Robert Blecker Wants Me Dead

In the documentary, Robert Blecker Wants Me Dead, New York Law School professor and well-known retributivist Blecker submits he can measure -- in his gut -- who deserves to die.

Robert Blecker Wants Me Dead

Director: Ted Schillinger
Cast: Robert Blecker, Daryl Holton
MPAA rating: N/A
Studio: Atlas Media Corp.
First date: 2008
US Release Date: 2009-02-27 (Limited release)

Why, asks Robert Blecker, does he support the death penalty? "Three words," he answers himself. "They deserve it."

The question is open, at least for a moment, as to who "they" are -- the victims seeking solace or "justice," or vengeance, or the villains, however motivated. For New York Law School professor and well-known retributivist Blecker, the deserving can be felt. One of the few academics who support capital punishment, he explains that he's frequently called on to testify before committees and panels investigating the morality and legality of such punishment. When he speaks to the New Jersey Death Penalty Commission, he explains the emotional basis of his belief. "I feel certain," he says. "It's not that I am certain, I feel certain to the core of my being that the death penalty [in certain cases] is an adequate moral response."

Blecker makes his case repeatedly in Ted Schilinger's documentary, Robert Blecker Wants Me Dead. The penalty should be applied only to "the worst of the worst," he says, and the "remote, remote possibility of executing an innocent person is the 'cost of doing business.'" This worries anti-death penalty attorney Robert Tabak, who submits that Blecker's "certainty" that he can know and measure the differences between criminals is unfounded. "The more he goes into this," Tabak says, "the more you can see that there's a lot of subjectivity, and the more you see that he thinks he can play God."

Blecker brings this subjectivity to bear on his relationship with Death Row inmate Daryl Holton. Convicted of killing his four children with an AK-47 in 1997, Holton is awaiting execution when Blecker meets him (his sentence is carried out in 2007, providing an uneasy conclusion -- really, more questions -- for the film). As they exchange letters and meet occasionally for interviews, the two men express a mix of curiosity respect, and sometimes, dislike for one another, debating the meaning and effect of the death penalty, focusing especially on moral and philosophical issues.

Holton, for his part, maintains that he murdered his children in order to save them from the awful life they were living in Murfreesboro, Tennessee, with their alcoholic mother, in a bad neighborhood. Sending them directly to heaven, Holton says, saved them a lifetime of suffering. His defense strategies (most conducted by him) range from confession to refusing appeals to rationalization to a suggestion by his lawyer that he is not of sound mind.

Blecker will have none of this, focusing on the prosecution's case that Holton killed the children -- and planned to kill hi ex-wife's boyfriend's young daughter as well as himself -- out of feelings of revenge. Because this motive -- along with the crime per se -- was heinous, Blecker feels that Holton deserves to die. And yet, even as he works to convince Holton of his wrongness, he also admires the man's intellect and engagement with the questions he puts to him. "As long as you continue to assert, at least implicitly, that you did the right thing, or at least to admit that what you did was the most horrendous, horrific, the worst mistake anyone could possibly make, and one that if the world were constructed and you had the opportunity to do it again, you never would do it, you aren't acknowledging the enormity of what you've done," Blecker tells Holton, "which means you're not taking responsibility."

The death penalty, for Blecker, is a means of taking responsibility -- for the criminal in need of moral reckoning, but also for the state -- the jurors included -- who, he says, should make decisions on behalf of victims. Beyond that, Blecker holds fast to the notion that his own feeling is an effective gauge of what crime deserves such punishment. "It is overtly emotional," he says of Holton, "I want him dead. That comes from my gut." (He recalls his parents as being more conventional liberals, who railed against Hitler and thought the Rosenbergs were wronged; "If they had given the secret of the bomb to Stalin," he pronounces, "They deserved to die.")

The film doesn't overtly argue with Blecker or take his side in any uncomplicated way. Holton appears in newspaper clippings and in courtroom footage as well as in an interview at the prison in Shelbyville, alternately polite and cartoonishly snide. Blecker reads their letters back and forth or offers his assessments of Holton while sitting in his cluttered office, the camera close on their word-processed or handwritten missives, Holton's marked by Blecker's notations.

Some of the film's imagery is obvious -- as legal or ethical experts opine on Blecker (ACLU president Nadine Strossen says, "His wanting his personal moral certainty to be reified in law, such that it trumps other people's contrary moral certainties, is to me rather authoritarian"), he appears literally walking along a median in traffic, riding his stationary bike amid boxes and file cabinets, salting his icy front walk. Yes his way is treacherous, but his thinking -- as he frames it -- is premised on feeling. He feels he is right and that makes it so.

