'Adultery' Makes a Legal Argument With Clarity

Deborah L. Rhode examines infidelity in a variety of arenas; from the military to politics, from marriage to alternative lifestyles.

Adultery: Infidelity and The Law

Publisher: Harvard University Press
Length: 272 pages
Author: Deborah L. Rhode
Price: $28.95
Format: Hardcover
Publication date: 2016-03

In Adultery: Infidelity and the Law, Stanford law professor Deborah L. Rhode argues that the US should remove civil and criminal penalties for adultery. Rhode cites the infrequency and inconsistency with which current laws on the matter are enforced.

Moreover, she argues that these penalties are out of tune with current social values. She cites a “fundamental ambivalence” that is reflected in the presence of such laws. While society generally disapproves of marital infidelity, support for laws that enforce criminal penalties has decreased. She notes that many remained surprised by these laws, a matter that speaks, she writes, to the outmoded nature of such legal strictures. She adds, “Marriage as an instruction is worthy of public respect” while “criminalizing extramarital affairs is not the best way of supporting it.”

Open and polyamorous marriages suggest that American society acknowledges that there are instances in which infidelity can be a consensual act. Certain professional climates, although not openly encouraging this violation of marital vows, do little to stop its perpetuation. The military is one sector in which extra-marital fairs are tolerated while, at the same time, punishment for these affairs is not meted out equitably.

Moreover, not all forms of adultery are the same. We hold little empirical evidence about the man who engages in a single one-night stand or the woman who is a serial philanderer. What we do know is that those who attend regular religious services are less likely to look for sex outside the marriage and that age, class and gender play a role in the likelihood that a partner will commit adultery. Men are more likely candidates regardless of age, with the incidence of women seeking an extra-marital partner tapers at around age 50.

If infidelity is widely unacceptable, then why do partners look beyond their marriage for sex? The answer ranges between problems in a marriage (which may or may not be sexual in nature), while other answers vary from depression to revenge. The former is the most common, though Rhode adds that even relationships undergoing little or no turbulence are not immune. A one-night stand with a coworker can, in some instances, seem normal to the actors, a way to gain excitement or even self-esteem. The short answer is that we may never know the exact reasons any more than we can provide exacting evidence for why some marriages fail.

The personal consequences are myriad. While most affairs bring a sense of exhilaration, it can be-short lived. If the wrong is discovered by a partner or the person initiating the dalliance feels remorse, the devastation that ensues can be life-threatening. But some even report a renewed vigor and sense of boding in their long-term relationship. Others, of course, begin a new and sometimes lasting relationship with the person they sought outside their marriage.

Most couples report significant and last damage, however. Children and the wrong spouse often suffer the most on an emotional level, as might the new partner. Having committed adultery with a married woman or man brings its own stigmas and wreaks its own havoc on the unmarried partner, too.

What Rhode ultimately suggests is that one can survey the devastation infidelity creates but still argue against it playing a factor in custody, employment, military service and a range other arenas.

Rhode opens the body of the book with a discussion of legal perspectives. She writes that English common law in and up to the 17th Century adhered to a strict Biblical interpretation and definition of adultery, which essentially meant “intercourse by a married woman with a man other than her husband”. That law in and of itself implied an imbalance in punishment because a married man having sex with an unmarried woman “constituted the lesser offense of fornication”.

As strictures around the offense tightened during the time of Oliver Cromwell, adultery became a capital offense, though that punishment was reserved for cases that were “open and notorious”. If the actors in the affair carried on in such a way that their relationship became common knowledge and therefore was harmful to the greater institution of marriage and society as a whole, the punishment could then include death.

The reluctance of English courts to grant divorces remained a factor in infidelity well into the 19th century. In 1858 fewer than 300 divorces granted and only four of those to women, this is a curious fact given that the main acceptable factor in the granting of a divorce was an adulterous husband. There were, however, other avenues if one were wealthy, including ecclesiastical courts, which would grant a separation of bed and board, which would ultimately see the new couple living in a kind of open adultery. With royals allowed mistresses until the end of that century it became increasingly difficult for subjects not to feel as though there was a double standard at play.

