably the most visible flaw revealed in revisiting Dark Souls 2 is the lack of tightness that is present in Dark Souls, from its combat, to its mechanics, to its story, to its map design. A clear example of this is evident when comparing the opening sequences of both games. Dark Souls begins with an overview of the world that the player is about to inhabit, introducing most of the major players and bosses that the player will fight later in the game. The player has a clear sense of his position in the world. He is small, maybe the chosen undead, but right now it looks like he is just another prisoner or mentally ill patient in the Undead Asylum.

Dark Souls 2’s opening cinematic is much more vague and ambiguous. Visually, nothing really makes sense in correlation with the loose plot established in it. The explanatory text describes what it is like to be cursed but gives the player no sense of direction or purpose. “None will have meaning,” a voice says, bemoaning your existence, though ultimately being “cursed” only has an effect on gameplay, but virtually none on the plot. Even the narrator pokes fun at this vagueness, saying: “But one day, you will stand before [the city’s] decrepit gate without really knowing why.” Right out of the gate, Dark Souls 2 feels like a directionless video game and the haze of its muddy exposition never really lifts.

Whether or not the player fully grasps it, Dark Souls generally provides clear direction to the player. The first NPC that the player meets after escaping the Undead Asylum tells that player exactly what to do, “Go ring the two bells.” After that, a gate opens and the player follows a fairly linear path through the City of Gods until being told to go get the four “Lord Souls”, which is where the game becomes similar to Dark Souls 2, in that the game lacks force in propelling the player to accomplish his goals.

The player is never given clear directions in Dark Souls 2. He is told to seek four “great souls” and “the king”, but generally, it is up to the player to explore and find his way through the world. While it's not too difficult to find where you are supposed to go, much as it is in the previous game, the player is really given few specifics on what tasks to complete. Instead, one wanders from place to place until finding a boss to fight. Ultimately, upon replay, this makes the game's early stages feel a bit sluggish by comparison to Dark Souls and Bloodborne, which are just as much open world and free roaming games as this sequel is, but the path towards the goal is made clearer in the other two titles.

The combat in Dark Souls 2 also suffers from this feeling of sluggishness. In what I assume is an attempt to emulate reality, dodging attacks feels especially unresponsive and difficult in a way that is based more on those controls than on creating challenging gameplay. One own weapons swing a little slower, and even enemies seem to struggle with their weapons sometimes in Dark Souls 2. Thus, even if the game itself isn't much longer in length than its predecessor, combat feels so much slower than it does in the first game. An hour in and it feels like more time has been spent than that, especially if the player is retreading areas again and again due to a difficult section or a difficult boss fight.

The mechanics of the game are more punishing but also less polished than its peers. Taking a page from Demon’s Souls, the player loses maximum health every time that they die, which can be solved if the player uses an item. The developers never really commit to this concept, though, giving the player an item that mostly negates this effect fairly early on. However, this can lead to a feeling of helplessness when the player has no way to get their health back to normal. In my opinion, there is enough punishment when the player loses virtually all of their money when they die (unless they can get it back with a bit of effort), so there is no reason to punish them further.

One of the strongest elements of Dark Souls is basically missing from Dark Souls 2, map continuity. In Dark Souls, the areas of the game are interlinked. The player may find a path from one place to another that they didn't imagine or can find a shortcut making their game easier. The interconnectedness of the map makes the world feel real and sensible. There is a feeling that if you see a castle, fortress, forest, etc. in the distance that you'll eventually be able to get there. But in Dark Souls 2, the map branches outwards from its starting area like spider legs, branches which often never meet.

A particularly awkward geographical location is the path to Iron Keep, which instead of feeling like it progresses logically, feels instead like four geographically disparate areas merged together. The player first proceeds through a forest, then a poisonous dune area called “Harvest Valley”, then through a windmill, and then into a lava filled fortress. What especially does not make sense is how the player rides a large elevator up from the windmill to get to Iron Keep. I guess that Iron Keep is in the clouds, but then why is lava not raining down around it? In the original Dark Souls, every location felt like it logically progressed to the next. Of course there would be a library near a castle. Of course there would be catacombs near a graveyard. But in Dark Souls 2, the areas feel more like set pieces loosely connected by elevators than they do like a reasonably geographically realistic world for the player to explore.

Dark Souls 2 also tries to offer quite a few nods to the content of Dark Souls with varying results. Sometimes it’s nice to see an old boss like Ornstein make his way into the game, but the amount of recycled content, especially in terms of weapons and armor, makes the game feel rather thin. Now I'm not saying that FromSoftware needed to make entirely new weapons, a sword is a sword, but many of the “unique” weapons are retreads of ones that have been seen before. In some instances, Dark Souls 2 tries to up the ante by providing moments in which the player must fight six “Belfry Gargoyles” who are virtually the same as the two gargoyles from Dark Souls. Yet, instead of feeling like improvements, these repeat boss fights feel uninspired, like the easiest thing that the developers could have done.