Blecker's relationship with Holton is surely provocative and, for all its repetition and Blecker's effort to control his self-image, also indicative of the problems of making such a film. He speaks directly to Schillinger, who remains off camera: "We're both aware of the Heisenberg Effect, to what extent are things changing because we're documenting them?" Indeed -- how is Holton's response to Blecker altered by his audience? How is Blecker's self-performance informed by the fact of the camera? None of this is precisely measurable. And neither, it seems, are the feelings so fiercely articulated by both men.






PM Picks Playlist 1: Rett Madison, Folk Devils + More

The first PopMatters Picks Playlist column features searing Americana from Rett Madison, synthpop from Everything and Everybody, the stunning electropop of Jodie Nicholson, the return of post-punk's Folk Devils, and the glammy pop of Baby FuzZ.


David Lazar's 'Celeste Holm  Syndrome' Appreciates Hollywood's Unsung Character Actors

David Lazar's Celeste Holm Syndrome documents how character actor work is about scene-defining, not scene-stealing.


David Lord Salutes Collaborators With "Cloud Ear" (premiere)

David Lord teams with Jeff Parker (Tortoise) and Chad Taylor (Chicago Underground) for a new collection of sweeping, frequently meditative compositions. The results are jazz for a still-distant future that's still rooted in tradition.


Laraaji Takes a "Quiet Journey" (premiere +interview)

Afro Transcendentalist Laraaji prepares his second album of 2020, the meditative Moon Piano, recorded inside a Brooklyn church. The record is an example of what the artist refers to as "pulling music from the sky".


Blues' Johnny Ray Daniels Sings About "Somewhere to Lay My Head" (premiere)

Johnny Ray Daniels' "Somewhere to Lay My Head" is from new compilation that's a companion to a book detailing the work of artist/musician/folklorist Freeman Vines. Vines chronicles racism and injustice via his work.


The Band of Heathens Find That Life Keeps Getting 'Stranger'

The tracks on the Band of Heathens' Stranger are mostly fun, even when on serious topics, because what other choice is there? We all may have different ideas on how to deal with problems, but we are all in this together.


Landowner's 'Consultant' Is OCD-Post-Punk With Obsessive Precision

Landowner's Consultant has all the energy of a punk-rock record but none of the distorted power chords.


NYFF: 'American Utopia' Sets a Glorious Tone for Our Difficult Times

Spike Lee's crisp concert film of David Byrne's Broadway show, American Utopia, embraces the hopes and anxieties of the present moment.


South Africa's Phelimuncasi Thrill with Their Gqom Beats on '2013-2019'

A new Phelimuncasi anthology from Nyege Nyege Tapes introduces listeners to gqom and the dancefloors of Durban, South Africa.


Wolf Parade's 'Apologies to the Queen Mary' Turns 15

Wolf Parade's debut, Apologies to the Queen Mary, is an indie rock classic. It's a testament to how creative, vital, and exciting the indie rock scene felt in the 2000s.


What 'O Brother, Where Art Thou?' Gets Right (and Wrong) About America

Telling the tale of the cyclops through the lens of high and low culture, in O'Brother, Where Art Thou? the Coens hammer home a fatalistic criticism about the ways that commerce, violence, and cosmetic Christianity prevail in American society .


Literary Scholar Andrew H. Miller On Solitude As a Common Bond

Andrew H. Miller's On Not Being Someone Else considers how contemplating other possibilities for one's life is a way of creating meaning in the life one leads.


Fransancisco's "This Woman's Work" Cover Is Inspired By Heartache (premiere)

Indie-folk brothers Fransancisco dedicate their take on Kate Bush's "This Woman's Work" to all mothers who have lost a child.


Rodd Rathjen Discusses 'Buoyancy', His Film About Modern Slavery

Rodd Rathjen's directorial feature debut, Buoyancy, seeks to give a voice to the voiceless men and boys who are victims of slavery in Southeast Asia.


Hear the New, Classic Pop of the Parson Red Heads' "Turn Around" (premiere)

The Parson Red Heads' "Turn Around" is a pop tune, but pop as heard through ears more attuned to AM radio's glory days rather than streaming playlists and studio trickery.


Blitzen Trapper on the Afterlife, Schizophrenia, Civil Unrest and Our Place in the Cosmos

Influenced by the Tibetan Book of the Dead, Blitzen Trapper's new album Holy Smokes, Future Jokes plumbs the comedic horror of the human condition.

Love in the Time of Coronavirus

Fire in the Time of Coronavirus

If we venture out our front door we might inhale both a deadly virus and pinpoint flakes of ash. If we turn back in fear we may no longer have a door behind us.


Sufjan Stevens' 'The Ascension' Is Mostly Captivating

Even though Sufjan Stevens' The Ascension is sometimes too formulaic or trivial to linger, it's still a very good, enjoyable effort.

Jordan Blum

Collapse Expand Reviews

Collapse Expand Features

PM Picks
Collapse Expand Pm Picks

© 1999-2020 All rights reserved.
PopMatters is wholly independent, women-owned and operated.