How might efforts to fathom suicide bombers' motives make them too much like their potential victims -- that is, everyone else -- and thus unmake the difference that defines everyone else?"
Paradise NowDirector: Hany Abu-Assad
Cast: Kais Nashef, Ali Suliman, Lubna Azabal, Amer Hlehel, Hiam Abbass
MPAA rating: PG-13
Studio: Warner Independent Pictures
First date: 2005
US DVD Release Date: 2006-03-21
It makes sense to consider suicide bombing from the perspective of survivors and victims' relatives. How to fathom what might motivate anyone to commit such atrocity? And more to the point for artists, how might such efforts at fathoming make bombers too much like their potential victims -- that is, everyone else -- and thus unmake the difference that defines everyone else? Paradise Now, released to extrasless DVD, looks at suicide bombing from this other, difficult perspective. Its focus on two Palestinians, best friends Said (Kais Nashef) and Khaled (Ali Suliman), shows them to be quiet, contemplative men, dedicated to a cause they think they believe in.
Approached separately, Said and Khaled spend their last nights with their families, unable to speak of their futures. They requested the assignment years ago, and feel honored to have it. Even better, they're directed to go together, as they had requested as well. Still, at the start of Paradise Now, the controversial Palestinian entry for 2005's Best Foreign Film Oscar, the friends are also sobered, even stunned at the news. The paradise they've been imagining for so many years is now just hours away. Long alienated in occupied Nablus on the West Bank, Said and Khaled accept the assignment with a mixture of anticipation and anxiety. Accompanied home for dinner by his "angel," or handler Jamal (Amer Hlehel), Said tells his mother (Hiam Abbass) he's headed for a new job in the morning, having finally gotten a work permit. She's happy for him, he lies to her all night.
Said has other questions roiling inside: he's recently become interested in Suha (Lubna Azabal), daughter of a famous martyr for Palestine and customer at the auto repair shop where Said and Khaled both work. Born in a refugee camp and troubled by his own father's conviction as a collaborator with the Israelis, Said is both impressed by Suha and intimidated by her.
Ironically, Suha's legacy is the one Said covets and hopes to win for his own family, whom he believes is shamed by his father's nefariousness (this even though, as his mother tries to explain, "Whatever your father did, he did it for us"). Suha feels very differently: her father is no hero to her. When, the night before his mission, Said drops by her house at four a.m. to "drop off" her car keys, she brings him inside for conversation. Here he reveals something about his trouble-making, proto-radical childhood, when he and his friends burned down a cinema in Nablus. "Why?" asks Suha, "What did the cinema do to you?" "Not the cinema," he explains, "Israel." Suha pushes him, asking him to name a favorite genre of movie; in response, he asks her which is the most "boring, like life."
Though he may not know it, Said's effort to hate his life is part of a broader effort, to imagine his death. To this end, he presses Suha to speak about her father, to hear her attest to her pride and devotion. She sees martyrdom in another way, however, and so establishes the film's anti-bomber "conscience," saying that her father left his family feeling only tragedy and unhappiness. Said can't believe this. It undercuts his very existence. "The occupation defines the resistance," he insists. The bomber to be sees himself as a victim: why else would he inflict such horrors on people he'll never know? The act is symbolic, a means to strike back, to proclaim resistance.
But Suha's protest, the alternative she embodies and the experience she represents, make Said think again about his decision. The next day, as he and Khaled prepare for their martyrdom, he keeps his mouth shut, but their separate tensions are visible -- as they're shaved and suited (the cover story is that they're on their way to a wedding in Tel Aviv), and strapped with explosive belts. They also pose for their posters (Khaled declares he wants his to be displayed prominently in the town center, to showcase his martyrdom) and record their martyr videos (in town, there's a brisk market for these as well as for collaborators' videos, a conjunction that unnerves Said). Their recording session -- posed with guns held aloft and reading from mission-exalting scripts -- goes briefly awry when the operator has to repair the camera. This means Khaled must go through his speech twice; in his second version, he succumbs to precious banality, offering shopping advice to his mother.
In this and other instances, Paradise Now underlines the absurd rituals of suicide missions, the ways that the perpetrators are induced into thinking that what they're doing is special, necessary and will, in time, help to change things. Indeed, their inspiration, local cell leader Abu-Karem (Ashraf Barhoum), promises them care for their families and everlasting respect by their community. Feeling emasculated by the occupation and immobilized by their lack of future, the young men have nothing to lose. And this, it seems is more a motivation than any specific religious zealotry. Said and Khaled see no options. They've been indoctrinated since birth to see paradise in the future they can choose, if only they believe and allow themselves to be directed.
It's these directors who provide, however briefly, the movie's most perversely compelling images. Apparently dispassionate, they make all arrangements and watch over their bombers -- closely in the hours before the deed -- to ensure smooth execution. When, at the hour of crossing over the border, something goes wrong and Said and Khaled are split up, the handlers are left to worry about their capture, and so, their own exposure. Abu-Karem is particularly cold, insinuating that if Khaled does not locate his friend soon enough, that Said will need to be "handled" with the organization's best interests in mind.
The movie concentrates its final hour on the pursuits of Said, by his friends and his handlers. But it is, in the end, Jamal's face that haunts you. While Said and Khaled speak frequently, discussing their choices, wondering about their rightness, Jamal remains quiet, only in place to help them complete their work -- and their lives -- as his work will continue, as he works through the apprehensions felt and questions raised by future bombers. Jamal, impassive, silent, relentless, helps to convince the bombers to continue. Without him, the system could not function.