Ultimately, the loose way that Dark Souls 2 plays with the tropes of the Souls series damages it somewhat. While at times it nails the mood and tone that made Dark Souls a surprise hit, occasionally it feels more like a fan-made pastiche rather than it does like a true sequel. It's no surprise to me that Miyazaki is back on board for Dark Souls 3, and it wouldn't surprise me if the game plays and feels more like the first game than its direct predecessor does. While I don't regret giving the game a 10 (it was given based on how I felt at the time and also based on a single playthrough) and I would still give it a high score, a more careful reevaluation can reveal qualities easily missed on a first pass through it.

Please Donate to Help Save PopMatters

PopMatters have been informed by our current technology and hosting provider that we have less than a month, until November 6, to move PopMatters off their service or we will be shut down. We are moving to WordPress and a new host, but we really need your help to save the site.





Peter Guralnick's 'Looking to Get Lost' Is an Ode to the Pleasures of Writing About Music

Peter Guralnick's homage to writing about music, 'Looking to Get Lost', shows how good music writing gets the music into the readers' head.


In Praise of the Artifice in George Cukor's 'Sylvia Scarlett'

George Cukor's gender-bending Sylvia Scarlett proposes a heroine who learns nothing from her cross-gendered ordeal.


The Cure: Ranking the Albums From 13 to 1

Just about every Cure album is worth picking up, and even those ranked lowest boast worthwhile moments. Here are their albums, spanning 29 years, presented from worst to best.


The 20 Best Episodes of 'Star Trek: The Original Series'

This is a timeless list of 20 thrilling Star Trek episodes that delight, excite, and entertain, all the while exploring the deepest aspects of the human condition and questioning our place in the universe.


The 20 Best Tom Petty Songs

With today's release of Tom Petty's Wildflowers & All the Rest (Deluxe Edition), we're revisiting Petty's 20 best songs.

Joshua M. Miller

The 11 Greatest Hits From "Greatest Hits" Compilations

It's one of the strangest pop microcosms in history: singles released exclusively from Greatest Hits compilations. We rounded 'em up and ranked 'em to find out what is truly the greatest Greatest Hit of all.


When Punk Got the Funk

As punks were looking for some potential pathways out of the cul-de-sacs of their limited soundscapes, they saw in funk a way to expand the punk palette without sacrificing either their ethos or idea(l)s.


20 Hits of the '80s You Might Not Have Known Are Covers

There were many hit cover versions in the '80s, some of well-known originals, and some that fans may be surprised are covers.


The Reign of Kindo Discuss Why We're Truly "Better Off Together"

The Reign of Kindo's Joseph Secchiaroli delves deep into their latest single and future plans, as well as how COVID-19 has affected not only the band but America as a whole.


Tommy Siegel's Comic 'I Hope This Helps' Pokes at Social Media Addiction

Jukebox the Ghost's Tommy Siegel discusses his "500 Comics in 500 Days" project, which is now a new book, I Hope This Helps.


Kimm Rogers' "Lie" Is an Unapologetically Political Tune (premiere)

San Diego's Kimm Rogers taps into frustration with truth-masking on "Lie". "What I found most frustrating was that no one would utter the word 'lie'."


50 Years Ago B.B. King's 'Indianola Mississippi Seeds' Retooled R&B

B.B. King's passion for bringing the blues to a wider audience is in full flower on the landmark album, Indianola Mississippi Seeds.


Filmmaker Marlon Riggs Knew That Silence = Death

In turning the camera on himself, even in his most vulnerable moments as a sick and dying man, filmmaker and activist Marlon Riggs demonstrated the futility of divorcing the personal from the political. These films are available now on OVID TV.


The Human Animal in Natural Labitat: A Brief Study of the Outcast

The secluded island trope in films such as Cast Away and television shows such as Lost gives culture a chance to examine and explain the human animal in pristine, lab like, habitat conditions. Here is what we discover about Homo sapiens.


Bad Wires Release a Monster of a Debut with 'Politics of Attraction'

Power trio Bad Wires' debut Politics of Attraction is a mix of punk attitude, 1990s New York City noise, and more than a dollop of metal.


'Waiting Out the Storm' with Jeremy Ivey

On Waiting Out the Storm, Jeremy Ivey apologizes for present society's destruction of the environment and wonders if racism still exists in the future and whether people still get high and have mental health issues.


Matt Berninger Takes the Mic Solo on 'Serpentine Prison'

Serpentine Prison gives the National's baritone crooner Matt Berninger a chance to shine in the spotlight, even if it doesn't push him into totally new territory.


MetalMatters: The Best New Heavy Metal Albums of September 2020

Oceans of Slumber thrive with their progressive doom, grind legends Napalm Death make an explosive return, and Anna von Hausswolff's ambient record are just some of September's highlights.

Collapse Expand Reviews

Collapse Expand Features

PM Picks
Collapse Expand Pm Picks

© 1999-2020 PopMatters.com. All rights reserved.
PopMatters is wholly independent, women-owned and operated.