Colonization in America offered its own set of complications, as it became a common practice for men to take on local mistresses. Much of the injustice in these laws is reflected in the law of the times, which held that women were the property of their husbands. In America, women could be punished by public beatings while men continued with fewer consequences. Men often had financial sovereignty and could therefore have the offense dismissed with the paying of a fine.

If those practices seem antiquated, they are but not by much. In the 20th Century, infidelity became a marker of poor moral character in the eyes of the law. Having an open record of infidelity could be used to deny citizenship, though a lack of clear definition allowed enough latitude for some courts to uphold this as part of their consideration in naturalization cases while others could entirely ignore it. The inconsistent nature and understanding of laws governing infidelity have upheld an “unwritten law” in America. This being that a man could murder his wife’s lover and feel assured that no conviction would result. To this day, juries are frequently more tolerant in how they convict men in such cases.

If the minutiae of the legal system in these matters can be daunting for the non-legal scholar, the simplest point to be made is this: A lack of consistency in the punishment of affairs makes its own argument that infidelity is largely a matter for which the personal and public consequences carry enough weight to be considered justice.

Today, infidelity plays a diminished role in divorce cases, though when it is a factor the punitive element remains inconsistent. An affair carried on after a couple has separated can bar alimony. Acts that do not include the sex act itself can be punished as though infidelity actually occurred which can, in many cases, have devastating consequences on the family.

With the professional world sometimes being a stage for infidelity, Rhode examines extra-marital affairs among those enlisted in the military. There, extended periods of time spent away from a spouse, and a climate that tolerates without entirely condoning extra-marital affairs, has perpetuated the presence of infidelity. Just as in the civilian world, in the military, there is no uniform way of dealing with the infraction.

Most notably, gender appears to play large role in the perceived inequality with how the service deals with infidelity. Rhode writes of Lieutenant Commander Syneeda Penland who was court-martialed in 2008 and convicted of conduct unbecoming after an affair with an unmarried partner. Penland lost severance pay, health benefits and her military pension in a climate where court-martials are rare among enlisted men. It's an issue that the notoriously conservative military must grapple with as much as the civilian sphere.

Adding to her notion that laws governing extra-marital affairs is her discussion of alternative lifestyles. Open marriages and “swingers” provide a landscape where this behavior is tolerated and encouraged. Moreover, some couples report benefits to their marriage and a deeper sense of self-awareness. Equally notable is that people engaged in these lifestyles rarely fit the image we hold of swingers. They are often conservative, church going and satisfied with their lives in and outside their unions.

Adding to the notion that the court of public opinion can be the most telling in deciding these cases, she points to notorious womanizers in the political sphere. She examines President Bill Clinton’s dalliances in close detail. Some hold an image of him as a serial philanderer, but were reluctant to support his impeachment. She notes that elected officials in similar positions of power in other nations carry on sex scandals in ways that are less concealed and, ultimately, more tolerated. Public opinion seems to be that harm done to marriages or long-standing relationships becomes a matter for the couple(s) to resolve and that so long as the public is not directly impacted, punishment and discussion of the matter should not be prolonged.

But the court of public opinion can be equally fickle. Clinton has emerged from his scandal with some semblance of his image and dignity intact. Others have not fared so well. Gary Hart, a onetime presidential candidate, banked on Clinton's affair with Jennifer Flowers remaining a matter of personal interest. His perceived arrogance in the matter ruined his political career, as the affair has overshadowed much of the political good he may have done.

Clinton, on the other hand, received his penance in public and although remained somewhat defiant, found sympathizers because of his natural charisma and the perceived good he had done as President. Arrogance, Rhode writes, was also a factor in the downfalls of John Edwards and Eliot Spitzer, while John F. Kennedy’s ability to massage the public’s image of him has rendered his open and egregious displays of extra-marital liaisons almost anecdotal.

Female candidates are less prone to sex scandals because, Rhode writes, they exist in a climate where double standards about infidelity are more intense and the resulting fallout is much more likely to damage their careers than the careers of male counterparts.

