Caravaggio May Be the Least Documented Yet Most Constructed Renaissance Artist

Caravaggio and the Creation of Modernity draws attention to both the skill of the historian and the enduring and towering genius of the artist.

Caravaggio and the Creation of Modernity

Publisher: Reaktion
Length: 271 pages
Author: Troy Thomas
Price: $22.50
Format: Hardcover
Publication date: 2016-10

Caravaggio and the Creation of Modernity is a splashy title that implies, at least, some degree of calculated passage and delivery into a new age from the mind and hands of the artist. Certainly, Caravaggio is an attractive subject for historians who are, we might say, promiscuous in their habit of discovering an image of themselves or their specialty -- whether Marxist, modernist, critical theorist or otherwise -- reflected in their historical subject matter.

Where Caravaggio is concerned, this is partly a function of the fleetingness of his career and the mystery around his life and character. Between around 1595 until 1610 he flickered in and out of existence like a ghost and left behind only a trail of art to speak on his behalf. He's probably the least documented Renaissance artist that still captures the imagination of the public and as a result probably the most "constructed" of them.

It is with relief, then, that Troy Thomas avoids the anachronistic trap of interpreting the 17th century artist in light of only present-day concerns and categories. Caravaggio and the Creation of Modernity is carefully designed as a forceful and concise statement on the artist's innovations. Thomas's objective is not to capture the milieu in which Caravaggio lived and worked in great social or economic detail, nor even so much to capture Caravaggio himself. He is even careful about the appearance of causal links between Caravaggio's art and the large-scale, long-term, and broad conjunctures culminating in the modern condition. "In creating a new kind of art around 1600," he writes in the Introduction, "Caravaggio went further than any previous painter in establishing characteristics that are today recognized as modern."

In the Conclusion such characteristics are again described as foundational to modernity but are also at the same time "rooted in" Caravaggio's cultural moment. He may or may not have caused the modern age to happen. But he will certainly be understood on his terms to the extent that that is possible, and as reflecting both early modern and modern characteristics.

So Thomas's key aim is to reveal the innovative qualities of Caravaggio's works. But he's also concerned with, and does a great deal of justice to, those elements of Caravaggio's works that belong more firmly to a cultural moment at the turn of the 17th century. There are subtle meanings an early modern Christian observer would read off his scenes of divine revelation, or of his depictions of poor people, or his uses of light that are likely to be lost on a modern observer. Thomas holds both the modern and the early modern perspectives in balance.

He proposes a definition of modernity and analyses each component of it as they relate to Caravaggio's works, chapter-by-chapter, and proceeds in a roughly chronological manner. The main categories that are taken as "quintessentially modern" in Caravaggio include self-consciousness, self-reflection, introspection, experimentation, social awareness, ambiguity, individualism, and loss of certainty. Thomas stresses the "far-reaching and foundational" nature of ambiguity in Caravaggio's works and it overlaps throughout, in one way or another, with all other of his categories of modernism.

Caravaggio's depictions of poor people, for example, possibly arises out of a social awareness cultivated by the poverty he experienced until the 1590s. The meaning of such depictions is deeply ambiguous. Caravaggio showed the low, humble, and ignorant exactly how they appeared to him; tattered clothing, holes in coats, dirty fingernails, soiled feet. As worshippers, they are crowded together helplessly before St. Dominic and the Virgin, clutching their rosaries. As innkeepers, servants, and workers --- like penitent Mary Magdelen is shown sitting alone in ordinary 16th century dress next to her broken pearls, head bowed in a forlorn countenance. It captures a sacred text but could just as easily be a secular portrait of a troubled young woman with whom we are invited by Caravaggio to empathize. The painting conveys another layer of meaning when we learn that it was well known at the time that Caravaggio employed local prostitutes as models, and one Anna Bianchini is likely to have modeled here as the Magdalen, and on other occasions, for Caravaggio. It is in any case far from traditional classical depictions of the Magdalen in which she appears sensuous and semi-nude. Caravaggio thus reinvents a sacred text as a living, human drama.

Caravaggio extended this approach to his depictions of saints and Apostles. A striking example is his first version of the Inspiration of St. Matthew in which the Apostle is shown as an illiterate peasant, shocked and confused, struggling to compose the Gospel despite divine help. Matthew is here less decisive and authoritative, more a "dullard", to use Thomas's term; more likely to evince pity than reverence.

From one point of view, depicting an Apostle as a simple person utterly unprepared to receive divine communication has the effect of heightening the sense that the divine realm is foreign from the earthly realm. From another, the sentiment resembles certain Protestant theologies -- the later English Quakers, for example, would believe that the holy spirit speaks to all individuals equally, to Pope and to pauper, in the very same manner. Such an interpretation was probably not intended by Caravaggio. But it might not have been lost on an astute Counter-Reformation observer, and it nevertheless highlights the ambiguous qualities inhering in his works.