Rhode concludes that criminal prohibitions on infidelity should be repealed, along with the abolition of civil damages related to it. The military should follow the civilian courts and adultery should be less a consideration in financial or custody award made by courts. If monogamy itself, she adds, is its own rich and fulfilling reward, then the courts have little to worry about. T he consensual sexual conduct of citizens can remain a matter of their own concern.

Adultery offers its challenges for those outside the realm of legal history: The patient terms in which Rhode outlines legal cases and their outcomes could read as esoteric and even inaccessible. For those fascinated by the history of this common but largely intolerable act, the volume is thorough and contributes to an argument that no doubt will continue for some time to come.


From genre-busting electronic music to new highs in the ever-evolving R&B scene, from hip-hop and Americana to rock and pop, 2017's music scenes bestowed an embarrassment of riches upon us.

60. White Hills - Stop Mute Defeat (Thrill Jockey)

White Hills epic '80s callback Stop Mute Defeat is a determined march against encroaching imperial darkness; their eyes boring into the shadows for danger but they're aware that blinding lights can kill and distort truth. From "Overlord's" dark stomp casting nets for totalitarian warnings to "Attack Mode", which roars in with the tribal certainty that we can survive the madness if we keep our wits, the record is a true and timely win for Dave W. and Ego Sensation. Martin Bisi and the poster band's mysterious but relevant cool make a great team and deliver one of their least psych yet most mind destroying records to date. Much like the first time you heard Joy Division or early Pigface, for example, you'll experience being startled at first before becoming addicted to the band's unique microcosm of dystopia that is simultaneously corrupting and seducing your ears. - Morgan Y. Evans

Keep reading... Show less

Electronic music is one of the broadest-reaching genres by design, and 2017 highlights that as well as any other year on record. These are the 20 best albums.

20. Vitalic - Voyager (Citizen)

Pascal Arbez-Nicolas (a.k.a. Vitalic) made waves in the French Touch electro-house scene with his 2005 debut, OK Cowboy, which had a hard-hitting maximalist sound, but several albums later, Voyager finds him launching into realms beyond at his own speed. The quirky, wallflower vocals and guitar snippets employed throughout Voyager drop a funk that brings to mind WhoMadeWho or Matthew Dear if they had disco-pop injected between their toes. "Levitation" is as pure a slice of dance floor motivation as theoretically possible, a sci-fi gunfight with a cracking house beat sure to please his oldest fans, yet the album-as-form is equally effective in its more contemplative moments, like when Miss Kitten's vocals bring an ethereal dispassion to "Hans Is Driving" to balance out its somber vocoder or the heartfelt cover of "Don't Leave Me Now" by Supertramp. Voyager may infect you with a futuristic form of Saturday Night Fever, but afterwards, it gives you a hearty dose of aural acetaminophen to break it. - Alan Ranta

19. Antwood: Sponsored Content (Planet Mu)

Sponsored Content is a noisy, chaotic, occasionally beautiful work with a dark sense of humor that's frequently deployed to get Antwood's point across. For instance, throughout the aforementioned "Disable Ad Blocker", which sounds mostly like the creepy side of Tangerine Dream's early '80s experimental output, distorted slogans and recognizable themes worm their way into the mix. "I'm Loving It", we hear at one point, the Sony PlayStation startup music at another. And then there's a ten-second clip of what sounds like someone getting killed in a horror movie. What is there to make of the coexistence of those sorts of samples? Probably nothing explicit, just the uneasiness of benign and instantly-recognizable brand content in the midst of harsh, difficult art. Perhaps quality must to some extent be tied to sponsorship. That Antwood can make this point amidst blasts and washes of experimental electronic mayhem is quite the achievement. - Mike Schiller