Tellingly, Caravaggio's first piece on St. Matthew was rejected by the Contarelli Chapel in Rome for either the indecorousness of the depiction, the excessiveness of its realism, or the ambiguity of its message. The potential for negative responses is clear and Thomas shows that it was not lost on Caravaggio's 17th century critics. One disliked him for his predilection for "filth and deformity". Another dismissed him and his "dirty prostitute from the Ortaccio".

There's much more to say about this excellent book and Thomas offers daring interpretations on almost every page. Some are far-fetched. In the Martyrdom of St. Matthew, does the Apostle seem to reject the outstretched hand of an angel during the moment of his execution? Probably not, but a reasonable seeker of the truth might make the case.

Others are more plausible. Caravaggio's famous use of dramatic lighting (tenebrism), for instance, is well known to have had a deep influence on the course of modern visual art. But modern observers might be less aware of the philosophical ideas that inspired it, and Thomas suggests one potential origin in Neoplatonic theories of light. For the Neoplatonists, humankind in its fallen condition resides in a lower darker order on earth, alienated from God, the source of all light. This dynamic is dramatized by Caravaggio on canvasses filled with heaving and oppressive darkness, pierced by mysterious and merciful shafts of light. Moments such as these underline both Thomas's skill as a historian and Caravaggio's towering genius.





The Kinks and Their Bad-Mannered English Decency

Mark Doyles biography of the Kinks might complement a seminar in British culture. Its tone and research prove its intent to articulate social critique through music for the masses.


ONO Confronts American Racial Oppression with the Incendiary 'Red Summer'

Decades after their initial formation, legendary experimentalists ONO have made an album that's topical, vital, uncomfortable, and cathartic. Red Summer is an essential documentation of the ugliness and oppression of the United States.


Silent Women Filmmakers No Longer So Silent: Alice Guy Blaché and Julia Crawford Ivers

The works of silent filmmakers Alice Guy Blaché and Julia Crawford Ivers were at risk of being forever lost. Kino Lorber offers their works on Blu-Ray. Three cheers for film historians and film restoration.


Rush's 'Permanent Waves' Endures with Faultless Commercial Complexity

Forty years later, Rush's ability to strike a nearly perfect balance between mainstream invitingness and exclusory complexity is even more evident and remarkable. The progressive rock classic, Permanent Waves, is celebrating its 40th anniversary.


Drum Machines? Samples? Brendan Benson Gets Contemporary with 'Dear Life'

Powerpop overlord and part-time Raconteur, Brendan Benson, grafts hip-hop beats to guitar pop on his seventh solo album, Dear Life.


'Sell You Everything' Brings to Light Buzzcocks '1991 Demo LP' That Passed Under-the-Radar

Cherry Red Records' new box-set issued in memory of Pete Shelley gathers together the entire post-reunion output of the legendary Buzzcocks. Across the next week, PopMatters explores the set album-by-album. First up is The 1991 Demo LP.


10 Key Tracks From the British Synthpop Boom of 1980

It's 40 years since the first explosion of electronic songs revitalized the UK charts with futuristic subject matter, DIY aesthetics, and occasionally pompous lyrics. To celebrate, here's a chronological list of those Moog-infused tracks of 1980 that had the biggest impact.

Reading Pandemics

Poe, Pandemic, and Underlying Conditions

To read Edgar Allan Poe in the time of pandemic, we need to appreciate a very different aspect of his perspective—not that of a mimetic artist but of the political economist.


'Yours, Jean' Is a Perfect Mixture of Tragedy, Repressed Desire, and Poor Impulse Control

Lee Martin's Yours, Jean is a perfectly balanced and heartbreaking mix of true crime narrative and literary fiction.


The 60 Best Albums of 2007

From tech house to Radiohead and Americana to indie and everything in between, the 60 best albums of 2007 included many of the 2000s' best albums.

Love in the Time of Coronavirus

Solitude Stands in the Window: Thoreau's 'Walden'

Henry David Thoreau's Walden as a 19th century model for 21st century COVID-19 quarantine.

Love in the Time of Coronavirus

Will COVID-19 Kill Movie Theaters?

Streaming services and large TV screens have really hurt movie theaters and now the coronavirus pandemic has shuttered multiplexes and arthouses. The author of The Perils of Moviegoing in America, however, is optimistic.

Gary D. Rhodes, Ph.D
Collapse Expand Reviews

Collapse Expand Features
PM Picks
Collapse Expand Pm Picks

© 1999-2020 All rights reserved.
PopMatters is wholly independent, women-owned and operated.