18. Bonobo - Migration (Ninja Tune)

Although Bonobo, a.k.a. Simon Green, has been vocal in the past about not making personality driven music, Migration is, in many respects, a classic sounding Bonobo record. Green continues to build sonic collages out of chirping synths, jazz-influenced drums, sweeping strings and light touches of piano but on Migration sounds more confident than ever. He has an ability to tap into the emotions like few others such as on the gorgeous "Break Apart" and the more percussive "Surface". However, Bonobo also works to broaden his sound. The electro-classical instrumental "Second Sun" floats along wistfully, sounding like it could have fit snugly onto a Erased Tapes compilation, while the precise and intricate "Grains" shows the more intimate and reflective side of his work. On the flipside, the higher tempo, beat driven tracks such as "Outlier" and "Kerala" perfectly exhibit his understanding of what works on the dance floor while on "Bambro Koyo Ganda" he even weaves North African rhythms into the fabric. Migration is a multifaceted album full of personality and all the better for it. - Paul Carr

17. Kiasmos - Blurred EP (Erased Tapes)

The Icelandic duo of Olafur Arnalds and Janus Rasmussen, aka Kiasmos, is a perfect example of a pair of artists coming from two very different musical backgrounds, finding an unmistakable common ground to create something genuinely distinctive. Arnalds, more known for his minimal piano and string work, and Rasmussen, approaching from a more electropop direction, have successfully explored the middle ground between their different musical approaches and in doing so crafted affecting minimalist electronic music. Blurred is one of the most emotionally engaging electronic releases of the year. The duo is working from a refined and bright sonic palette as they consummately layer fine, measured sounds together. It is an intricate yet unforced and natural sounding set of songs with every song allowed room to bloom gradually. - Paul Carr

16. Ellen Allien - Nost (BPitch Control)

BPitch boss and longtime lynchpin of the DJ scene in Berlin, Ellen Allien's seven full-length releases show an artist constantly reinventing herself. Case in point, her 2013 offering, LISm, was a largely beat-less ambient work designed to accompany an artsy dance piece, while its follow-up, 2017's Nost, is a hardcore techno journey, spiritually born in the nightclubs and warehouses of the early '90s. It boasts nine straight techno bangers, beautifully minimalist arrangements with haunting vocals snippets and ever propulsive beats, all of which harken back to a hallowed, golden, mostly-imagined age when electronic music was still very much underground, and seemingly anything was possible. - Alan Ranta

It's just past noon on a Tuesday, somewhere in Massachusetts and Eric Earley sounds tired.

Since 2003, Earley's band, Blitzen Trapper, have combined folk, rock and whatever else is lying around to create music that manages to be both enigmatic and accessible. Since their breakthrough album Furr released in 2008 on Sub Pop, the band has achieved critical acclaim and moderate success, but they're still some distance away from enjoying the champagne lifestyle.

Keep reading... Show less

Aaron Sorkin's real-life twister about Molly Bloom, an Olympic skier turned high-stakes poker wrangler, is scorchingly fun but never takes its heroine as seriously as the men.

Chances are, we will never see a heartwarming Aaron Sorkin movie about somebody with a learning disability or severe handicap they had to overcome. This is for the best. The most caffeinated major American screenwriter, Sorkin only seems to find his voice when inhabiting a frantically energetic persona whose thoughts outrun their ability to verbalize and emote them. The start of his latest movie, Molly's Game, is so resolutely Sorkin-esque that it's almost a self-parody. Only this time, like most of his better work, it's based on a true story.

Keep reading... Show less

There's something characteristically English about the Royal Society, whereby strangers gather under the aegis of some shared interest to read, study, and form friendships and in which they are implicitly agreed to exist insulated and apart from political differences.

There is an amusing detail in The Curious World of Samuel Pepys and John Evelyn that is emblematic of the kind of intellectual passions that animated the educated elite of late 17th-century England. We learn that Henry Oldenburg, the first secretary of the Royal Society, had for many years carried on a bitter dispute with Robert Hooke, one of the great polymaths of the era whose name still appears to students of physics and biology. Was the root of their quarrel a personality clash, was it over money or property, over love, ego, values? Something simple and recognizable? The precise source of their conflict was none of the above exactly but is nevertheless revealing of a specific early modern English context: They were in dispute, Margaret Willes writes, "over the development of the balance-spring regulator watch mechanism."

Keep reading... Show less
Pop Ten
Mixed Media
PM Picks

© 1999-2017 All rights reserved.
Popmatters is wholly independently owned and operated.